Lou Anarumo’s first two games running the Indianapolis Colts defense have gone so badly that the numbers are already in historic territory.
Through Week 2, Indianapolis has given up 1,029 yards, a staggering total that sits among the biggest marks the NFL has ever seen. It also wipes out the Colts’ previous franchise high. That old benchmark looked ugly enough on its own, but this group has blown past it.
The comparison that jumps off the page is the 1976 Seattle Seahawks, who allowed 884 yards. That was Seattle’s first season as a franchise. Indianapolis and Anarumo do not have that kind of expansion-team excuse.
The damage has shown up in familiar places, too. In Week 2, Kansas City Chiefs tight end Travis Kelce grabbed nine passes for 101 yards, his most since October 2023. At times, Kelce looked like he had a cushion to work with on every catch, taking short throws, turning upfield, and running before anyone could get a hand on him.
At this point, the bigger question is whether anyone should be surprised. Anarumo is in his ninth season as an NFL defensive coordinator, and only once - with the 2022 Cincinnati Bengals - has one of his units finished in the top half of the league in both yards allowed and points surrendered. Even that Bengals defense was just 16th in yards allowed.
That kind of sample size makes it hard to blame the players alone. The common thread keeps pointing back to Anarumo.
The Colts have been torched in both games, giving up more than 500 yards in each one. Over those two weeks, they have allowed 74 points. That’s the kind of production that sinks games before the fourth quarter even gets interesting.
Player development has not offered much comfort either. Defensive end Jaylahn Tuimoloau, a 2025 second-round pick, has not produced anything notable. And while general manager Chris Ballard has praised this year’s second-round selection, linebacker CJ Allen, and said Allen would be the green dot on defense from the start of his career, Allen has barely been on the field.
Indianapolis has pointed to injuries as part of the explanation for Allen’s slow start, but his missed practices all came before mid-August. Rookie safety AJ Haulcy has missed more practices, all since mid-August, and still has played plenty. Allen, after being a healthy scratch in Week 1, logged only six snaps in Week 2.
There also isn’t an obvious sign that the unit is about to turn the corner. Cornerbacks Charvarius Ward and Sauce Gardner were banged up in Week 2, but neither missed the game and both played most of it, just as they did in Week 1. DeForest Buckner has also been out there, and he has been pretty good.
The bottom line is hard to ignore: the numbers do not support the idea that Anarumo is delivering strong work as a defensive coordinator. Shane Steichen and Ballard need to get the Colts into the playoffs or risk losing their own jobs, and right now Anarumo’s defense is putting the organization on a path toward major changes after the season.
In Other News...
Colts Fans Wont Love What Mahomes Said After That Overtime Call
The Colts left Kansas City with a 33-30 overtime loss that will linger, and not just because Harrison Butker ended it with a final field goal. The game swung on a crucial fumble call against Indianapolis that was overturned after replay review, a ruling that changed the tone of the night and gave the Chiefs a break they needed as Patrick Mahomes kept the offense moving.
Mahomes certainly noticed the break, and he did not try to hide how much it helped. After the game, he addressed the reversal with relief and a little humor, a reaction that Colts fans probably wont appreciate given how much that sequence shaped the outcome. On the field, he was sharp enough to capitalize, finishing 32 of 47 for 382 yards and three touchdowns to help Kansas City escape with the win. [Read more 🡒]
Mahomes Weighed In On The Colts Call Everyone Is Arguing About
The overtime sequence between the Chiefs and Colts had enough drama on its own, but Patrick Mahomes added another layer afterward by weighing in on the officiating decision that had plenty of people talking. The Chiefs quarterback said he was relieved the play was not ruled a fumble against Kansas City, knowing full well how quickly a controversial call can take over the conversation once fans get on social media.
Mahomes also pointed to the bigger issue any time a game ends with a disputed judgment call: teams still have to settle it on the field. For the Colts, that leaves the frustration of a heated moment hanging around longer than they would like, especially in a game that turned on a decision everyone seemed to have an opinion about. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Were Nearly Burned By A Brutal Overtime Rules Mistake
The Colts came dangerously close to turning a routine overtime coin toss into a self-inflicted mess before the extra period even began. Captain Cam Bynum initially said defer, a choice that is not available in overtime, and the moment briefly gave Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs a chance to press their case with the referee before the situation was sorted out.
In the end, the ref went back to Bynum to clarify the decision, and the Colts settled on starting on defense, which meant kicking off to begin overtime. Mahomes later acknowledged he was trying to take advantage of the miscue, a small but telling reminder that in the NFL, even the rules at the coin toss can become part of the strategy. [Read more 🡒]