The Indianapolis Colts might be gearing up for some significant moves in the next free-agent market. As the dust settles from this year's NFL free agency frenzy, the league's focus is shifting toward the upcoming NFL Draft.
The Colts have been active players early in the new league year, but what about next year? Let's dive into some key players who might be on the market.
Jonathan Taylor: The Workhorse
Jonathan Taylor has established himself as one of the NFL's elite running backs. With a combination of power, vision, and explosive speed, he's a force to be reckoned with.
Last season, Taylor led the league with 323 carries and 18 rushing touchdowns, amassing 1,585 rushing yards, which ranked third overall. His ability to contribute in the passing game, with 46 receptions in 2025, adds to his versatility.
Taylor's coming off one of his most productive seasons, with career-highs in total touches and yards from scrimmage. As the Colts push for success in 2026, Taylor's performance will be crucial.
Remember the contract stalemate and ankle issues from 2023? Those are in the rearview mirror, but they highlight the importance of securing Taylor's future with the team.
Quenton Nelson: The Anchor
Quenton Nelson continues to be a cornerstone of the Colts' offensive line. His aggressive play and high-level performance make him an ideal fit for any team.
Last season, his pass block win rate was an impressive 95.5%, ranking seventh among guards. Nelson's ability to dominate in the run game further cements his status as one of the best.
Nelson's future with the Colts seems secure. He's already one of the franchise's most accomplished players, and extending his contract could reset the market for guards once again. The Colts recognize his value, and securing him long-term could also provide some much-needed salary cap relief.
DeForest Buckner: The Enigma
DeForest Buckner's situation is a bit more complex. While his sack totals and pass rush win rate have dipped recently, his physical attributes and versatility make him valuable across various defensive schemes. Standing at 6-foot-7 and weighing 295 pounds, Buckner's presence is undeniable.
However, injuries have been a concern. Buckner dealt with a herniated disc in his neck last season, which required surgery.
As he returns to the field at 32, questions about his performance and future contracts linger. His health and play this season will be critical in determining his next steps.
As the Colts navigate these potential free-agent scenarios, the decisions made will shape the team's trajectory. With key players like Taylor, Nelson, and Buckner potentially hitting the market, the Colts' front office has some big choices ahead.