Colts Face One Huge Jonathan Taylor Question This Season

The Colts are strategizing to lighten Jonathan Taylor's load in an effort to maintain his health and extend his performance longevity.

The Colts don’t sound eager to keep Jonathan Taylor on the same punishing track forever.

Taylor has been one of the league’s heaviest-used backs, and only two running backs in the NFL have topped 300 carries in each of the last two seasons. Indianapolis, though, would clearly like to see that streak stop there. The reason isn’t performance - Taylor has been excellent, piling up 3,016 yards and 29 touchdowns on 626 carries - but the wear and tear that comes with that kind of load.

Running backs coach DeAndre Smith said the team wants to ease some of that burden and keep Taylor fresher over the course of games and the season.

“We definitely need to find ways to take some of that workload off him,” Smith said, via Stephen Holder of ESPN.com. “If I can find another guy or two that can take some of those carries off, he’s just going to be that much better.

So, it’s definitely been a constant conversation. I’m aware of it.

When he’s healthy, we’ve got a chance to win every game. So, that’s always the first thing I think about: making sure he’s available every week.”

That concern is rooted in Taylor’s recent availability. He played every game in 2025, but he missed three games in 2024 and 13 games over the previous two seasons.

The issue for Indianapolis is that the current depth chart doesn’t offer an obvious answer. Fifth-round pick DJ Giddens carried the ball just 26 times as a rookie, while seventh-rounder Seth McGowan and a group of undrafted free agents sit farther down the list. If none of those backs makes a quick impression in camp, the Colts may need to look outside the roster for help in lightening Taylor’s load.

In Other News...

Colts Linked To Troubling Terrion Arnold Interest During Legal Drama

Terrion Arnolds legal situation took another turn this week when he appeared in court for a hearing tied to whether he would have to wear a GPS monitor while on house arrest as he awaits trial on felony charges. His agent told the court that interest in Arnold has not gone away, with multiple NFL teams still checking in even as he remains confined to his home except for work and legal meetings.

For the Colts, the intrigue is less about the courtroom mechanics and more about what happens next with a player whose football future is still drawing attention despite the off-field uncertainty. Indianapolis is among the teams that have inquired, and the broader picture now centers on how much appetite there is around the league to keep pursuing him while his legal case continues to play out. [Read more 🡒]

Colts Linebacker Overhaul May Not Be Done After All

The Colts have already spent part of the offseason reworking their off-ball linebacker group, moving on from Zaire Franklin and bringing in Akeem Davis-Gaither as they try to reshape the middle of the defense. Even with those changes, the position still looks like an area that could use another steady hand, especially for a unit that wants more reliability and leadership in the front seven.

One name that continues to make sense is Bobby Wagner, whose resume still carries real weight because of his tackling, consistency and the way he has stayed productive deep into his career. His experience would also give the Colts another veteran voice for younger defenders to lean on, and with his market value projected in the mid-range for 2026, the question is whether Indianapolis is willing to keep pushing on a linebacker overhaul that may not be finished yet. [Read more 🡒]

Chris Ballard Linked To A Colts Move Fans Will Absolutely Question

A surprising Colts rumor surfaced this week when reporting from Dave Birkett linked Indianapolis to cornerback Terrion Arnold, one of several teams said to be interested in a player whose off-field situation has already made any football discussion complicated. Arnolds agent said in a court hearing that he has had one visit with a team and is expected to have another, which only adds to the sense that clubs are at least kicking the tires even as the legal cloud hangs over everything.

For Indianapolis, the fit is what makes the idea hard to square. The Colts already have depth at cornerback, so a move like this would have to clear a lot of football and non-football hurdles before it made much sense on the roster. And with the risk tied to Arnolds case and the possibility of an NFL suspension looming, it is the kind of link that will naturally leave fans wondering why the team would even be in the conversation. [Read more 🡒]