The Colts’ defense looked like a unit that never got the chance to show what it really was.
Indianapolis spent real money, real draft capital and real optimism on that side of the ball last year, then watched the whole plan get wrecked by injuries. Lou Anarumo arrived as the new coordinator, the team poured more than $66 million in guaranteed money into defensive additions, and the front office drafted players it expected to help right away. But before the season even settled in, rookies Justin Walley and Hunter Wohler were lost for the year in summer injuries.
The hits kept coming after that. Charvarius Ward Sr., Kenny Moore II and DeForest Buckner all missed significant time, and the defense never got the chance to build any real rhythm. Even the big midseason gamble - sending two first-round picks to land Sauce Gardner - didn’t produce much payoff because a calf strain limited him to only two full games.
That’s why the conversation around Indianapolis this time is different. The injured pieces are back and, for the most part, healthy. The Colts also reshaped the front seven with the idea of getting younger, faster and more versatile.
Nguyen put it plainly: "The Colts hired a top-notch play caller in Lou Anarumo last season, but unfortunately, they were hit hard by the injury bug," Nguyen wrote. "Their best player, DeForest Buckner, had season-ending neck surgery after Week (16), corner Charvarius Ward only played seven games because of multiple concussions, and cornerback Sauce Gardner, for whom they traded two first-round picks, (had a calf injury).
In Weeks 1-7, with a healthy Buckner and Ward, the Colts ranked fourth in defensive EPA per play. It’s a small sample size, but it gives a glimpse of what Anarumo can do with some talent to utilize."
That early stretch matters because it’s the clearest glimpse of what this defense can be when the personnel is intact. Buckner and Ward were among the team’s most important players, Moore was also a major loss, and Walley was expected to be in the mix to start opposite Ward before his injury.
Once those bodies disappeared, everything around the defense shifted. Coverage had to be deployed differently, blitzes changed, and the pass rush lost some of its edge because there wasn’t enough reliable cornerback play behind it.
The offseason moves suggest the Colts are trying to build a unit that can do more than just survive. Second-round linebacker CJ Allen is in line to help against the run, and third-round safety A.J. Haulcy gives Anarumo another piece he can move around the formation.
Nguyen highlighted Haulcy as especially intriguing: "The Colts have a better defensive roster now than at the beginning of last season with the addition of second-round linebacker CJ Allen, who will help fortify the run defense, and I’m intrigued by how Anarumo will use third-round pick A.J. Haulcy," Nguyen continued. "Haulcy is a safety who is best utilized around the line of scrimmage and could fit into the role of a modern big nickel."
Allen brings a familiar style, even if the upside is different. He resembles Zaire Franklin in how he plays, and he is the player stepping into Franklin’s old role after the Colts traded the MIKE linebacker to the Green Bay Packers this offseason. But Allen is younger, has more range, and offers more in coverage.
Haulcy, meanwhile, is built to play with an edge. He brings the hard-hitting style that made Nick Cross useful near the line, but his coverage instincts were considered stronger entering the draft. Cross signed with the Washington Commanders in free agency, and Haulcy’s combination of strength, athleticism, intelligence and ball skills should give him a chance to make plays quickly.
The ceiling is obvious if Ward and Gardner are on the field together. Nguyen pointed out that the duo could become one of the league’s best cornerback pairings and give Anarumo the freedom to lean on man coverage outside and bring pressure when the four-man rush doesn’t finish the job.
That kind of flexibility could make Indianapolis stand out in a league that keeps drifting toward two-high, zone-heavy looks. Anarumo’s calling card is creativity, and the Colts seem built to let him mix and match from week to week.
There was at least one small taste of what that might look like. Ward and Gardner only shared one full game last season, a road matchup with the Kansas City Chiefs, and Patrick Mahomes treated them with the kind of caution elite corners force. He often worked underneath and over the middle instead of taking unnecessary chances outside.
That’s the blueprint, and it’s why the Colts can talk themselves into a breakout. The talent is there.
The scheme is there. The only question that really matters is whether the health finally holds.
In Other News...
Colts May Be Settling For A Familiar Pass Rush Reunion
The Colts have already reshaped the edge of their defense this offseason, parting with Kwity Paye and bringing in Arden Key as they try to keep the pass rush from slipping after a noticeable personnel shift. With salary cap room still available, Indianapolis has also kept an eye on lower-cost depth options, and Tyquan Lewis has surfaced as a name that fits both the roster need and the teams familiarity with him.
Lewis is not coming off a huge season, but his appeal for the Colts is more about fit than flash. He knows Lou Anarumos system and could be in position to handle a more useful role if he returns to it, giving Indianapolis a veteran option who can supplement the pass-rush group without forcing the front office into a major commitment. [Read more 🡒]
ESPN Thinks Ballard Made One Colts Bet He Could Regret
The Colts spent the spring making a clear choice about which of their own pieces mattered most, and it was Daniel Jones who got the transition tag while Alec Pierce was allowed to move into a new long-term deal. ESPNs Seth Walder took aim at that approach, arguing Indianapolis should have flipped the decision and tagged Pierce instead, a critique that only sharpened the sense that the front office was choosing stability under center over certainty at receiver.
Pierces profile makes the debate interesting because the upside is obvious even if the production still comes with questions. He has yet to top 50 catches in a season, but he has also led the league in yards per catch in each of the past two years, leaving the Colts with a player who can stretch defenses but still has more to prove as a complete target. Jones, meanwhile, brings a different kind of gamble, and Indianapolis is already on the hook for a deal that could become even more consequential if he does not take the next step. [Read more 🡒]
PFF Just Delivered A Telling Verdict On The Colts Defense
The Colts spent the offseason trying to get younger and faster on defense, and the early PFF outlook suggests the unit still has room to grow even after those changes. Indianapolis allowed 24.2 points per game a season ago, which left it sitting 21st in the league, so there is real pressure on the projected 2025 starters to turn better athletic traits into better week-to-week results.
What stands out in the grades is how wide the spread still looks across the roster, with a few players flashing high-end potential while others remain in more uncertain territory. That kind of mix usually tells you the ceiling is there, but the floor may still depend on whether the defense can stay healthy and get enough steady play from the spots that have not yet sorted themselves out. [Read more 🡒]