Colts Could Face Painful Decisions On Several Familiar Names

With the Indianapolis Colts eyeing a strategic rebuild, several key players may be facing their last days with the team as management considers a major shake-up to pave the way for future success.

The Colts may already be looking beyond this season, and if Indianapolis leans into a real rebuild, the roster churn could stretch well past the players with expiring contracts.

Some of the names that could be on the way out are under contract beyond 2026, but that doesn’t mean they’re safe. If the front office decides it’s time to reset, a few expensive veterans could become expendable fast.

Daniel Jones is the clearest example. He’s signed through 2027, but the Colts could move on and clear $38 million.

That kind of savings would give Indianapolis room to bring in a veteran bridge option such as Jacoby Brissett, someone who could serve as a better stopgap on the way to a long-term quarterback. The bigger point is simple: the Colts still need to find a way to draft a potentially high-end QB.

That becomes even more likely if Shane Steichen, Jones’ biggest fan, is no longer the head coach. Another coach probably would not have tolerated Jones’ play in the first half of the season and would have benched him much earlier.

Anthony Richardson could be next in line for a departure, and his situation is tied directly to Jones. He may have been handed a shot in 2026 because the starter was so poor, but instead he has mostly watched from the bench, appearing only for one quarter in a blowout.

If he didn’t already have hard feelings about Indianapolis, this season likely changed that. Richardson is set to become a free agent next offseason, and there’s little reason to think a reunion makes sense.

The Colts could wind up losing both of their top quarterbacks if they release Jones to save money and fully commit to a reset, but starting over at the position would not be the wrong move.

Grover Stewart is a different case. He’s still a strong run defender in his early 30s, and he would absolutely help a team trying to win right now.

But that’s exactly the issue: a rebuild doesn’t really need him in the same way. Stewart’s cap hit this season is a little over $14 million, and Indianapolis shouldn’t be paying anything close to that if it brings him back.

He’s a good player and a good person, but he should be looking for a winner in 2027.

Charvarius Ward also fits the profile of a veteran who could become too expensive for a team that’s changing course. He’s under contract through 2027, but his cap hit next season is $24,666,667, and cutting him would free up $18 million.

For a rebuilding roster, that’s the kind of money that matters. If the Colts draft well and enter free agency with real spending power, the turnaround could come quickly.

Ward is already over 30, and his 2026 season hasn’t been strong. In Week 9, he posted a quarterback rating of 127.1 and allowed a touchdown.

He should look better in Week 10 against the Miami Dolphins, but that matchup doesn’t say much, because Miami is awful. The real evaluation comes after that.

In Other News...

Colts Win Couldnt Hide The Bigger Problems Waiting After Miami

The Colts escaped Miami with a narrow Week 10 win, but the relief was short-lived. At 3-7, Indianapolis is still staring at a season that has gone off course, and the victory did little to quiet the questions around Daniel Jones, whose play continues to fuel debate about his fit and future with the team. Even with a win in hand, the bigger picture remains stubbornly bleak for a roster that has spent much of the year trying to find an identity.

Shane Steichens offense is also under the microscope, with criticism building around the way the unit has been managed and the overall tone of the team under his leadership. Injuries are another looming concern heading into the next game, and discipline remains an issue for a group that has too often made life harder on itself. For a Colts team trying to turn one win into something more, the problems waiting after Miami still look a lot larger than the result that came out of it. [Read more 🡒]

Colts Quarterback Debate Is Far From Over After Steichens Latest Comments

Shane Steichen made it clear the Colts are not treating the quarterback spot like a quick-trigger decision, even after Daniel Jones uneven play has kept the conversation alive. The head coach said his evaluation starts with the film and centers on ball security, a telling point for a team that just snapped a losing streak with a win over the Dolphins but still has plenty to sort through under center.

Jones will start again this week against the Houston Texans, giving Indianapolis at least one more chance to see whether steadier decision-making follows the recent reset. Even with the victory in hand, the Colts quarterback debate has hardly gone away, and Steichens latest comments suggest the team is still weighing performance, protection of the football and the bigger picture before making any tougher calls. [Read more 🡒]

Colts Rebuild Just Created A Jonathan Taylor Decision Fans Will Question

The Colts have spent the early part of this rebuild ripping up a roster that once looked built to contend, parting with Chris Ballard and moving on from core pieces like DeForest Buckner, Quenton Nelson and Josh Downs. In that context, keeping Jonathan Taylor stands out as the clearest holdover from the old plan, especially after Indianapolis reportedly turned away trade interest that included a second-round pick from the Giants.

For a team trying to reset its direction, the decision to keep Taylor raises a bigger question about what the next version of the Colts is supposed to be. A proven running back still has value, but on a roster that has been stripped down and still faces uncertainty at quarterback, retaining him suggests the front office is weighing short-term stability against the chance to add more future capital. [Read more 🡒]