The Indianapolis Colts didn’t just lose to the Jacksonville Jaguars in Week 8. They got flattened, 42-7, in a performance so lifeless it made the rest of the season feel like an afterthought by the first day of November.
This wasn’t one of those losses you can wave away with a quick “well, the Jaguars are good.” That excuse doesn’t hold up when the game is effectively over by halftime and the team looks checked out before the final whistle. For a coaching staff trying to save its job, that kind of showing is a disaster.
And the damage wasn’t limited to one side of the ball. The Colts managed to pile up failure across the board, from the sideline to the quarterback spot to the roster decisions that now look even worse in the light of a blowout. If there was any doubt about whether sweeping changes are coming, this game did its best to erase it.
Shane Steichen has to wear a huge piece of this one. The highs he reached earlier in his time in Indianapolis don’t matter much after a week like this, because this was the moment he needed to show he still had the locker room.
Instead, the body language by halftime told the story. The players looked like they had already accepted what was coming.
The losses of Quentin Nelson and DeForest Buckner to the trade market made Steichen’s job even more important, because the team needed a steady hand to hold things together. He didn’t deliver that.
Not even close. A 42-7 loss is bad enough on its own; when you put it in the context of how the season has gone, it starts to look like the kind of defeat that can end a tenure.
This may be the nail in the coffin before fan-favorite Colt Jonathan Taylor gets dealt for draft capital, and, to be frank, this may be (should be?) the last game Shane Steichen ever coaches for the Indianapolis Colts.
Lou Anarumo’s defense didn’t offer any relief. If the offense was embarrassing, the defense somehow managed to be worse.
Giving up 42 points while the coaching staff is fighting for its future is the kind of collapse that leaves no room for excuses. DeForest Buckner is gone, yes, and the Jaguars are a good team, but that doesn’t make this acceptable.
Anarumo has already taken heat even when the Colts were cruising through the first eight weeks of the 2025 season, and now that the team is officially 2-6, the case against him has only gotten louder. There were already fans calling for him to be gone after the 2025 season, and after the way 2026 has unfolded, that conversation feels overdue. The Colts have been a pile of problems, and he hasn’t done enough to stop the slide.
Daniel Jones also deserves his share of the blame, because his play helped turn a bad game into a total blowout. He has been near the top of the list in almost every Colts loss, and this one was no different. His play had already started to dip before his Achilles tear in 2025, and since then he’s looked close to unplayable.
The turning point came late in the first half. Indianapolis had just picked off Trevor Lawrence in the red zone, only 20 yards from the end zone, and at 21-0 there was still at least a theoretical path back into the game. Jones immediately erased that hope with an 80-yard pick-six that pushed Jacksonville’s lead to 28-0 before halftime.
By the end of the day, Jones had thrown for 144 yards with one touchdown and two interceptions. Anthony Richardson has taken his share of criticism too, but at least he brings an athletic element Jones doesn’t.
He’s young, and despite all the doubts around him, he’s 8-7 as a Colts starter. After this performance, the idea of Richardson starting going forward no longer sounds far-fetched.
Then there’s Sauce Gardner, whose arrival was supposed to help change the direction of the franchise. Instead, the trade for him may end up being one of the most painful moves the Colts have made in the near future. Without that deal at the 2025 deadline, Indianapolis would have had a first-round pick in the 2026 draft and control of what looks like a very high selection in the loaded 2027 draft.
Instead, they have Gardner, a very good cornerback and one of the better players at his position, on a defense that just gave up 42 points. He was a non-factor against Jacksonville.
And with Adonai Mitchell putting up 142 receiving yards and a touchdown for the Jets - just two fewer yards than Jones had for the Colts - the cost of the trade looks even more brutal. The Colts also gave up two additional first-round picks to get him.
Gardner was supposed to be the piece that pushed this team over the top. Right now, he looks like a very good corner on a 2-6 team that is nowhere near contention.
For Indianapolis, this loss wasn’t just ugly. It was the kind of game that exposes how far the whole operation has fallen.
In Other News...
Jonathan Taylor Gives Colts Fans One Less Thing To Worry About
Jonathan Taylor looks set to give Colts fans a little stability heading into Week 8, with the running back expected to play against the Jacksonville Jaguars. Head coach Shane Steichen said Taylor will be available, and the plan is for him to go into the game without any additional limitation on his reps, a welcome bit of clarity for an offense that can use as much certainty as it can get.
Josh Downs is also expected to be active, even as his situation continues to hang over the roster. Downs has requested a trade and is headed for free agency next year, but for now he remains part of the mix as Indianapolis prepares for a divisional test that could benefit from having both playmakers on the field. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Ugly Jaguars Loss Just Put Everyone On Notice
The collapse in Jacksonville left the Colts in a familiar but increasingly uncomfortable spot, staring at a 42-7 defeat that extended the losing streak to four and turned a rough stretch into something much harder to ignore. What stood out most was not just the score, but the way the game looked from start to finish, with the Jaguars in control and Indianapolis never finding much of a response.
Shane Steichens postgame tone suggested this is no longer about one bad afternoon or one isolated phase of play. The coaching staff is now looking at every part of the roster, and the latest quarterback wrinkle only added to the unease around the team. With questions already swirling about possible changes, the Colts have reached a point where even routine decisions suddenly feel like part of a much bigger reckoning. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Ugly Loss Just Made One Trade Deadline Question Even Bigger
The Colts 42-7 loss to Jacksonville only sharpened the questions around a team already trying to sort out its future at 2-6. Indianapolis has been leaning on younger players like DJ Giddens as trade chatter continues to follow Jonathan Taylor, but the wider issue after a lopsided defeat was how much more turbulence the roster could absorb.
Josh Downs added another layer to that uncertainty with four catches for 23 yards and the Colts only touchdown, then was not in the locker room afterward amid reports of a public trade request. The team had still not heard from him after the game, and for a Colts offense already searching for answers, that makes the deadline conversation feel even bigger than it did before kickoff. [Read more 🡒]