Colts Are Right Back In A Quarterback Debate Fans Dread

Despite a season with no playoff hopes, Colts fans and players are eager for a divisional win against the Texans, while worrying about their quarterback dilemma and coaching strategy.

Beating the Texans would still count as a good day for the Colts, even if the bigger picture around the franchise is already tilted toward the offseason.

That’s the tension hanging over this team now: the fan base has mostly made peace with the idea that the regular season is winding down into draft-position math, but that doesn’t mean a win over a division rival would suddenly lose its appeal. The argument is simple enough.

Losing doesn’t feel as crushing when the season is already headed for the beach, and winning doesn’t automatically become a disaster just because it nudges the draft board. There’s still plenty of satisfaction in knocking the Texans down a peg.

The problem is that there isn’t much confidence in Indianapolis getting it done. The quarterback situation has been a revolving door since Andrew Luck retired, and it’s hard to look at the current group and feel great about any of them.

On top of that, Shane Steichen is drawing frustration for the way he’s handling the job. The sense here is that he still looks like an offensive coordinator wearing a head coach’s title, and the criticism goes beyond play-calling.

The press conferences aren’t helping much either.

The defense isn’t getting a pass, either. Lou Anarumo has some individual players making a case for themselves, but the bigger picture still leaves plenty to question.

Ade, CJ, and JTT finally seem to be getting the regular reps they needed, but it took too long to get there. The Dolphins would have reached 30 points if they had converted their two-point try and a couple of makeable field goals, and that was against a backup quarterback making his first start.

At the same time, the Colts’ offense handed them seven points. The frustration there is obvious: the blitz can create chaos, but it keeps getting held back until the game is already slipping away.

Then there’s Daniel Jones, and that’s where the conversation gets complicated.

He’s been rough, no doubt about it. The performance has been bad enough that the writer says he would not let Jones take another snap this year and would have pulled him at halftime against the Jaguars. But the argument for keeping him as QB1 next year is rooted in something different: the belief that the injury has not fully healed him.

The case is that Jones was supposed to be back to full strength by opening day, backed by Duke medicine, fitted braces, and the idea that last year’s success would carry over. The assumption was that a younger quarterback would bounce back faster than veterans like Kirk Cousins and Aaron Rodgers.

That didn’t happen. Even with a preseason absence that didn’t change the opinion at the time, the current view is that Jones still isn’t anywhere near 100%.

He isn’t comfortable moving up in the pocket or escaping it, and that matters. The read is that Flacco and Ryan may have been better at buying time than this version of Jones is.

Without that movement, he’s living on his first read or dumping it to the nearest outlet. Even that first-read timing has been off, and he doesn’t seem willing to trust throws before a receiver breaks open.

So while the play has been ugly, the belief is that the quarterback is not simply broken - he’s limited by what the injury has left behind.

That’s why the next general manager and head coach would need to sit down with Jones before making any decision on his roster status. The expectation is that he’ll point to the parts of his game that still work, especially his preparation.

He’s smart - he was accepted to Princeton - and he should be able to process whatever the new staff puts in front of him. He also has 47 million reasons to stay in Indianapolis, and the Colts have the cap space to make that conversation matter.

The alternative, at least in this view, doesn’t look especially appealing. There isn’t much faith in the free-agent quarterback market, and the draft path sounds messy too.

Packaging a pick with the No. 2 selection to move into the end of the first round would amount to reaching for a quarterback who isn’t considered first-round material. Even then, it’s hard to imagine another rookie being thrown into the fire right away after the Anthony Richardson experience.

With no No. 1 pick to use in a trade, the team would be shopping from a limited shelf, and a new regime is unlikely to want that kind of short-term fix.

There’s still a belief that Jones could be part of a reset that only lasts one year. Last season is too hard to erase, even with the reminder that some of the competition wasn’t elite.

He was good against good teams too. That’s why the current play doesn’t fully change the evaluation.

The writer doesn’t think Jones is as good as he looked last year, but also doesn’t think he’s as bad as he’s looked this year.

The fix, in this view, starts with structure. Give him a dedicated offensive coordinator without head coaching duties.

Let him have more freedom at the line. Get Pierce back to full strength.

Add a true bookend receiver and strengthen the offensive line. One suggestion is to go big at left tackle, move Raimann to right tackle, and keep the interior intact.

In year two, Burks could slide into the slot role that Downs left behind.

A few other notes came with it. Big Grove should get more chances on third down and passing downs because he’s strong at eating blocks and can still win one-on-ones, which could help create the middle pressure this defense is missing. In a season like this, the veteran big man should be allowed to eat.

Raimann also drew heat. The question is why he keeps escaping criticism, especially if Jones is cut and Raimann becomes the highest-paid Colt next year unless the team makes a major free-agent addition. McGowen, meanwhile, earned praise for getting more carries and showing how badly he wants it, even if he probably isn’t going to break one for a long touchdown.

And if Jones does get replaced, the preference here is Leonard. The idea is to give him more live reps because he could be a depth quarterback for some time.

The team already passed on that chance last year in favor of Rivers. AR might give the Colts a better shot at winning, but since he won’t be here next year, the argument is to play the quarterback who will still be under contract at a manageable price.

In Other News...

Justin Walley Just Gave The Colts A New Defensive Question

Justin Walleys Week 10 performance against Miami gave the Colts a jolt on defense and a reminder that a young secondary can swing a game in a hurry. The cornerback forced a strip-sack on Dolphins quarterback Kyle McCord, and Adetomiwa Adebawore turned the takeaway into a fumble recovery touchdown, the kind of sequence that can change the tone of a game and a locker room.

Walleys day was good enough to earn AFC Defensive Player of the Week honors, the first league-wide recognition of his NFL career. Along with the strip-sack, he finished with five tackles, two tackles for loss and two passes defensed, leaving Indianapolis with a useful question moving forward: how much more can this defense lean on him after a breakout showing like that? [Read more 🡒]

Colts Keep Waiting On Anthony Richardson As Pressure Builds

The Colts have kept Daniel Jones in the starting job through a 3-7 start, and the message from Shane Steichen has been consistent: he is sticking with the veteran while weighing what the team has behind him. Steichen said he looks at quarterback play through film and a broader set of factors, and he confirmed Jones will start again this week, a sign that Indianapolis is not ready to make a change even as the losses keep piling up.

For Anthony Richardson, the wait continues. The 2023 first-round pick has dealt with injuries and limited snaps, leaving him in the same holding pattern that has defined much of his time in Indianapolis, while Riley Leonard also remains part of the discussion in the room. Steichen has shown little public confidence in either backup option, but Richardson is still preparing as if his chance could come at any point, and the pressure around the position only grows louder with each game the Colts stay put. [Read more 🡒]

CJ Allen Is Finally Giving Colts Fans What They Waited For

CJ Allens rookie season has started to look a lot more like the Colts probably envisioned when they spent a second-round pick on him. After a slow opening stretch, the linebacker has settled in over the past few games, and his role has grown along with his confidence. In the win over the Miami Dolphins, he was on the field for every defensive snap and showed up all over the stat sheet with nine tackles, a sack and a pass breakup.

The bigger takeaway for Indianapolis is how much better Allen has looked with more responsibility in the MIKE linebacker spot. Missing training camp clearly slowed his early progress, but the recent uptick suggests the game is starting to slow down for him. For a defense that needs young players to keep ascending, Allens latest stretch has given Colts fans a reason to believe the early frustration may have been worth the wait. [Read more 🡒]