The Colts went all-in for Sauce Gardner because they believed they were buying the kind of corner who can erase an offense’s best option and tilt a game by himself.
That’s not what they got.
Sunday’s loss to Dallas put the problem in full view. With Indianapolis ahead and the game hanging in the balance, Dak Prescott threw a 50-50 ball to Ryan Flournoy with Gardner in coverage.
It was exactly the sort of snap the Colts envisioned when they paid a massive price to land him. Gardner never found the ball, Flournoy came down with it, and the Cowboys’ final drive flipped from a shot at a tying field goal to a march toward the winning touchdown in a 27-23 Dallas victory.
“I’m pissed off,” Gardner said. “End of the game, big play, can’t let that happen.
Game on me, I got to be better. I got to get my head around to make that play.”
The trade that brought Gardner to Indianapolis already looked aggressive at the time. Former general manager Chris Ballard, long criticized for staying conservative, finally made the kind of win-now move he usually avoided. The Colts sent two first-round picks and wide receiver Adonai Mitchell to the Jets, with defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo pushing for a cornerback he believed could help cover up the team’s pass-rush issues and push the roster into contender territory.
Instead, the deal has only gotten harder to defend as the losses pile up. New York’s own struggles have made the draft compensation even more painful, with the Jets positioned to use the Colts’ pick to chase their quarterback of the future - either by taking one in 2027 or by packaging the pick to move up for the player they want.
And even before Indianapolis started sliding, the price was steep for a cornerback. Teams have spent that kind of draft capital on game-wrecking pass rushers like Micah Parsons, Myles Garrett and Jeffery Simmons.
Cornerbacks almost never live in that class. The truly transformational ones are the rarest of the rare, the Deion Sanders and Darrelle Revis types.
Everybody else needs help.
Gardner has not played like someone who belongs in that upper tier. Drafted No. 4 overall by the Jets in 2022, he was a first-team All-Pro in each of his first two seasons and arrived with a reputation that made the Colts believe they were getting a true lockdown corner. But he hasn’t been that player in Indianapolis.
The Cowboys game made that hard to ignore. Dallas had to lean heavily on CeeDee Lamb after George Pickens was inactive, but the Colts did not shadow Lamb with Gardner. Indianapolis has Charvarius Ward on the other side, and Dallas moves Lamb around the formation anyway.
Lamb still carved them up, catching 10 passes for 195 yards despite also drawing two offensive pass interference flags and fumbling at the end of a brilliant fourth-quarter play.
“They were trying to scheme him up a decent amount,” Gardner said. “He made the plays. … At the end of the day, my best was supposed to be required, and I didn’t do that.”
Even so, Gardner’s worst miss did not come against Lamb. It came against Flournoy, a sixth-round pick in 2024 who has never caught more than 40 passes or averaged more than 12 yards per catch in a season. He’s not the kind of receiver a supposed shutdown corner should lose on a decisive throw.
Gardner lost it anyway.
“I’ve got to make that play,” Gardner said. “No matter what happened before that.”
He didn’t hide from it after the game, and that part has been consistent since he arrived in Indianapolis. Gardner has owned his mistakes.
The issue is that the Colts didn’t trade for accountability. They traded for dominance.
There have been other warning signs this season. Treylon Burks beat Gardner deep in London, and Pro Football Reference lists Gardner as allowing 51.9% completions this season, along with 18.1 yards per catch and 9.4 yards per attempt.
“Man, shoot, one game-changing play is the main thing that matters,” Gardner said. “That negates everything that happened before that play.”
The Colts have gotten too many of those plays against them, and too little return on the investment they made to stop them.
Gardner did miss time last season with a calf injury, appearing in only four games after being brought in to help fuel a playoff push, and he has already missed another game this year because of an injury to the same calf. He has rare physical tools, and there’s still room for him to be a difference-maker.
But he has not been close to the player Indianapolis thought it was acquiring.
In Other News...
Colts Fans Are Staring At An Uncomfortable Daniel Jones Decision
Daniel Jones has spent much of this season trying to steady an offense that has not found much consistency, and the Colts are still weighing what comes next at quarterback. His recent stretch has included multiple games under 200 passing yards, and the broader line on his season is hard to ignore: six touchdowns against 10 interceptions over nine games, a profile that has done little to calm the frustration around a disappointing year.
Inside the organization, there is at least some discussion about whether Anthony Richardson should get more playing time as another option under center. For Colts fans, the bigger issue is not just Jones' numbers, but whether the current setup gives the team any real chance to change the direction of a season that has already slipped. The quarterback picture remains unsettled, and the next move figures to say plenty about how the Colts view the rest of this year. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Suddenly Face QB Uncertainty As Vikings Search For Help
The quarterback market is starting to stir ahead of the Nov. 10 NFL trade deadline, and Indianapolis has suddenly found itself part of the conversation. Minnesota is reportedly exploring ways to add a quarterback, with NFL Networks Ian Rapoport pointing to Kirk Cousins and Daniel Jones as possible targets as the Vikings look for help.
For the Colts, the immediate wrinkle is Jones, who had been mentioned as a fit in the rumor mill. Indianapolis has already made clear it is not moving him, even as Minnesota continues to search for options and the deadline clock keeps ticking. The Vikings may still chase a deal, but for now the Colts stance leaves one potential avenue closed. [Read more 🡒]
Colts Benefited From One Of The Strangest Penalties All Season
The Colts left Week 9 with a loss to Dallas, but one of the games strangest moments briefly swung the field in Indianapolis favor. The Cowboys were flagged 14 times for 153 yards in the 27-23 win, and one of those penalties came on an unusual unsportsmanlike conduct call that helped set up the Colts to get back even before the finish tightened again.
It was the kind of sequence that can change the feel of a game without changing the final result, especially in a matchup already littered with flags. Indianapolis took advantage of the extra room after the penalty, but Dallas still found a way to close it out, leaving the Colts to wonder how much different the night might have looked if one bizarre celebration had never happened. [Read more 🡒]