CJ Allen Is Finally Giving Colts Fans What They Waited For

Can CJ Allen's recent breakout transform skepticism into renewed confidence in the Colts' draft strategy?

It took most of the first half of the season, but CJ Allen is starting to look like the player the Colts believed they were getting.

Indianapolis made Allen the first player it landed this year after giving up its 2026 first-round pick in the Sauce Gardner trade, and the expectation was immediate impact. As a second-round pick out of Georgia, he was supposed to be ready to contribute right away. Instead, he was quiet through the first eight games before finally turning the corner over the past couple of weeks.

Against the Miami Dolphins, Allen looked like the best player on the field. He played every defensive snap for the second straight game and stuffed the stat sheet with nine total tackles, two tackles for loss, a pass breakup and a sack.

That sack may have been the biggest play of the night. Allen came free on a five-man pressure and dropped Kyle McCord, knocking the Dolphins out of field-goal range with less than two minutes left. Indianapolis won by two, so the play may have saved the game for Shane Steichen.

Allen also flashed his playmaking ability with a diving interception after reading McCord’s throw, then returning it for what would have been the Colts’ second defensive touchdown of the night. The score was wiped out by a penalty, but the play still stood out.

For a while, Allen looked out of place compared with other rookie linebackers such as Sonny Styles, Jacob Rodriguez and Arvell Reese, who have been making noise every week. His slow start now makes more sense when viewed through the lens of a missed training camp, which clearly set him back.

What has changed is the role and the comfort level. With the Colts effectively in a different phase of the season, Allen has been thrown into the MIKE spot and has responded with sharp communication, a strong feel for the game and real production against the run.

He may not be the fastest linebacker on the field, but once he plants his feet, he’s hard to move. Allen is playing with more freedom now, and the confidence that was missing early on is finally showing up on Sundays.

In Other News...

Justin Walley Just Gave The Colts A New Defensive Question

Justin Walleys Week 10 performance against Miami gave the Colts a jolt on defense and a reminder that a young secondary can swing a game in a hurry. The cornerback forced a strip-sack on Dolphins quarterback Kyle McCord, and Adetomiwa Adebawore turned the takeaway into a fumble recovery touchdown, the kind of sequence that can change the tone of a game and a locker room.

Walleys day was good enough to earn AFC Defensive Player of the Week honors, the first league-wide recognition of his NFL career. Along with the strip-sack, he finished with five tackles, two tackles for loss and two passes defensed, leaving Indianapolis with a useful question moving forward: how much more can this defense lean on him after a breakout showing like that? [Read more 🡒]

Colts Keep Waiting On Anthony Richardson As Pressure Builds

The Colts have kept Daniel Jones in the starting job through a 3-7 start, and the message from Shane Steichen has been consistent: he is sticking with the veteran while weighing what the team has behind him. Steichen said he looks at quarterback play through film and a broader set of factors, and he confirmed Jones will start again this week, a sign that Indianapolis is not ready to make a change even as the losses keep piling up.

For Anthony Richardson, the wait continues. The 2023 first-round pick has dealt with injuries and limited snaps, leaving him in the same holding pattern that has defined much of his time in Indianapolis, while Riley Leonard also remains part of the discussion in the room. Steichen has shown little public confidence in either backup option, but Richardson is still preparing as if his chance could come at any point, and the pressure around the position only grows louder with each game the Colts stay put. [Read more 🡒]

Colts Injury Trouble Is Suddenly Changing The Texans' Week 11 Outlook

A short week was already going to test the Colts, and the injury report has only made the challenge steeper. Indianapolis has officially ruled out five players for Thursday nights matchup with the Texans, including tight end Will Mallory, offensive tackles Bernhard Raimann and Jalen Travis, defensive tackle Jerry Tillery and cornerback Charvarius Ward Sr. That kind of list changes the feel of a divisional game quickly, especially when the turnaround is this tight.

The uncertainty does not stop there, either. Four more Colts are listed as questionable, among them cornerback Sauce Gardner and wide receiver Anthony Gould, leaving plenty of moving parts as the team tries to get ready for Houston. For a matchup that already carried plenty of weight in the AFC South race, Indianapolis now has to navigate both the opponent and its own health issues before kickoff. [Read more 🡒]