Andrew Nembhard has become the rare Pacers draft pick who actually beat the odds, and that alone is part of why his future matters so much.
Indiana has not exactly built a glowing recent track record with its own selections. Over the past decade, Nembhard stands out as the one draft pick who developed into a useful player for the team and outperformed where he was taken.
Before him, the only player who might fit that description was Myles Turner. That’s how thin the list has been.
Bennedict Mathurin has been described as mid. Jarace Walker as a bust.
Isaiah Jackson, Chris Duarte and Goga Bitadze never became good enough to hang around. Jackson did get extended after his rookie contract, but he was quickly sent out in the Ivica Zubac package.
That history helps explain why the Pacers and their fans are so attached to Nembhard. He is the one homegrown rotation player Indiana can point to and say it got this one right.
But the bigger picture is getting harder to ignore. The summer of 2028-29 is closing in, and Indiana has a lot of contract decisions coming.
Unless extension talks move in a way that has not been reported, three of the five starters could hit free agency that offseason. If you widen the lens to the whole rotation, the Pacers only have two of their best eight players locked in beyond the next two seasons.
That group includes Zubac and Pascal Siakam, who are also the team’s star acquisition and top scorer. It also includes the bench mix - veterans like TJ McConnell, reclamation pieces such as Obi Toppin, and newer additions like Kelly Oubre Jr.
That is a lot of uncertainty for a team that could be staring down a summer full of negotiations with only Tyrese Haliburton and Aaron Nesmith secured long term.
So where does Nembhard fit? He is extension-eligible, and if Indiana cannot work out a deal, the question becomes whether it makes sense to keep him at all.
Zubac and Siakam may be in line for full max deals as they move deeper into their careers at 29 and 32. Nembhard, by contrast, is the kind of younger player who is likely to want his first major payday.
And if the Pacers can’t pay him, the logic points toward moving him.
Letting a player like Nembhard walk for nothing would be the worst-case outcome. He is a shot-creator, a defender and a playmaker - the kind of guard every team can use. Indiana would have a tough time replacing that production, but the team’s bigger obligation is protecting itself from losing far more valuable pieces in Zubac and Siakam.
If a deal never comes together, the Pacers could look for draft capital from a younger team in need of a lead guard and creator. The Dallas Mavericks were mentioned as one possible fit, especially with Kyrie Irving aging out. Another path would be dealing Nembhard to a contender that sees him as the final piece.
It would be a difficult move, because Nembhard has been one of the better developmental stories in Indiana. Still, the decision has to be made with the franchise’s long-term health in mind. He could end up being a cap casualty, and it would not be because of anything he did wrong.
In Other News...
Pacers May Regret How Ben Sheppard Got Lost In The Shuffle
The Pacers drafted Jarace Walker and Ben Sheppard in 2023 with the idea that both could help reshape a wing rotation that needed more size, versatility and long-term depth. Instead, the arrival of Pascal Siakam changed the teams direction and crowded the path for both young players, leaving Indiana with a different look and fewer clean minutes to hand out as it tried to balance immediate wins with development.
Sheppard has shown enough progress to suggest there is something worth keeping in the picture, but his role has never really settled in the way a young player usually needs. For a Pacers team that has dealt with its share of depth questions, that makes his spot in the rotation look more important than ever, and it is fair to wonder whether Indiana is letting one of its better upside bets drift to the margins. [Read more 🡒]
Tyrese Haliburton Just Gave Pacers Fans Another Reason To Watch Him
Tyrese Haliburton has already given Pacers fans plenty to track on the floor, but his latest move suggests he is building something off it as well. He posted on X looking for thumbnail designers, a small detail on the surface that points to a broader push around his YouTube and Twitch presence, where he has been steadily carving out a bigger digital footprint.
Haliburton also recently launched Zero Doubt Creative with Wheelhouse Entertainment, a production company aimed at storytelling and content creation. For Indiana, it is another reminder that its point guard is becoming more than just the engine of the offense, even as analysts continue to point to his impact on the Pacers' success. Fans who already follow every pass and pickup game now have another lane to watch. [Read more 🡒]
Tyrese Haliburton Could Change Everything About How Fans See The Pacers
ESPN analyst Bobby Marks sees a path for the Pacers to look a lot different this season, even after last years 19-win finish and the long absence of Tyrese Haliburton. Indiana is getting back key pieces and added Kelly Oubre, which gives the roster a little more balance around a point guard who changes the whole feel of the team when hes healthy. In a stronger Eastern Conference, that kind of swing matters, because it can quickly turn a rebuilding-looking group into one that makes the standings a lot more interesting.
Marks even drew a parallel to Kawhi Leonards return from injury, the kind of comparison that hints at how much Haliburton can alter expectations if hes fully back. The Pacers do not need a miracle to look better, but they may need Haliburton to be the version of himself that forces opponents to adjust every night. If that happens, Indianas season could look nothing like the one fans saw a year ago. [Read more 🡒]