Kirk Herbstreit isn’t shy about where he stands on Notre Dame heading into the new college football season.
On “The Pat McAfee Show,” the longtime analyst named the Fighting Irish as his top pick among the national contenders, pointing to quarterback CJ Carr as a major reason for the optimism.
“I’m going Notre Dame. … [quarterback] CJ [Carr] is the real deal,” Herbstreit said. “I like Notre Dame.”
He doubled down on that feeling in the same conversation, adding: "I like Notre Dame and Miami..
I think Texas A&M could make a run with Marcel Reed this year" ~ @KirkHerbstreit #PMSLive pic.twitter.com/iaREizIxoW
- Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) July 22, 2026
That confidence lines up with the broader picture around Notre Dame, which enters the season with a real path back to the College Football Playoff after missing last year’s field. The Fighting Irish fell short of a national title in 2024, but their postseason fate this time around looks mostly in their own hands.
The numbers back up the hype. ESPN’s Football Power Index slots Notre Dame third, gives the program the best shot at finishing the regular season unbeaten at 32.7 percent, and puts its CFP chances at 74.4 percent, second only to Ohio State. FPI also has the Fighting Irish third in national championship game appearance probability and third in title odds.
Still, projections don’t win games. Notre Dame’s schedule gives it a favorable runway, but the team will have to handle business on the field and survive another playoff push to turn that preseason praise into something bigger.
Marcus Freeman’s group does return important pieces from its last deep postseason run, and the head coach gives Notre Dame an edge against most of what it will face. The source material points to only Georgia, Indiana and Ohio State as teams with a comparable mix of talent and coaching.
Notre Dame also has a familiar connection to the state’s title chase. The Fighting Irish beat Indiana at home in the 2024 CFP before later falling to Ohio State in the championship game. Now they’re trying to follow Indiana’s lead and bring another national championship back to the state.
Will Notre Dame return to the CFP in 2026?
In Other News...
Another Indiana Commitment Just Sent A Bigger Message About Cignetti
Indianas recruiting momentum keeps building, and the latest sign of it came from the quarterback position. Lukas Prock, a four-star prospect in the 2028 cycle, has already given Curt Cignetti another early win on the trail, a move that says as much about where Indiana is headed as it does about the player himself.
Procks commitment fits the broader pitch Cignetti has been making: that the program has a direction, a standard and enough stability to convince top talent to buy in early. Indiana has been stacking notable recruiting victories lately, including the addition of five-star receiver Monshun Sales and a wave of blue-chip 2027 prospects, and Procks decision only adds to the sense that the Hoosiers are starting to look like a place where elite recruits expect the growth to continue. [Read more 🡒]
Several Hoosiers Are Making A Statement Before Indiana Heads Home
Indianas trip to Lima has turned into a useful summer showcase, with IU basketball representing the United States and rolling through the FISU America Games without a loss. The Hoosiers won Group B, then backed it up with a lopsided semifinal win over Chile, putting together a clean run that has given the program a chance to see several players make an early statement before the group heads back to Bloomington.
Aiden Sherrell has been one of the steadier producers in the event, averaging 16 points and seven rebounds through three games, while Prince-Alexander Moody has added a balanced line with scoring, playmaking and perimeter shooting. Indiana has one game left in Peru, and the way these performances carry over into the final will be worth watching once the Hoosiers return home. [Read more 🡒]
Marcus Freeman Just Admitted Indiana Football Changed Everything In State
Indiana footballs title run has already started to ripple well beyond Bloomington. The national championship trophy made a stop at IUs satellite campus in South Bend, a fitting backdrop for a program that just delivered the first national title by an Indiana team since 1988 and suddenly has the states football conversation turned in its direction.
Marcus Freeman has noticed, too. In a recent interview, the Notre Dame coach acknowledged Indianas success and the influence it can have on the sport, a notable nod from a rival whose program has long loomed large in the state. The timing matters for IU, which has also picked up commitments from notable recruits as the momentum around the program continues to build. [Read more 🡒]