SEATTLE - The Big Ten spent Saturday taking hit after hit, and Indiana’s overtime loss at Washington may have delivered the clearest sign yet: there may not be a true title contender left standing in the league.
Indiana’s 27-24 loss in overtime at Husky Stadium dropped the Hoosiers to 9-2 and left them needing help from around the conference just to get back to the Big Ten Championship Game. Washington tipped Paddy McAteer’s 37-yard field goal attempt wide in overtime, then the fans rushed the field after the win.
“I give Washington a lot of credit, great win for them,” Indiana coach Curt Cignetti said. “They made one more play than we did, and that was it.”
The Hoosiers were not the only Big Ten team to stumble. No.
4 UCLA, the conference’s last unbeaten team, lost 18-16 to Michigan in triple overtime. No.
14 Ohio State was beaten 31-28 at Nebraska, dropping the Buckeyes to 7-4 and ending any realistic at-large playoff path.
That leaves the league in a strange place two weeks before selection Sunday. Oregon has three losses.
Iowa has two, but like Indiana, it does not have the kind of signature wins that would make an at-large case easy. Both probably need to win the Big Ten Championship Game to have a real shot at the College Football Playoff.
That means the conference could wind up sending only its champion to the 12-team bracket.
Indiana’s resume took another blow with the Washington loss. The Hoosiers have one ranked win this season, last week’s 27-13 victory over No.
18 USC, and they were already sitting behind several two-loss SEC teams in the latest rankings. Cignetti had criticized that order on X in recent weeks, and now the results have made the climb even steeper.
Indiana could drop behind one- and two-loss teams such as Tennessee, Wake Forest, Texas Tech and BYU, all of whom have bigger wins on their cards.
The Big Ten has been in this kind of spot before, though not for a long time. In 2012, Ohio State went 12-0 in Urban Meyer’s first season and finished No. 3 in the final AP poll, but NCAA sanctions kept the Buckeyes out of the Big Ten Championship Game and out of a bowl.
Wisconsin then won the league title despite a 7-5 record and 4-4 mark in conference play, rolling past Nebraska 70-31 before losing the Rose Bowl to Stanford, 20-14. The Big Ten finished 2-5 in bowl games that season.
The league bounced back quickly. Michigan State finished No. 3 in 2013 after winning the Rose Bowl, and Ohio State captured the first College Football Playoff national championship in 2014.
Since then, the Big Ten has had a team in the title conversation every year. That streak is in real danger of ending now.
Indiana is not out of the race for Indianapolis, but the road is tight and crowded with chaos. The Hoosiers need to beat Purdue next Saturday in the Old Oaken Bucket game, and then they need help.
One path has Indiana beating Purdue, UCLA losing to USC, and at least one of these results: Oregon losing to Washington, Iowa losing to Nebraska, or Wisconsin losing to Minnesota.
Another path has Indiana beating Purdue, UCLA beating USC, and at least one of these results: Oregon losing to Washington or Iowa losing to Nebraska.
If UCLA, Oregon and Iowa all win, the Bruins would meet Oregon, which would hold the tiebreaker over Iowa and Indiana because of its record against common conference opponents. If UCLA loses to USC and Oregon and Iowa both win, Oregon and Iowa would play for the Big Ten title.
Even if Indiana found its way into the championship game, its playoff hopes would still depend on a committee that already appears unlikely to reward the Hoosiers with much of anything. Missing Indianapolis would likely end the playoff dream altogether.
For now, the Hoosiers are talking like a team that knows what it can and cannot control. Their focus has shifted to Purdue.
“As far as the CFP goes, that's something we can't control,” offensive lineman Carter Smith said. “Full steam ahead on the bucket.”
Stephen Daley echoed that sentiment after the loss.
“We need to just control what we control from here on out,” Daley said postgame.
Purdue, sitting at 3-8, comes to Bloomington next Saturday for the final game of the regular season. That’s the one result Indiana can secure on its own. Everything beyond that - Indianapolis, the playoff, all of it - depends on other people.
In Other News...
Indiana Just Brought Its Biggest Fears Into The Stretch Run
A missed 37-yard field goal by Paddy McAteer in overtime sent Indiana home with a 27-24 loss to Washington, a result that landed hard because of what was at stake. The defeat dropped the Hoosiers to 9-2 and turned what had been a promising late-season position into something far more precarious as the Big Ten Championship Game and College Football Playoff picture tightened around them.
Indiana did not just leave with a loss, either. The game also brought more injury trouble, including hits to the offensive line and the kind of depth issues that can become especially costly this time of year. With the stretch run now carrying even more pressure, the Hoosiers have to sort through both the standings and the health of a roster that can ill afford many more setbacks. [Read more 🡒]
Tennessee Suddenly Has A New Role In Another Teams Playoff Fate
Oregons playoff path got a little cleaner with a recent win over Michigan State, and the Ducks have now strung together four straight victories to stay in the mix. Even so, the No. 13 Ducks are still in the position of needing help, with several higher-ranked teams ahead of them and a crowded stretch of games still to come that could reshape the College Football Playoff picture.
Tennessee is part of that traffic jam, along with BYU, Indiana, Iowa, Ohio State and Michigan, all of whom have upcoming games that could swing Oregons standing one way or another. For the Ducks, the next few weeks are less about style points and more about scoreboard watching, because their postseason fate may depend as much on what happens elsewhere as on anything they do themselves. [Read more 🡒]
Indianas Playoff Push Suddenly Has One Brutal New Problem
Indianas playoff push ran into a harsh roadblock at Husky Stadium, where the No. 8 Hoosiers came up short in a 27-24 overtime loss to Washington. The game had the feel of one that might be decided by a single mistake, and it was. Washington forced the extra period after Demond Williams Jr. found Decker DeGraaf for a late touchdown, then Tyler Robles delivered a 46-yard field goal to put the Huskies ahead.
For Indiana, the missed chance stung even more because the Hoosiers had a response in hand and could not finish it. Their 37-yard field goal attempt was blocked, leaving them with a second loss and a 9-2 record as the margin for error shrinks. Washington, meanwhile, moved to 7-4 and left Indiana with a brutal reminder that one close finish can change the entire shape of a season. [Read more 🡒]
