Indiana’s path to Selection Sunday may be cleaner than its résumé.
That’s the strange spot the Hoosiers are in right now. Curt Cignetti’s team can keep winning, keep stacking results, and still wind up staring at a Playoff profile that feels thinner than it should.
The issue isn’t what Indiana can do. It’s what everyone else around the Hoosiers might do over the next five weeks.
At the moment, Indiana has the benefit of the doubt in the AP Poll, and the “defending national champs” label helps. But the bigger question is what the final College Football Playoff rankings will look like when the field is set on Selection Sunday. And the uncomfortable possibility is this: Indiana could get there without a single ranked win.
To be clear, that means ranked at the end of the season, not ranked when the games are played. If you looked at it that way and assumed the chalk held, Indiana still wouldn’t have a win over a Top 25 team at the time of the matchup. But the real conversation is about how the résumé looks when the committee makes its final call.
If Indiana finishes 11-1 and doesn’t reach the Big Ten Championship - with UCLA and Ohio State projected there if things go according to script - the Hoosiers should still make the Playoff without much drama. The real concern is whether that record would be strong enough to secure a home game if the best win on the sheet is Northwestern.
That’s where the picture gets messy. Northwestern is 6-1 and one of the season’s surprises, thanks in part to Chip Kelly’s Wing-T sets.
The Wildcats are No. 20 in the country and the second-lowest ranked one-loss Power Conference team. But the catch is glaring: they don’t have quality wins.
Among undefeated and one-loss Power Conference teams, the number of Power Conference wins by the teams they’ve beaten looks like this:
Miami: 13
Kentucky: 11
BYU: 10
ND: 10
Wake: 10
Georgia: 9
IU: 9
OSU: 9
UCLA: 9
SMU: 8
Utah: 7
Arizona: 6
Texas Tech: 6
Northwestern: 2
That’s the problem for the Wildcats. The moment they take another loss, they’re likely out of the Top 25.
That could happen this weekend at Oregon in a Kelly reunion game. If not there, Iowa at home or a trip to Ohio State could do the damage later.
A 10-2 Northwestern team would probably still be ranked on Selection Sunday. A 9-3 version without quality wins?
That’s a different story.
Minnesota is another possible answer, but it comes with its own complications. The Gophers are 5-2 and 3-1 in SEC play, and they still have chances to add quality wins, including Saturday in Bloomington.
But they’re not ranked now, and a loss to Indiana would likely knock them further down from the seven votes they currently have in the AP Poll, unofficially No. 31.
You can call it brand bias if you want, or just note that Minnesota has been inconsistent. The Gophers took a home loss to Mississippi State and were blown out by 3-win Purdue.
Their path to becoming a ranked win for Indiana would require losing to the Hoosiers, then winning out against UCLA, Penn State, Northwestern and Wisconsin. That’s a lot to ask from a team that has already shown plenty of wobble.
USC is in the mix too, though the Trojans are currently unranked with two losses and tied with Minnesota at seven AP votes. If they beat Julian Sayin-less Ohio State this weekend, that changes. If they lose again to a backup quarterback, that ranking dream likely disappears along with it.
And even if USC does beat Ohio State, there’s still the question of whether beating a team with a backup quarterback would earn enough credit. Then Indiana would have to beat USC later, which would hand the Trojans a third loss after they skipped playing a Power Conference team in non-conference play.
That’s the theme here: the teams Indiana might point to as ranked wins are all living on the edge. Beat them, and they may tumble out of the Top 25. That leaves Northwestern as the most realistic hope, and even that feels like a narrow lane.
Nebraska? Not likely.
The Huskers haven’t beaten a ranked opponent in more than a decade, and their coach is 2-26 lifetime against ranked teams. No one should be banking on them to beat Iowa, let alone Ohio State.
As for the messy three-loss possibilities like Michigan and Washington, they don’t look like realistic candidates to climb back into the Top 25 either.
So yes, an 11-1 Indiana would look different than it did two years ago. That much is clear. What isn’t clear is whether the rest of the board will cooperate enough to give the Hoosiers a résumé that looks as good on Selection Sunday as it does in October.
In Other News...
Indiana Spotlight Weekend Included A Brutal Near Miss Fans Wont Forget
Pat McAfee brought his Kicking is Easy contest to Bloomington during Week 9, and Indiana fans got a front-row seat to one of the seasons most nerve-racking moments. Student Jackson stepped up for two tries from 33 yards, with a $1 million prize hanging in the balance, and the setup had all the ingredients for a campus moment nobody would forget.
The contest has already produced several successful college kicks this season, including a recent $3 million win by BYU student Carter, which only sharpened the tension around Jacksons attempt. Instead, the Hoosiers crowd was left with a brutal near miss on both tries, and the episode wrapped with special guest Isiah Thomas making picks ahead of Indianas Big Ten game. [Read more 🡒]
Indiana's Homecoming Test Feels Bigger Than A Routine Big Ten Saturday
Homecoming in Bloomington brings a little extra weight to Saturdays Big Ten matchup, with Indiana set to welcome Minnesota to Memorial Stadium in a late-afternoon window that should give the game a bigger stage than a typical league date. The Hoosiers come in at 7-1, Minnesota at 5-2, and both teams have spent the fall building enough momentum to make this one feel like more than just another conference checkpoint.
Curt Cignettis group has turned every home date into a measuring stick, and this one arrives with CBS carrying the broadcast and P.J. Fleck bringing a familiar brand of physical, disciplined football into town. For Indiana, the setting matters as much as the standings, because a win here would keep the Hoosiers right where they want to be in the Big Ten picture while giving the homecoming crowd a game with real consequence. [Read more 🡒]
Indianas Tight End Shift Could Say A Lot About This Offense
Indianas tight end room has been one of the quieter parts of the offense this season, but it has also become one of the more interesting. Trevor Gibbs, Andrew Barker and Brock Schott have all worked their way into the mix after early-season uncertainty and injuries, giving Curt Cignetti more options as Indiana keeps searching for ways to stress defenses that are built to take away the obvious answers.
Cignetti has pointed to steady improvement from the group, with Schott drawing particular notice after a key catch in overtime against Michigan. For an offense trying to broaden its menu, the way Indiana uses its tight ends over the next stretch could be revealing, not just about who is earning snaps but about how much flexibility this unit really has. [Read more 🡒]