Indianas 5-0 Start Is Already Changing This Hoosiers Debate

The Hoosiers have found early success with a balanced attack, but questions remain about which emerging players will carry them forward.

Indiana’s 5-0 start has already sorted out a lot of the Hoosiers’ rotation, and the early returns have been pretty revealing. A statement win over Arkansas helped sharpen the picture even more, with some players surging, a few settling into the roles Indiana wanted, and others still trying to find traction.

Trevor Manhertz has been one of the clearer bright spots. The freshman has given Indiana useful minutes when called upon, averaging 6.0 points while hitting 42% from three.

He’s shown the shooting touch that made him such an interesting part of the latest recruiting class, and he’s chipped in on the boards too. The catch is that his role has stayed fairly small, as he’s logged the second-fewest minutes among the regulars.

That makes a push at the program’s freshman 3-point record look less and less likely.

Darren Haris has taken a much bigger leap than anyone probably expected after a quiet preseason. He’s now Indiana’s top scorer, thanks in part to a pair of 20-point games and some of his best work coming against Syracuse and Arkansas.

The 36% mark from deep still leaves room for growth, but he’s been excellent at the line, where he’s making 87% of his tries. He hasn’t stuffed the stat sheet in every area, and he’s only hit five of 13 shots inside the arc, but his shot-making at key moments has mattered.

Without his second-half work against Syracuse and Arkansas, Indiana’s unbeaten start could look very different.

Bryce Lindsay has been a little harder to pin down, but the Arkansas game was a good snapshot of what he’s brought so far. He was quiet for most of the night, then drilled the biggest shot Indiana has hit this season to that point - a deep 3-pointer that put the Hoosiers ahead late.

That’s been his pattern through five games: not always dominant, but always dangerous. He hasn’t matched the offensive takeover stretches he showed in preseason, yet he’s still a real scoring threat off the bench.

His 34% shooting from three isn’t eye-popping, though the degree of difficulty on some of those attempts makes it look better than it sounds. The consistency can still climb, but Indiana has gotten what it needed from him.

Jaeden Mustaf has become one of the more valuable glue pieces on the roster. He’s averaging just 4.8 field-goal attempts per game, but he’s still one of six Hoosiers scoring in double figures because he’s efficient and keeps getting to the free-throw line.

He’s also knocked down three of seven from beyond the arc. If that volume rises without hurting his efficiency, Indiana’s offense gets even tougher to guard.

Even so, his biggest value may be on the other end. He’s handling the hardest perimeter matchups, rebounding well for his size and giving Indiana another ball-handler next to its primary guards.

Sam Alexis is doing exactly what Indiana needs from him. The numbers won’t jump off the page - 4.8 points and 4.0 rebounds per game - but that’s not the point.

He’s settled into the role of the Hoosiers’ third center, bringing energy, depth and leadership. The offense hasn’t been especially efficient, but in a role like this, dependable is enough.

Markus Burton may be the toughest player on the roster to evaluate right now. The stat line looks strong: 12.2 points per game, 54% shooting from three, nearly five assists a night and a better-than-2-to-1 assist-to-turnover ratio.

But even with those numbers, it still feels like Indiana hasn’t seen the fullest version of him yet. He hasn’t taken many threes, and much of his scoring has come from the midrange.

He’s been efficient, but he hasn’t consistently taken over games. For a player with all-conference expectations, there’s still another gear to find.

Trent Sisley, meanwhile, is still trying to carve out a real role in his second season. He’s averaging fewer than 12 minutes a game and looks stuck near the back end of the rotation.

Against Arkansas on Tuesday, he played six minutes, didn’t record a counting stat beyond a personal foul and had some trouble defensively against the Razorbacks’ athleticism. He’s also made just one of five 3-point attempts this season.

His versatility still matters, but the second-year jump hasn’t shown up yet, and he needs to make more of the chances he gets.

Samet Yigitoglu has been one of the clearest answers to an offseason need. Indiana wanted a real interior presence, and through five games, he’s provided it.

He’s averaging 11.0 points and 6.8 rebounds while giving the Hoosiers the kind of physicality they were missing last season. His production hasn’t been steady every night, but his first half against Arkansas stood out.

He finished with 17 points and 10 rebounds, much of it coming early, and showed he can do that against a ranked power conference team, not just against smaller nonconference opponents. Indiana doesn’t need that kind of night every time out, but it helps to know it’s in there.

Aiden Sherrell may have been the most important answer of all against Arkansas. The first half made it clear why Darian DeVries targeted him so aggressively this offseason.

Sherrell was excellent, helping carry the offense before the guards got rolling. He ended with 17 points and six rebounds in one of his best performances yet.

He’s shooting 36% from three, can score at all three levels and leads Indiana with 10 stocks. Even more important, he’s proven he fits with anyone.

He can protect the rim, stretch the floor, rebound and guard multiple spots without needing the offense built around him. Five games in, Sherrell looks like one of the biggest additions DeVries made.

In Other News...

Washington Coach Just Identified Indianas Edge In Close Games

Washington head coach Jedd Fisch spent part of his media availability this week breaking down what has made No. 8 Indiana such a difficult out, and he kept coming back to the same themes: experience and belief. With Saturdays game set for Seattle, Fisch pointed to the Hoosiers continuity as a real edge, noting how Curt Cignetti and Bob Chesney brought a familiar standard with them from James Madison and helped preserve a strong culture along the way.

For Indiana, that kind of outside recognition is more than just a compliment. Close games often come down to poise, trust and a teams comfort in big moments, and Fischs comments suggested those are exactly the traits Washington sees when it looks at the Hoosiers. The challenge now is whether that edge travels with Indiana into a road setting where the Huskies will try to test it from the opening kickoff. [Read more 🡒]

Rick Neuheisel Just Put Indiana On Upset Alert With Playoff Stakes Rising

Indiana is heading into Week 12 with College Football Playoff stakes hanging over every snap, and the latest outside opinion adds a little more tension to an already tricky road trip. Rick Neuheisel is calling for Washington to spring the upset at Husky Stadium, pointing to the kind of crowd energy that can make a November night feel bigger than the records suggest.

The matchup comes with plenty of uncertainty on both sides, including Washingtons 6-4 mark and quarterback Demond Williams working back from injuries, while Indianas own quarterback situation remains unsettled because of injuries to starter Josh Hoover. The Hoosiers still sit in strong position for the playoff, but a loss would complicate that path and could open the door for teams like Ohio State and Oregon to gain ground. [Read more 🡒]

Indiana Leaves USC Win With New Roles Fans Need To Watch

Indianas win over USC did more than add another quality result to the ledger. It also offered a clearer look at how the Hoosiers are reshaping themselves on the fly, with Khobie Martin giving the run game a lift and Jacob Savage making his presence felt on defense. With injuries forcing changes up front and elsewhere, the game became a snapshot of a roster that is still adjusting while trying to keep its momentum intact.

The most interesting part for Indiana now is how those new responsibilities settle in over the next stretch. Austin Leibfried slid into the right guard spot, Brock Schott saw his offensive role grow, and the staff got a better read on who can handle added work when the depth chart is tested. Not every performance came together cleanly, either, as A.J. Harris had a quieter outing and will be one of the players to watch as the competition tightens again. [Read more 🡒]