The first half of Indiana’s girls volleyball state finals produced two very different kinds of champions Saturday at Gainbridge Fieldhouse in Indianapolis.
Indianapolis Lutheran rolled through the Class 1A bracket without dropping a set, then finished the job with a 25-19, 25-11, 25-21 sweep of Rossville. Benton Central followed with a much tougher road in Class 2A, shaking off a second-set stumble to beat Heritage Christian 25-5, 14-25, 25-19, 25-21 and claim the first team state championship in school history in any sport.
Both teams came into the title matches ranked No. 2 in their classes, but the way they got there couldn’t have looked more different.
Lutheran’s run was all about control. The Saints entered the championship having already swept five postseason opponents, and they made it six straight with a match that never really slipped out of their hands. Senior Sophia Levine finished it off with her 19th kill, capping a postseason in which Lutheran won every set it played.
Levine had been a major force all season, entering the final with 317 kills and 72 blocks across 96 sets. And with six starters back from last year’s team, the Saints had the kind of experience that can turn a good tournament team into a dangerous one.
That edge showed up in the postseason, especially after a sectional exit last year left a sour taste.
"After last, after we lost in sectionals, it wasn't really like, 'I want to win state,' it was 'I'm going to win state' mentality. We all made this happen," senior libero Reagon Crabtree said.
"Going through the postseason run that we did, not dropping a set, I think it showed all of our hard work."
Rossville had built a strong case of its own. The Hornets came into the tournament after back-to-back regular-season losses, then found their rhythm at the right time. Their run included a win over top-ranked Covington to secure a second straight regional title, pushing them all the way to their first state championship match.
But Lutheran never let them settle in. The Saints set the tone early and kept the pressure on all the way through, completing a postseason that ended the same way it began: with a sweep.
Benton Central’s championship had a different feel from the start. The Bison were chasing more than a volleyball trophy - they were trying to bring home the first team state title in school history, and they got it done after a season that had already hinted at something special.
A year after finishing as the Class 2A runner-up, Benton Central returned with five starters back and a clear mission to finish the job. A 12-match winning streak that started in September helped build that belief, and the Bison carried it into the final.
They came out flying, taking the first set 25-5. Heritage Christian answered with a 25-14 second-set win to even things up and force Benton Central to reset. From there, the Bison steadied themselves, taking the third set 25-19 and closing out the match 25-21 in the fourth.
When it was over, Benton Central had reached a milestone no previous team at the school had managed. The school had already been close before, finishing as state runner-up in girls basketball in 1989, 2011 and 2019, along with last year’s volleyball title match.
"We played for (two hours) today for forever," Benton Central head coach Scott Mattson said. "They'll have their picture on the wall in the gym; they will have a trophy with their name on it in a special place. They will be remembered forever as the first to do it."
Mattson also pointed to what the championship meant beyond the court.
"I feel great for the community, they have put out so much support for us, so much energy for us," Mattson said. "I know it means a lot to them, and to win the first, that's just fantastic for the school and the kids."
Benton Central’s win was built on balance. Maggie Widmer led the way with 13 kills, McKenna Yadon had nine, and Goodman added seven kills and 13 digs.
Ella Miller and Rhyan Deno chipped in with six kills apiece, while Whaley finished with 23 assists. Minniear added 12 assists and nine digs.
Heritage Christian had its own standouts. Ella Mensch put down 19 kills, Kenley Mitchell added 13, and Quinn Ralston tied the IHSAA Class 2A championship record with two solo blocks. The Eagles also got important help from freshman defensive specialist Addie Mayer, who finished the season with 391 digs in 102 sets after the team entered the year with only three returning starters.
Still, Benton Central’s experience and resolve made the difference.
Saturday’s opening pair of finals showed two different routes to the top of Indiana volleyball: one team that never let go of control, and another that had to absorb a punch before landing the final one. For Lutheran, it was validation of a season built on belief. For Benton Central, it was history.
In Other News...
Urban Meyer Just Added Fuel To Indianas CFP Debate
Urban Meyer added another layer to the College Football Playoff debate this week by questioning how the committee is sorting out Indiana and Ohio State. He said he was confused by the gap between No. 4 Indiana and No. 12 Ohio State, especially with the Buckeyes holding a head-to-head win over the Hoosiers, and he took aim at the committees approach to nonconference schedules while arguing Ohio States ranking does not match how it has played.
For Indiana, the comments only sharpen an argument that has already been simmering around the programs place in the playoff picture. The Hoosiers record and rsum have kept them in the upper tier of the rankings, while Ohio States own profile includes a notable win over Indiana, creating a messy comparison the committee will have to keep defending. Meyers history with Ohio State also hangs over the discussion, which makes his criticism hard to separate from his old ties to the program. [Read more 🡒]
Indiana Just Reclaimed Control Of A Big Ten Title Shot
Indianas path to the Big Ten championship game suddenly looks a lot clearer. Sitting in second place at 5-1, the Hoosiers now control their own fate after Ohio States consecutive losses reshuffled the top of the standings, giving Indiana a chance to finish the job without needing help from anyone else.
The twist, of course, is that the margin for error is still thin, and the leagues tiebreaker rules could come into play if Indiana slips again in conference play. Their October meeting with Ohio State already carried an asterisk after both quarterbacks were injured during the game, a reminder of how quickly the title picture can change in this league and why every remaining result matters so much. [Read more 🡒]
Indiana Just Got A Reminder How Little Margin It Has Left
After nine straight weeks to open the 2026 season, Indiana finally got a breather in Week 10, but the idle weekend did little to ease the pressure on the stretch run. The Hoosiers sit at No. 6 in the AP top 25 and No. 5 in the coaches poll, a sign of how far they have climbed and how closely they are being watched as the regular season enters its final act.
What comes next leaves no room for a slip. Indiana still has USC, Washington and Purdue on the schedule, and the path to the Big Ten championship game is still there if the Hoosiers can run the table. It is the kind of setup that makes every remaining week feel heavier, because the margin for error is now about as thin as it gets. [Read more 🡒]