Indiana’s 38-0 win over Western Kentucky looked clean on the scoreboard, but the film told a more uneven story. The Hoosiers shook off a sluggish first half and pulled away after halftime, yet the performance still landed well short of what you’d expect from the then-No. 4 team in the country facing a Group of Six opponent.
That was the tone Curt Cignetti set at the break, too. When he spoke with NBC Sports’ Caroline Pineda, he put it bluntly: “We’ve got to play better.”
Indiana did exactly that after halftime. The Hoosiers piled up 308 yards over the final two quarters and turned a scoreless first quarter into a comfortable shutout. But the opening stretch was messy enough to keep the final grade from climbing much higher than solidly average.
The passing game still gave Indiana a real edge. Redshirt senior Josh Hoover finished 18 for 24 for 273 yards and two touchdowns, including a 79-yard strike to junior wide receiver Charlie Becker in the third quarter.
It was the first time in three games Hoover had more than 17 pass attempts, and his season completion rate sits at 72.5%, which ranks 18th in the country. He was efficient again, though four inaccurate throws in the first half kept the performance from being spotless.
Becker was one of the biggest reasons the receiver group earned top marks. The junior hauled in five catches for 127 yards, highlighted by the 79-yard touchdown that pushed Indiana ahead 24-0.
Hoover has a perfect passer rating - 158.3 - when targeting Becker this year. Indiana also made a point of getting junior Nick Marsh involved after he had just four catches across the previous two games.
Marsh responded with seven receptions for 81 yards on 10 targets. Three other receivers added six catches for 70 yards.
The ground game had a much slower start, even against a Western Kentucky defense that had already been gashed for an average of 279 rushing yards per game in its first two outings against the University of Nevada, Reno and the University of Georgia. Indiana managed only 53 rushing yards on 13 carries in the first half.
Things changed after intermission, when the running backs started finding room as the Hilltoppers wore down. The Hoosiers got 180 rushing yards from four backs in the second half alone, with junior Turbo Richard leading the way at 149 yards and a touchdown on 9.9 yards per carry.
The offensive line had a hand in both the good and the bad. Indiana didn’t allow a quarterback hurry on Hoover, giving him time to work through reads in the pocket.
At the same time, the unit gave up two sacks and four tackles for loss, and it couldn’t create much push in the run game before halftime. The second-half surge helped, but the slow start kept the grade from rising.
On defense, the front seven and secondary both settled in after some early issues. Indiana’s defensive line produced only one sack, coming from redshirt senior Tobi Osunsanmi, who also forced a fumble and added a tackle for loss.
Graduate student Tyrique Tucker had one TFL as well. Even with the shutout, the Hoosiers weren’t consistently disruptive up front, and that showed in the grade.
The linebackers made one of the game’s biggest plays. Redshirt senior Isaiah Jones intercepted Western Kentucky redshirt junior quarterback Brock Glenn with 1:07 left in the second quarter, jumping a receiver and returning it 21 yards to the Hilltoppers’ 3-yard line.
That set up a touchdown and gave Indiana momentum going into halftime. The group tightened up from there, holding Glenn to 33 passing yards in the second half after he had 87 in the first two quarters.
Junior Rolijah Hardy led the way with nine total tackles, two tackles for loss and one quarterback hurry.
The secondary also did enough to keep Western Kentucky from finding big plays. Redshirt senior Jamari Sharpe returned after leaving in the first quarter against North Texas in Week 1 and missing the Howard game, and he made an immediate impact with a seven-yard loss on a bubble screen in the first quarter and a pass breakup in the second.
Seventh-year Preston Zachman and graduate student Ryland Gandy combined for 14 tackles, and Gandy forced a fumble. Senior Amare Ferrell and sophomore Byron Baldwin each added 0.5 tackles for loss.
Indiana was without senior A.J. Harris, who Cignetti said has practiced “only 20%” in both fall camp and the regular season because of injuries, but the back end still limited Western Kentucky to 120 passing yards on 17 completions.
Special teams, though, were a problem again. Senior Nico Radicic was out, leaving redshirt senior Paddy McAteer as the top kicker.
McAteer missed a 54-yard field goal in the first quarter, giving Western Kentucky a short field, then later connected on a 21-yarder. Becker also handled one punt return for 17 yards, but Indiana’s return game didn’t do much beyond that.
Indiana now closes its four-game home stretch by opening Big Ten play Friday night against Northwestern. Kickoff is set for 8 p.m. at Memorial Stadium in Bloomington, and the game will air on FOX.
In Other News...
Indianas Big Ten Opener Just Got A Huge Eligibility Twist
The lead-up to Indianas Big Ten opener picked up an unexpected off-field wrinkle this week, as a Monroe Circuit Court judge granted a preliminary injunction that keeps three Hoosier athletes eligible for competition. IU football players Kellan Wyatt and Stephen Daley are among the athletes covered, along with IU basketball forward Sam Alexis, after the temporary restraining order in the broader lawsuit against the NCAA expired and left them waiting on the next court ruling.
For Indiana football, the timing matters most because the injunction allows Daley and Wyatt to play in the upcoming conference game. The case involves 97 athletes, so the decision reaches beyond Bloomington, but the immediate effect is on a Hoosiers team that suddenly has two more available pieces as it gets ready for league play. [Read more 🡒]
Indianas Frontcourt Picture Just Changed As NCAA Faces New Fight
A Monroe County Circuit Court ruling this week has added another layer to the college basketball offseason, and Indiana is right in the middle of it. Judge Kara Krothe granted a preliminary injunction to nearly 90 athletes in the state, opening the door to a fifth year of eligibility and putting several familiar names back in the conversation for another season.
For Indiana, the ripple effects could matter in a frontcourt that is still taking shape as roster decisions continue to evolve around the sport. The ruling reaches beyond one program and could alter the late-summer landscape across the country, though the NCAA is expected to fight it on appeal and keep the issue tied up a while longer. [Read more 🡒]
Indiana Just Got A Defensive Boost With More Uncertainty Ahead
A Monroe County judge has given Indiana a short-term defensive boost, at least for now, by opening the door for Stephen Daley and Kellan Wyatt to keep playing while a larger fight over NCAA eligibility rules works its way through the courts. The preliminary injunction from judge Kara Krothe applies to 97 student-athletes and temporarily blocks the associations five-for-five rule, which has become a flashpoint because it leaves the 2022 high school class without an extra year of eligibility.
For Indiana, the immediate effect is straightforward: two players who might have been sidelined by the new guidelines are still available as the Hoosiers move through the season. The longer-term picture is less settled, though, because the lawsuit is only beginning and the NCAA is expected to appeal, leaving the status of that rule and the players affected by it very much in play. [Read more 🡒]