Michigan is making a quarterback change, and it’s happening on the eve of a massive test.
Freshman Tommy Carr is expected to start Saturday against No. 6 Indiana after stepping in and helping Michigan rally past Penn State last week, according to CBS Sports’ Matt Zenitz. The move sends former top recruit Bryce Underwood to the backup role, at least for now.
Carr didn’t light up the stat sheet through the air, finishing 5 of 7 for 47 yards. But Michigan looked cleaner with him at quarterback, and he gave the offense a needed jolt on the ground as well, rushing four times for 36 yards and the game-sealing touchdown. That was enough to push Kyle Whittingham toward a full change under center.
The timing makes the decision feel significant. Making the switch before Indiana suggests this isn’t just a short-term adjustment for one game. It looks more like Michigan has decided Underwood’s stretch as the starter had gone as far as it could.
The numbers back that up. Michigan is averaging just 22.7 points per game, which ranks 105th nationally, and turnovers have repeatedly wiped out chances to score. That’s a tough combination for any team, especially one with a defense strong enough to hang around in the Big Ten.
Underwood’s season told the same story. In six starts, he completed 58.1% of his passes for 924 yards, five touchdowns and six interceptions. Strip out the UTEP game - when he went 76% for 223 yards and two touchdowns - and that completion rate falls to 53.5%.
Whittingham had been signaling that a change might be coming since the opener, when Michigan barely got by Western Michigan in controversial fashion on a last-second Hail Mary. The sense around the program all season was that he wasn’t satisfied with how the offense functioned with Underwood running it.
The problem wasn’t just accuracy. Michigan also lacked explosive plays. The Wolverines rank 119th nationally in pass plays of 20 yards with just 13 this season, which made the offense feel stuck even when Underwood’s physical talent showed up on the field.
Carr, by contrast, gives Michigan a different kind of hope. The grandson of legendary Michigan coach Lloyd Carr and the brother of Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr, he came to Ann Arbor as a four-star recruit in the 2026 class out of Saline, Michigan.
He signed with the Wolverines knowing the starting job might not come until his junior year. That timeline changed fast.
Now he gets thrown into the fire against an Indiana defense that remains one of the best in the country, even if the Hoosiers haven’t matched the dominance of last year’s national title team. Indiana will also be looking to answer after letting its game against Ohio State slip away.
For Michigan, the message with Carr seems clear: don’t try to be something bigger than you are. Just run the offense efficiently, stay on schedule and use the run game to keep things moving.
That leaves the biggest question of all hanging over Bryce Underwood.
Michigan poured major money into flipping him from LSU and bringing him home, but after a season and a half of disappointing play as the starter, the program is moving on. Underwood was supposed to be the quarterback who changed everything. Instead, he’s become one of the defining disappointments of the NIL era.
What happens next is anyone’s guess, though a transfer seems likely if he looks for a new start this offseason. Plenty of teams will still see the talent and dream on what he could become. But his struggles may also push him away from the top tier of portal options.
Programs such as Miami, Oregon, Indiana, Georgia, Texas, LSU and others should all be in the market for a quarterback. The real question is whether any of them would bet on Underwood’s ceiling after seeing the floor he’s hit at Michigan.
A different kind of destination might make more sense. Houston, where Connor Weigman has revived his career after struggling at Texas A&M, offers one possible blueprint. That kind of environment could fit Underwood better - a place with a staff willing to invest serious time in teaching him what he does best and how to make it work.
In Other News...
Indiana Fans Just Got A Bigger Reason To Watch Josh Hoover
Josh Hoovers rise to the top of the Big Ten quarterback rankings adds another layer to a conference race that has already been thinned by injuries and uneven play. With the rankings pared down from eight quarterbacks to five, Hoover now sits ahead of a group that still includes Purdues Ryan Browne, whose recent performance was enough to push him into the top five despite a loss, along with Northwesterns Hunter Maiava and Nebraskas Jeff Colandrea.
For Indiana fans, Hoovers new standing gives them an even clearer reason to keep an eye on him as Week 8 approaches. The competition around him has shifted quickly, especially after Ohio States Julian Sayin was injured, and the latest shuffle underscores how much the Big Tens quarterback picture has changed in a short span. [Read more 🡒]
Michigans Respect For Indiana Just Raised The Stakes In Ann Arbor
Michigan coach Kyle Whittingham spent part of his pregame availability giving Indiana a level of respect that usually tells you plenty about the matchup before anyone takes the field. He pointed to Curt Cignettis team as a balanced, veteran group that takes care of the ball, the kind of profile that tends to travel well and force opponents to stay sharp from the opening snap.
The other wrinkle is on Michigans side, where Whittingham said the Wolverines will turn to freshman quarterback Tommy Carr against Indiana. His mobility and efficiency were part of the rationale, but it also adds another layer to a game already carrying more intrigue because of what Indiana has built. When a conference opponent talks this carefully about your strengths, it usually means the margin for error gets a lot thinner in Ann Arbor. [Read more 🡒]
Ohio State Faces A Huge QB Question After Indiana Fallout
Julian Sayins elbow injury has left Ohio State with a major question under center, and it comes on the heels of the Indiana game in a way that could shape the rest of the Buckeyes season. Ryan Day has not settled on a replacement yet, but he did offer a pointed endorsement of Luke Fahey, noting the backups work ethic and competitiveness even with limited game experience.
Faheys challenge now is the one every young quarterback eventually faces in Columbus or anywhere else: turning practice promise into reliable production when the bullets start flying. Day acknowledged the rough edges that can show up in live action, but his confidence in Faheys development suggests the Buckeyes believe they have at least one viable path forward while the depth chart remains unsettled. [Read more 🡒]