Monshun Sales’ decision to pick Indiana over Alabama on Friday afternoon landed like a warning shot for the Crimson Tide.
The nation’s top-ranked wide receiver announced his commitment on The Pat McAfee Show, choosing the Hoosiers over Alabama, Texas, LSU, and Ohio State. The 6’5 210 WR becomes the highest-ranked recruit to commit to Indiana in program history.
For Alabama, the miss stings beyond one player. Sales grew up in the Yellowhammer State and even carried the nickname “Bama” growing up, which made this feel like a recruitment the Crimson Tide should have been able to close. For much of the race, it looked like Alabama and Indiana were the two teams fighting it out, and losing that battle only adds to the unease around Kalen DeBoer’s current recruiting cycle.
That unease is already backed up by the numbers. Alabama’s class currently sits 32nd in the country in Rivals’ Industry Recruiting Rankings, a spot that would have been unthinkable in the Nick Saban years. The Crimson Tide are trailing programs like Minnesota, Vanderbilt, Wisconsin, and Georgia Tech.
DeBoer has already said this would be a smaller class, but the bigger issue is the quality of the haul. Alabama has just 1 5-star recruit and 3 4-stars, with 10 3-stars filling out the class. Plenty of coaches will say rankings don’t matter, but it’s hard to ignore how few blue-chip names are headed to Tuscaloosa right now.
That’s what makes Sales’ choice feel so significant. Alabama used to live at the top of recruiting boards, with Saban’s final five classes finishing 2nd, 1st, 2nd, 1st, and 2nd. The program’s rise under Saban was built on recruiting nationally and landing elite talent from places like Hawaii, California, and even the Northeast.
Now the Tide are trying to find their footing in a different era. The old Alabama advantage no longer carries the same weight, and the staff may have to lean harder on the transfer portal if this is the direction they want to go. But that path comes with its own risk, as Florida State and Colorado have already seen how quickly things can change there.
The reality is simple: the Nick Saban era is over, and the pre-NIL world that helped Alabama overpower the field is gone too. DeBoer and his staff have to adjust fast, because misses like Sales are starting to pile up and the cost could be real.
In Other News...
The 5 Portal Moves That Built Curt Cignetti's Indiana Powerhouse
Curt Cignettis rise at Indiana has been built as much in the transfer portal as on the practice field, and the core of that turnaround is easy to spot. In just two seasons, the Hoosiers have gone from trying to change their trajectory to playing at a level that produced a National Championship, with portal additions like Fernando Mendoza, DAngelo Ponds, Elijah Sarratt, Pat Coogan and Roman Hemby giving the roster the kind of immediate impact that can reshape a program.
What makes the list even more important for Indiana is how many of those moves became proof points for Cignettis approach. Mendoza, Ponds, Sarratt, Coogan and Hemby each filled major roles and helped push the Hoosiers into a different tier, while some of that talent has already moved on to the NFL. The bigger question now is how long Indiana can keep stacking wins in the portal before other programs start treating the Hoosiers the way Indiana once treated everyone else. [Read more 🡒]
Curt Cignetti And Indiana Just Became A Blueprint For Contenders
Rhett Lashlees new deal at SMU was always going to say something about where the Mustangs see themselves in the college football pecking order. The extension, signed in October 2025, pushed him into the sports top financial tier at more than $9 million a year and underscored how aggressively SMU has invested in its football future, from the coaching staff to the player budget to keeping the roster intact.
What makes Lashlees stance more interesting is the larger argument behind it. With college footballs power structure feeling a little more open than it used to, he has pointed to the idea that programs outside the traditional heavyweights can build real staying power if they commit the resources and trust the process. For Indiana fans, it is the kind of validation that matters, because it suggests the path to contention may no longer belong to only the usual suspects. [Read more 🡒]