Indiana Just Got Pulled Back Into A Familiar Respect Fight

Indiana football seeks justice from the College Football Playoff committee after their questionable drop in rankings despite consistent on-field excellence.

The College Football Playoff committee handed Indiana football a head-scratcher Tuesday night, dropping the 8-1 defending national champions to No. 9 after a bye week.

That move came after the Hoosiers had been slotted No. 4 a week earlier. CFP Selection Committee chair Hunter Yurachek called Indiana “the victim of having a bye week,” but that explanation did little to calm the reaction. Indiana head coach Curt Cignetti took to X and mocked the committee for rewarding teams with multiple losses while punishing a one-loss Hoosiers team.

The frustration made sense. Indiana’s opponents went 1-8 during the bye week, which pushed the Hoosiers’ strength of schedule down to No. 42 in the country, according to ESPN.

Even so, Indiana entered the week with the No. 8 strength of record. That made the committee’s decision to place the Hoosiers behind three two-loss SEC teams - No.

3 Alabama, No. 6 Texas and No.

8 Tennessee - hard to square.

The ranking didn’t linger long as the Hoosiers’ problem. Four days later, they answered on the field.

With seventh-year quarterback Grant Wilson making his first start in more than two years, Indiana beat No. 18 USC 27-13 at Memorial Stadium in Bloomington.

It was a statement win, and it came against one of the Big Ten’s highest-scoring offenses. USC redshirt senior quarterback Jayden Maiava, who entered the game completing 66.9% of his passes for 280.4 yards per game with a 157.2 passer rating, was picked off three times - a season high.

Indiana’s defense has been the backbone all season, and it showed again. The Hoosiers are allowing 13.8 points per game, the fourth-lowest mark in the nation, and that unit helped push Indiana to its ninth victory.

Cignetti said after the game that he hadn’t seen other results around the country, but he made clear he expects the rankings to sort themselves out eventually.

“It doesn’t really matter who’s where,” Cignetti said. “There’s a lot of football left.”

Khobie Martin wasn’t nearly as diplomatic. The redshirt sophomore running back called Indiana’s No. 9 spot “B.S.”

“At the end of the day, we proved that whatever the committee says, it doesn’t matter to us,” Martin said postgame. “We’re just going to go out there on the field and dominate.”

Redshirt senior linebacker Isaiah Jones also pushed back on the perception around the program, saying the national media has “disrespected” the Hoosiers for years. Jones was one of 13 players who stayed in Bloomington after former head coach Tom Allen was fired.

That skepticism has followed Indiana through Cignetti’s first season in Bloomington and beyond. National analysts questioned whether the Hoosiers belonged even after they went 11-1 in the regular season and reached the first round of the CFP, a remarkable turnaround from a 3-9 season the year before and years of little success. After Indiana’s 27-17 loss to Notre Dame in 2024, ESPN’s Kirk Herbstreit said on College GameDay that Indiana was “outclassed” by Notre Dame and argued the committee should focus on the best 12 teams, saying Indiana didn’t belong.

That view didn’t hold up against what happened elsewhere in the first round. Of the four teams that lost in the 2024 CFP first round, Indiana’s 10-point defeat was the smallest margin.

Even during last season’s undefeated run, the Hoosiers were met with the same doubts. Many picked against them, and Indiana kept proving people wrong on the way to the national championship. The same storyline has returned this season, and the Hoosiers have shown no interest in letting it dictate anything.

They still control their own path. If they beat Washington and Purdue over the next two weeks, they’ll clinch a spot in the Big Ten Championship Game.

For now, Indiana sits at No. 9.

After beating USC the way it did, though, the Hoosiers have earned a move up. The committee owes them that.

In Other News...

Indiana Just Proved Something Bigger Than Beating USC

Indianas win over USC at Memorial Stadium did more than add another notch to an already impressive season. At 9-1, the Hoosiers have put themselves in a position that would have sounded far-fetched not long ago, and the way they handled the Trojans offered a reminder that this team can win in more than one style. The defense bent plenty, giving up yardage, but it kept USC out of the end zone often enough and came up with the kind of interceptions that swing a game.

Grant Wilsons first start of the season gave Indiana a different look on offense, and he delivered several big plays even as the unit remained uneven at times. The inconsistency did not keep the Hoosiers from controlling the result, which is part of what makes this stretch so notable for Indiana. This was not just a good win over a name opponent, but another sign that the Hoosiers have grown into a team that can survive pressure, absorb mistakes and still finish the job. [Read more 🡒]

Lincoln Riley Could Feel What Indiana Just Did To USC

USCs trip to Bloomington ended with a 27-13 loss to Indiana, another reminder that the Trojans still have work to do if they want to be taken seriously in the national picture. It was USCs third loss of the season, and Lincoln Riley pointed to the kind of self-inflicted problems that can sink a road team, from turnovers to missed chances in the scoring area.

Riley said the Trojans have made progress, but he also made clear that progress alone is not the same as being ready to compete at a championship level. For Indiana, it was the kind of win that can change the tone around a program, while for USC it leaves the bigger question hanging: how much better can this team get before the season slips further away? [Read more 🡒]

Indiana Faces A Huge Availability Question Against USC

USC heads into its Big Ten matchup with Indiana in unusually good shape, at least by the standards of a conference grind that has already tested depth across the league. The Trojans are carrying no new significant injuries, their healthiest status in Big Ten play so far, and that matters with a game like this where every available starter can tilt the matchup. Safety Trestin Castro and defensive lineman Jahkeem Stewart still appear on the injury report, but tight end Mark Bowman has returned to full participation, giving USC a cleaner look than it has had in recent weeks.

Indianas availability picture is more complicated. Starting quarterback Josh Hoover has been removed from the injury report, which is obviously a positive sign for the Hoosiers, but they will still be without starters Joe Brunner and Turbo Richard because of injuries. In a conference game where roster stability can matter as much as scheme, Indiana will be trying to manage those absences while hoping its quarterback situation stays clear enough to keep pace. [Read more 🡒]