Indiana had spent most of the season surviving tight games. In Seattle, that formula finally broke.
Washington outlasted the Hoosiers 27-24 in overtime on Saturday afternoon after Paddy McAteer missed a 37-yard field goal that would have kept the game going. The defeat sent Indiana to 9-2 and left its route to the Big Ten Championship Game and College Football Playoff more complicated.
Special teams ended up at the center of the collapse. Nicolas Radicic had a 46-yard field goal blocked on Indiana’s first possession of the second half, then McAteer came in and drilled a 34-yarder later in the third quarter before adding an extra point. But when Indiana needed one more kick to extend overtime, McAteer pushed the 37-yard attempt wide left and Washington walked off with the win.
For a team whose coach keeps hammering the importance of not beating itself, Indiana delivered too many self-inflicted mistakes again. This time, it couldn’t escape them.
The quarterback picture also shifted again. After two games with Grant Wilson as the starter, Curt Cignetti went back to Josh Hoover midway through the third quarter. Wilson had his moments, including a rushing touchdown in the first quarter, but Indiana’s offense stalled after its first two scoring drives.
Hoover gave the offense a jolt right away. On his first series, the TCU transfer hit Charlie Becker for 34 yards and added a 12-yard scramble to help set up McAteer’s first field goal. Hoover looked more comfortable attacking downfield than he had against Michigan and Minnesota, and later found Nick Marsh for a 35-yard touchdown that put Indiana ahead 24-17 in the fourth quarter.
It still wasn’t clean. The Hoosiers had trouble sustaining drives for much of the day, and with two regular-season games left, the quarterback situation remains something to watch. But Hoover did show some encouraging signs after recent injury concerns.
The injury situation around him may be the bigger issue. Indiana already entered the game without starting right guard Joe Brunner, then lost center Bray Lynch and right tackle Adedamola Ajani during the contest.
Ajani did return, but the offensive line had to be rearranged on the fly. Austin Leibfried slid from right guard to center, while Baylor Wilkin and Sam Simpson were pushed into bigger roles.
Even with all that shuffling, the line held up well enough at times, especially on Hoover’s touchdown drive in the fourth quarter. Still, the depth chart is getting stretched thin.
The Hoosiers were already missing starting linebacker Rolijah Hardy, cornerback A.J. Harris and running back Turbo Richard, who sat out for the second straight game. Nick Marsh later needed assistance leaving the field after an apparent injury late in the fourth quarter.
And the concerns don’t stop there. Indiana’s defense gave up more than 400 yards for the second straight week, the first time that has happened under Cignetti. Washington kept finding ways down the field, and quarterback Demond Williams’ mobility again exposed one of Indiana’s recurring defensive problems.
Indiana still has plenty in front of it. But with injuries piling up and the margin for error gone, Saturday’s loss raised real questions about what this team will look like over the final stretch.
In Other News...
Tennessee Suddenly Has A New Role In Another Teams Playoff Fate
Oregons playoff path got a little cleaner with a recent win over Michigan State, and the Ducks have now strung together four straight victories to stay in the mix. Even so, the No. 13 Ducks are still in the position of needing help, with several higher-ranked teams ahead of them and a crowded stretch of games still to come that could reshape the College Football Playoff picture.
Tennessee is part of that traffic jam, along with BYU, Indiana, Iowa, Ohio State and Michigan, all of whom have upcoming games that could swing Oregons standing one way or another. For the Ducks, the next few weeks are less about style points and more about scoreboard watching, because their postseason fate may depend as much on what happens elsewhere as on anything they do themselves. [Read more 🡒]
Indianas Playoff Push Suddenly Has One Brutal New Problem
Indianas playoff push ran into a harsh roadblock at Husky Stadium, where the No. 8 Hoosiers came up short in a 27-24 overtime loss to Washington. The game had the feel of one that might be decided by a single mistake, and it was. Washington forced the extra period after Demond Williams Jr. found Decker DeGraaf for a late touchdown, then Tyler Robles delivered a 46-yard field goal to put the Huskies ahead.
For Indiana, the missed chance stung even more because the Hoosiers had a response in hand and could not finish it. Their 37-yard field goal attempt was blocked, leaving them with a second loss and a 9-2 record as the margin for error shrinks. Washington, meanwhile, moved to 7-4 and left Indiana with a brutal reminder that one close finish can change the entire shape of a season. [Read more 🡒]
Indianas Quarterback Decision Just Put New Pressure On Curt Cignetti
Indianas quarterback situation took another turn against Washington when Curt Cignetti went back to Josh Hoover early in the third quarter, looking for a jolt in a tied game. Cade Wilson had started the previous games, but the switch gave the Hoosiers a different look at a moment when the offense needed something to change, and Hoover helped steady things right away.
Hoover responded by guiding Indiana back into the lead with a field goal drive and a touchdown pass, giving Cignetti a decision that now carries a little more weight going forward. The move may have been made for the moment, but it also sharpened the larger question around the position, where the Hoosiers have to decide whether this was simply a spark or the start of something more permanent. [Read more 🡒]
