Indiana has produced plenty of elite high school basketball talent over the last 15 years, but Bloomington hasn’t always been the landing spot. Since 2010, only four Indiana Mr. Basketball winners have chosen the Hoosiers, and a handful of the state’s best prospects ended up becoming major what-ifs for IU fans.
Gary Harris is one of the earliest and most painful examples. The Hamilton Southeastern star from Fishers won Indiana Mr.
Basketball in 2012 and came in as the No. 11 overall recruit and No. 2 shooting guard in the ESPNU100. But Indiana’s 28-66 record over the three seasons before his decision made the Hoosiers a tough sell, and Harris chose Tom Izzo and Michigan State instead.
He made that call look right with a strong Spartan career, averaging 14.9 points and 3.3 rebounds per game over two seasons, earning First-Team All-Big Ten honors in 2014, and going on to be drafted No. 19 overall in the 2014 NBA Draft. Harris has since built an impressive NBA résumé with the Nuggets, Magic, Bucks and Pistons.
Trey Lyles left an even deeper scar because he had once been tied to Indiana so early. Before he ever played a game for Arsenal Tech High School, he committed to the Hoosiers in September 2010 and stayed pledged for more than two years.
Then, before his junior season, he backed off that commitment and picked Kentucky and John Calipari. Lyles went on to win Indiana Mr.
Basketball in 2014, then had a productive lone season in Lexington. He made the 2015 All-SEC Freshman Team, helped Kentucky reach the Final Four, and was selected 12th overall by the Jazz in 2015.
In the NBA, he has averaged 7.6 points and 4.3 rebounds across 650 games.
Kyle Guy’s decision hit differently because of what followed. The Lawrence Central standout chose Virginia over Indiana and later said he just never really clicked with then-IU head coach Tom Crean.
The 2016 Indiana Mr. Basketball then put together a standout run in Charlottesville, averaging 12.9 points, 3.0 rebounds and 2.1 assists per game while shooting 42.5% from three.
Hoosier fans had to watch him win a national title and take home Final Four Most Outstanding Player honors in 2019, which made the miss feel even bigger.
Jaren Jackson Jr. was another elite in-state talent Indiana couldn’t keep home. After splitting his high school career between Park Tudor and La Lumiere School, he chose Michigan State over the Hoosiers.
The move paid off immediately for the Spartans, as Jackson was named Big Ten Freshman of the Year and Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year in 2018. He then went fourth overall in the 2018 NBA Draft and has become one of the league’s top two-way players, earning two All-Star nods and the NBA Defensive Player of the Year award in 2023.
He is averaging 18.6 points per game over 455 professional games.
The newest name on the list is Braylon Mullins, and the sting is still fresh. The Greenfield-Central star put together one of the most eye-catching senior seasons in state history, averaging 32.9 points, 7.2 rebounds, 4.2 assists and 3.7 steals per game while shooting over 47% from deep.
A consensus 5-star prospect and the No. 12 overall player in the 2025 class according to 247Sports, Mullins was heavily pursued by Mark Woodson and Indiana, but he chose UConn instead. He made an immediate impact in Storrs, starting 29 games and averaging 12.0 points and 3.5 rebounds as a freshman while shooting 42.1% from the floor.
Then came the March moment that really landed: his buzzer-beater against Duke to send UConn to the Final Four. Mullins is now set up for an even bigger sophomore season.
In Other News...
Indiana May Finally Be Showing The Toughness Fans Have Wanted
Indianas exhibition offered a better glimpse of the identity this roster has been chasing, with Samet Yigitoglu and Aiden Sherrell giving the frontcourt a more physical edge and the backcourt doing enough to keep the offense moving. Even with the perimeter shot not falling, the ball was finding open looks, and the overall effort level suggested a team that is starting to look more connected on both ends.
Aiden Sherrell was the most encouraging sign, pairing scoring with rim protection and rebounding in a way Indiana has been hoping to see from its interior pieces. Freshman Prince-Alexander Moody also stood out for his energy and defensive activity, giving the Hoosiers another jolt of toughness, and the coaching staff came away sounding upbeat about where those young players can go from here. [Read more 🡒]
Two Unexpected Hoosiers Just Changed The Rotation Conversation
Indianas exhibition tune-up at Simon Skjodt Assembly Hall offered a first real look at how this summer roster might sort itself out before the trip to Lima. Representing the United States, IU handled Collge Jean-de-Brbeuf of Canada 98-64, and the game gave the staff a chance to see which pieces looked comfortable in a faster, looser setting ahead of the FISU America Games.
Aiden Sherrell led the way with 16 points, six rebounds and three blocks, while Markus Burton filled the box score with 11 points, six assists, six rebounds, three steals and a block in 22 minutes. The more interesting part for Indiana, though, is how the rotation conversation is starting to shift around the edges as the Hoosiers prepare to depart Saturday for Peru, where some of these early impressions could matter a lot more once the games begin. [Read more 🡒]