Indiana Fans Have Seen This CFP Problem Before With Alabama

With Indiana's unexpected ranking drop as a cautionary tale, Alabama's position in the College Football Playoff is under scrutiny after recent setbacks and their remaining schedule's performance.

Alabama’s playoff case took a hit over the weekend, and now the question is whether the College Football Playoff committee will treat the Crimson Tide the same way it treated Indiana.

Indiana’s tumble from No. 4 in the first rankings to No. 9 last week came even though the Hoosiers didn’t play. The damage was done by the teams around them.

Every Big Ten opponent Indiana had faced lost while the Hoosiers were idle, and that made their one loss look worse while their narrow wins started to feel a lot less sturdy. With no game of its own to strengthen the résumé, Indiana slid hard.

Now Alabama is in a similar spot, at least in terms of how the committee might view a résumé that just got weaker. The Tide were one of the teams that passed Indiana last week, and they’ve built a strong profile overall. But their schedule took a pounding this weekend, too.

Here’s the key issue: of Alabama’s nine power conference opponents, only three won on Saturday. Those three were Alabama’s two losses, Georgia and Tennessee, plus Florida State.

That means all seven of Alabama’s wins against power conference teams came against opponents that lost this weekend. In other words, every SEC win on the Tide’s résumé was undercut in the same way Indiana’s Big Ten wins were two weeks ago.

The full picture looks like this:

No. 3 Alabama

45-17 W at No. 11 Kentucky (7-3, 21-14 L vs Florida) - *second consecutive loss

50-36 W vs Florida State (5-5, 16-10 W at Pitt)

49-18 W vs No. 17 South Carolina (6-4, 34-6 L at Arkansas)

56-23 W vs Mississippi State (4-6, 41-9 L vs Auburn) *sixth consecutive loss

20-17 L vs No. 1 Georgia (9-1, 48-21 W vs No. 22 Missouri)

26-10 L vs No. 14 Tennessee (8-2, 22-7 W at Texas A&M)

31-20 W vs Texas A&M (4-6, 22-7 L vs No, 14 Tennessee) *third consecutive loss

31-13 W vs No. 14 LSU (6-4, 22-21 L vs No. 6 Texas)

21-6 W at Vanderbilt (4-6)

The difference between Alabama and Indiana is that the Tide’s losses kept winning. Georgia is still sitting near the top of the sport, and Alabama can point to the fact that it pushed the Bulldogs harder than anyone else.

Tennessee is also still building its own playoff case. Indiana, by contrast, watched its lone loss to Ohio State age badly as the Buckeyes kept rolling.

That’s why the committee may not punish Alabama as harshly as it did Indiana. Still, if the committee is going to stick to the same logic it used before, there’s a case for the Tide to slip.

Alabama probably won’t fall five spots the way Indiana did. But is there a reason to keep the Crimson Tide ahead of 9-0 UCLA, especially with the Bruins’ road win at Oregon looking stronger by the week?

Probably not. Notre Dame could also enter the conversation after its blowout win, since the Irish own the top-10 victory Alabama still lacks.

If Alabama does drop, it likely won’t be by much. One or two spots feels like the range. Then again, the committee has already shown this season that its own precedent can be a moving target.

In Other News...

Indianas Big Ten Dream Suddenly Comes With Real Danger

Indianas push toward the Big Ten title game has reached the part of the season where every result starts to feel like a trap door. The Hoosiers and UCLA still sit at the top of the standings with straightforward paths to the conference championship game if they keep winning, but the margin for error is gone and the race around them is crowded enough to make every Saturday matter.

Oregon, Ohio State and Iowa are still technically alive, though each is navigating a much tougher route through the tiebreaker maze and the remaining schedule. With the Big Tens championship-game rules now looming over the final stretch, Indianas dream is still very much intact, but the leagues December 5 title game in Indianapolis is close enough to feel real and far enough away to remain just out of reach. [Read more 🡒]

Indiana Fans Have Every Right To Be Furious With The CFP Committee

Indianas place in the College Football Playoff picture took another hit in the latest rankings, and the frustration around the program only grew because the Hoosiers did not even play. While Alabama stayed put at No. 3, the committee left Indiana to absorb the drop, a move that only sharpened the sense that the criteria are being applied unevenly from one team to the next.

Hunter Yurachek pointed to Alabamas strength of schedule and record when explaining the Crimson Tides standing, but that rationale has not sat well with Indiana supporters watching the race unfold. When a team can lose ground without taking the field while another holds steady after its defeated opponents also stumble, it is hard to blame Hoosier fans for feeling the process is inconsistent. [Read more 🡒]

Cignetti Isnt Letting Indianas USC Win Hide A Growing Concern

Curt Cignetti had plenty to like after Indianas win over USC, but he was just as quick to point out what still needs cleaning up before the Hoosiers move on to Washington. The victory gave the program a boost, yet Cignetti made clear that defensive lapses, penalties and special teams mistakes are not the kind of habits he wants following them into the next game.

Washington brings a different kind of challenge, and Cignetti singled out mobile quarterback Demond Williams as a player Indiana will have to account for. He also pointed to issues in the snapping and holding operation on special teams, a reminder that the Hoosiers cannot afford to lean on one good result while the details still need work. [Read more 🡒]