Rece Davis shook up his latest AP Top 25 ballot after a wild Week 10, and the biggest takeaway for the SEC was simple: Georgia got the top spot, but nobody else from the league cracked his top five.
The ESPN College GameDay host put Georgia at No. 1, then filled out the rest of his top five with Notre Dame, Utah, Miami and undefeated UCLA. Indiana came next at No. 6, followed by Texas, Tennessee and Alabama.
Davis explained on “The Pat McAfee Show” on Wednesday that Miami’s first loss didn’t push the Hurricanes too far down his list.
“I didn’t think Miami deserved to be overly punished, and I wanted to reward Utah for that great win against BYU,” Davis said.
Miami’s 31-24 loss at Notre Dame came after the Hurricanes had built a 24-3 lead early in the second half. Mario Cristobal said he was “beyond upset” that tight end Elija Lofton’s fourth-down catch in the end zone with 3:36 left was not ruled a touchdown. Davis still kept Miami at No. 4, three spots higher than the selection committee, which dropped the Hurricanes from No. 1 to No. 7 on Tuesday.
Notre Dame jumped all the way to No. 2 after CJ Carr threw for 319 yards and three touchdowns in the Fighting Irish’s 8-1 win over the top-ranked team. It was Notre Dame’s first win over a No. 1 team since Clemson in 2020, and Carr’s performance pushed him further into the Heisman conversation.
Utah held steady at No. 3 despite Davis calling the BYU game a mess in the best possible way.
“That was a wild roller coaster game that both teams seemed intent on bludgeoning the other and then would turn around and be ready to give the thing away,” Davis said.
Devon Dampier accounted for four touchdowns, and Utah’s defense picked off Bear Bachmeier four times in a 28-20 win that snapped a three-game losing streak to BYU. The Utes are 9-0 and sit second in both the AP poll and the CFP rankings.
Davis also kept UCLA high, but not quite high enough to crack the top three. He said he still wants to see more before moving the Bruins up again.
“I’m not sure, as well-coached and as good as UCLA is, I still wonder. I want to see them against an elite team, but I think you’ve got to respect the fact that nobody’s beaten them yet,” Davis said.
UCLA is 9-0 for the first time since 1998 under first-year coach Bob Chesney, one season after going 3-9. The Bruins’ only win over a ranked opponent came at Oregon in October, and they pulled away from Minnesota 34-20 on Saturday behind Ty Dieffenbach’s two 75-yard touchdown passes to Aidan Mizell in the fourth quarter.
Indiana landed at No. 6, three spots above its CFP ranking, and Davis said the Hoosiers have earned respect even if their résumé still has questions.
“And while I agree with the notion that Indiana really hasn’t beaten anybody at this point, I’ve got such respect for the fact that they know how to win games,” Davis said.
Indiana’s latest escape came against Minnesota. Paddy McAteer drilled a 60-yard field goal to force overtime, and backup quarterback Grant Wilson then found Charlie Becker for the winning score.
The Hoosiers had already beaten Michigan in overtime after a 19-15 loss to Ohio State on Oct. 17, and that Buckeyes team has since fallen to 6-3. Curt Cignetti summed it up afterward: “This team just finds a way.”
Davis sorted the SEC’s 7-2 teams by head-to-head results, which pushed Texas to No. 7, Tennessee to No. 8 and Alabama to No. 9.
“As we’ve talked about, I stacked up the SEC teams according to head-to-head because I think they’re all pretty similar,” Davis said.
That ordering differed from the committee’s, which had Alabama third, Texas sixth and Tennessee eighth. All three won in Week 10 anyway. Alabama beat LSU 31-13 in Baton Rouge behind three Keelon Russell touchdowns, Tennessee rolled Kentucky 34-6, and Texas rallied past Missouri 34-20 in Columbia after Arch Manning threw for 297 yards and three touchdowns.
Georgia stayed on top after its 42-7 win at Ole Miss, and Pete Golding didn’t sugarcoat what happened.
“Hats off to Kirby and Georgia, that was a butt-whipping,” Golding said.
Davis ranked nine SEC teams overall, including six in his top 15, with Ole Miss checking in at No. 13.
Georgia now turns to Missouri at 3:30 p.m. ET on Saturday, Tennessee visits Texas A&M at 3 p.m.
ET, and Texas heads to LSU.
In Other News...
Indiana Gets One Encouraging Sign Before Must Win USC Matchup
Indiana at least got one bit of positive injury news heading into a must-win matchup with USC, with quarterback Josh Hoover expected to be available after being left off the initial injury report. Coach Curt Cignetti still has not named a starter, but he said Hoover will be in uniform if he stays clear of the report, giving the Hoosiers some stability at the most important position as they try to keep their season on track.
The rest of the availability picture is less reassuring. Leading rusher Turbo Richard and defensive end Kellan Wyatt have already been ruled out, while cornerback A.J. Harris and linebacker Rolijah Hardy are listed as questionable, leaving Indiana with several key spots still unsettled. Even with Hoover trending in the right direction, the Hoosiers are heading into a game where every healthy body matters, and the final lineup could shape how much room they have to compete with USC. [Read more 🡒]
Indianas Quarterback Uncertainty Just Got Bigger Before USC
Indianas quarterback situation got a little murkier this week as Curt Cignetti sorted through a room already under scrutiny ahead of USC. Grant Wilson missed practice because of the flu, while Josh Hoover was held out for injury recovery, leaving the Hoosiers to lean more heavily on backup Jacob Bell, who drew praise from Cignetti for the way he handled his work on the field.
The timing is less than ideal with USC looming, especially with Cignetti already pointing to the Trojans offense and defense as a major test. Indiana also has some cleanup to do in other areas, including special teams, which adds another layer to a week that was already going to be about finding answers before kickoff. [Read more 🡒]
Urban Meyer Just Reignited Indianas CFP Respect Debate
Indianas place in the College Football Playoff conversation took another public hit this week when Urban Meyer weighed in on the rankings, and the former coach did not exactly defend the Hoosiers standing. On FOX, Meyer pointed out that Indiana slid from No. 4 to No. 9 even without playing in Week 10, using the drop as evidence that the committee may have overvalued the Hoosiers early on.
The larger debate around Indiana has only grown louder as Notre Dame and UCLA moved up in the rankings and the Big Ten and Big 12 continue to jockey for playoff representation. Meyers comments fed right into the skepticism around Indianas rsum, with unimpressive wins and a shaky strength of schedule becoming the central sticking points in how the Hoosiers are being judged. [Read more 🡒]