Let’s dive into the intriguing debate surrounding Fernando Mendoza’s ranking among the top college quarterbacks of the 21st century. Fresh off leading the Indiana Hoosiers to an undefeated College Football Playoff-winning season, Mendoza’s journey from Cal transfer to IU legend is nothing short of spectacular.
Yet, ESPN's Bill Connelly has him at No. 14.
Let’s break down why this ranking might be selling him short.
Mendoza’s spot behind renowned names like Baker Mayfield, Cam Newton, Vince Young, Tim Tebow, and Joe Burrow is understandable. These players have set benchmarks of greatness. However, there are several quarterbacks ranked ahead of Mendoza where the logic doesn’t quite add up.
Trevor Lawrence (Clemson Tigers, No. 11, 2018-20):
Lawrence’s college career was impressive, but his national championship win came with a powerhouse Clemson defense backing him. While Lawrence’s NFL career has shown promise, it hasn’t yet reached the heights expected of a generational talent.
Mendoza’s leadership and impact at Indiana arguably eclipse Lawrence’s college achievements.
Marcus Mariota (Oregon Ducks, No. 9, 2012-14):
Mariota’s Heisman-winning season was filled with stats, but his play was often more mechanical. His NFL struggles further highlight the gap between potential and performance.
Mendoza’s charisma and leadership at Indiana were game-changers, setting him apart from Mariota’s more reserved style.
Robert Griffin III (Baylor Bears, No. 10, 2008-11):
Griffin’s Heisman win was a pivotal moment for Baylor, but it’s hard to separate his accomplishments from the tumultuous era under Art Briles. Mendoza’s Heisman season at Indiana was more impactful, showcasing his ability to elevate a historically struggling program.
Colt McCoy (Texas Longhorns, No. 12, 2006-09):
McCoy’s productivity at Texas was undeniable, but he thrived in a well-established program. Mendoza, on the other hand, transformed Indiana into a national contender, a testament to his talent and determination.
Kyler Murray (Oklahoma Sooners, No. 7, 2015-18):
Murray’s Heisman and No. 1 NFL Draft pick status are impressive, but his collegiate success came in a system primed for quarterbacks.
Mendoza’s leadership and ability to galvanize his team mirror the legendary Tim Tebow, making a strong case for a higher ranking.
In conclusion, while Mendoza’s ranking at No. 14 acknowledges his incredible season, it may not fully capture the transformative impact he had at Indiana. His leadership, talent, and ability to elevate those around him suggest he deserves a spot higher on this prestigious list.