Curt Cignetti didn’t let Indiana’s place in history go quietly, even after the Hoosiers left the ESPY Awards without the Best Team trophy.
Indiana’s undefeated 2025 national championship squad was among the nominees at this week’s ceremony, and it had a real case. The Hoosiers finished 16-0, becoming major college football’s first team to do that since 1894. At least nine members of the team were in attendance in New York.
Instead, the award went to the NBA’s New York Knicks, whose run as the No. 3 seed in the East carried them to a dominant postseason and ended a long franchise drought. But Cignetti made it clear Friday on the Pat McAfee Show that he didn’t think Indiana’s accomplishment should have been brushed aside.
“You know, that natty 16-0 hadn’t happened in 136 years,” Cignetti said Friday on the Pat McAfee Show. “Now, how that team doesn’t win a certain award as the team of the year, you know, but some networks are consistent at getting it wrong.”
The comment fit into a longer-running tension between Cignetti and ESPN that has been building since the 2024 season. Indiana’s coach has repeatedly found himself on the receiving end of criticism from ESPN voices and commentators from Disney-owned sister outlets, especially after the Hoosiers’ College Football Playoff loss at Notre Dame. Paul Finebaum, in particular, took repeated shots at IU before eventually backing off.
This time, though, McAfee - an outspoken Indiana supporter who also works for ESPN - told Cignetti that fan voting played a major role in the ESPY result. That softened Cignetti’s stance a bit.
“You’re not beating them (New York fans), and there’s a lot of deserving teams in there,” Cignetti said.
Still, the message had already been delivered. Cignetti got his jab in, and the latest round in his back-and-forth with ESPN looks far from over.
In Other News...
Curt Cignetti Just Pulled Off The Recruiting Win Indiana Never Gets
Curt Cignettis run at Indiana has already rewritten what feels possible in Bloomington, and the latest proof came on the recruiting trail. Monshun Sales, a highly regarded wide receiver from Lawrence North High School in Indianapolis, gave the Hoosiers a commitment that fits the kind of momentum the program has built under Cignetti, with Indiana coming off a 27-2 stretch and a perfect 16-0 season that ended with a National Championship.
Sales is ranked by Rivals as the No. 7 overall recruit in the 2027 cycle, which is the sort of profile Indiana usually has to watch head somewhere else. Instead, the Hoosiers landed a player who had plenty of heavyweight options in the mix, a sign that Cignettis pitch is resonating in a way Indiana football rarely gets to enjoy. [Read more 🡒]
IU Fans Have One Big Question About Monshun Sales' Ceiling
The conversation around Monshun Sales is already starting to sound familiar for Indiana fans who have watched elite receiver talent come through the sport and then wondered how high the ceiling really is. A review of the top two wideout recruits from each class from 2016 through 2025 offers a useful backdrop, showing that most of those players turned into productive college receivers and many eventually heard their names called in the NFL Draft.
For IU, the interesting part is not just where Sales is ranked in the 2027 class, but how often this kind of profile has translated into real value at the next level. The piece points to former Hoosier James Hardy and recent standout Elijah Sarratt as reference points, then walks through a decade of outcomes without settling the biggest question of all, whether Sales is headed toward star status, a solid college run, or something in between. [Read more 🡒]