Curt Cignetti didn’t exactly give himself a glowing scouting report when asked to revisit his days as a quarterback.
On Saturday, the IU football coach broke down what he looks for in prospects on the BTN Tailgate pregame show from Bloomington, and that led him right back to his own playing career at Morgantown H.S. in the class of 1979. The verdict was blunt.
“Ankle - stiff. Lower body - stiff. Below average arm,” Cignetti said Saturday on the BTN Tailgate pregame show from Bloomington.
“Probably didn’t belong there.”
Before that self-assessment, Cignetti had laid out the traits he values most when evaluating talent. He said toughness is the first thing he wants to see, and he also tries to learn as much as possible about a player’s background by talking to coaches, people around them and even a guidance counselor.
“What we’re really looking for there are position-specific criteria. Toughness at all positions is still number one,” Cignetti said of his top evaluation requirement on a recent podcast.
“You talk to the coach, the people around them, maybe the guidance counselor. You get a good idea when they walk in your office what their family background is like, first impression.”
By that standard, Cignetti said his younger self had at least one thing going for him: he was tough. He also had a built-in advantage because football was already part of the family. His father, Frank Cignetti Sr., started coaching at West Virginia University as offensive coordinator on Bobby Bowden’s staff in 1970, then became the Mountaineers’ head coach from 1976-79.
Frank Cignetti brought his son in to play quarterback at West Virginia, but after Curt’s freshman year, Frank was fired and stepped away from coaching for a while before later going on to his Hall of Fame run at Indiana University of Pennsylvania.
Curt remained at West Virginia, where he was stuck behind Oliver Luck, the father of former Indianapolis Colts star Andrew Luck. Oliver Luck, who had the athletic tools Cignetti did not, offered a candid view of the future IU coach as a player.
“He (Cignetti) wasn’t a good athlete, I think he’d be the first to admit that,” Oliver Luck told Pat Forde. “But you could tell he was the son of a coach.
He absorbed everything. He was great for me to have on the sideline because he saw everything.”
Cignetti’s own checklist also included flexibility and movement traits, with emphasis on ankle, knee and hip flexibility, plus the ability to change directions, stop-start and generate power.
The old West Virginia numbers line up with the harsh scouting report. In four seasons there, Cignetti attempted one pass, and it fell incomplete. He also ran the ball once and gained no yards.
Still, the football education kept rolling. Cignetti worked as a graduate assistant at Pitt in 1983, and later reconnected with Saban in 2007 at Alabama.
In Other News...
Curt Cignetti Is Proving Indiana Needs More Than NIL To Dream Big
Curt Cignetti has turned Indiana football into a national-championship program in just two seasons, and he has done it without the Hoosiers operating like one of college footballs biggest NIL spenders. The numbers around roster investment still matter, of course, but Indianas estimated spending for 2026 sits in the $36 million to $40 million range, which places the program 13th nationally and tied for fourth in the Big Ten.
What makes the rise so striking is how much of it has come from Cignettis eye for talent and his coaching, not just from competing at the top of the financial market. Indiana has shown it can dream bigger in the NIL era, but Cignettis success suggests the path forward is still about more than money, and the real question is how long the Hoosiers can keep building that way as the spending race keeps escalating. [Read more 🡒]
Darian DeVries Has A Chance To Change Indiana's Recruiting Buzz
Darian DeVries is still early in his run at Indiana, but the recruiting energy around his program is already starting to shift. This weekend, the Hoosiers are hosting 5-star 2028 combo guard Brady Pettigrew on an official visit, a notable get for a staff trying to build traction with elite prospects while also laying out its long-term vision in Bloomington.
Pettigrew is expected to keep taking visits to other programs, so Indiana is competing in a crowded race rather than enjoying any sort of clean lead. The Hoosiers are also in the mix for 5-star 2027 recruit Darius Wabbington, giving DeVries a chance to stack high-end targets around a class that already includes commitments from 4-star Chase Branham and Felix Kiehlneker, and maybe change the way Indiana is talked about on the trail. [Read more 🡒]
Indiana Just Got An Early Big Ten Reality Check
Lindys Sports has already started setting the tone for the 2026-27 college basketball season, and the early read on the Big Ten is as familiar as it is demanding. Eleven league teams landed in the magazines preseason top 40, with Illinois coming in at No. 3, a reminder that the conference is expected to be loaded again from top to bottom.
Indiana checked in at No. 27, which puts the Hoosiers in the mix but not yet among the leagues elite on paper. The magazine also rolled out preseason All-American and All-Big Ten selections, along with national player rankings, so there is still plenty for Indiana fans to scan for signs of respect as the broader picture of the conference begins to take shape. [Read more 🡒]