Each week, The Dash lays out the 12 teams that would make the College Football Playoff if Selection Sunday arrived right now. And this week, the conversation starts with Alabama and a question the committee may have to answer the hard way: will the Tide get the Indiana treatment?
That’s not a random comparison. Alabama has already benefited from the kind of committee respect that can shape an entire bracket, opening the season at No. 5 before climbing to No. 3 in the second ranking.
Indiana, by contrast, took a brutal hit without even taking the field, dropping five spots from No. 4 to No. 9 between Week 1 and Week 2. Cignetti was not a fan.
The committee’s explanation for Indiana was simple enough: the teams the Hoosiers had beaten kept losing, and that dragged down the value of the résumé. Now Alabama is staring at the same kind of problem.
The Tide’s quality wins have taken a beating. Kentucky lost for the second straight week and fell to 7-3.
South Carolina dropped to 6-4. Mississippi State slipped again to 4-6.
Texas A&M also fell to 4-6. LSU lost as well, landing at 6-4.
Right now, Alabama’s only win over a ranked opponent is Kentucky.
So the question hanging over the bracket is whether the committee will judge Alabama the same way it judged Indiana. If the answer is yes, the Tide’s place in the playoff picture could look a lot different. Indiana will be watching.
In Other News...
Indiana Just Got Pulled Back Into A Familiar Respect Fight
Indianas 8-1 start and win over No. 18 USC looked like the kind of rsum boost that should have pushed the Hoosiers higher in the College Football Playoff picture, but the selection committee had other ideas. Instead of climbing into the national conversation the way many around the program expected, Indiana landed at No. 9, a placement that immediately reopened an old debate about how much respect the Hoosiers are getting compared with teams from the Southeastern Conference.
Curt Cignetti and several players did not hide their frustration, and the reaction fit a familiar pattern for a program that has spent much of the fall trying to prove its success is being taken seriously. Indianas defense helped make the USC win look convincing, and the ranking only sharpened the feeling that the Hoosiers are still fighting for recognition beyond the scoreboard, with national analysts and committee logic once again becoming part of the story. [Read more 🡒]
Lincoln Riley Could Feel What Indiana Just Did To USC
USC left Bloomington with a 27-13 loss to Indiana, a result that not only handed the Trojans their third defeat of the season but also underscored how unforgiving road games can be in the Big Ten. Lincoln Riley spent his postgame remarks sorting through the familiar pain points, pointing to turnovers and missed scoring chances as the kind of self-inflicted mistakes that can turn a winnable afternoon into a frustrating one.
Riley also tried to keep the bigger picture in view, noting that USC has made progress even if it is still not close to the championship standard the program is chasing. For Indiana, the win was the kind of statement result that can reshape a season, while for the Trojans it served as another reminder that improvement has to show up in cleaner execution before the record starts to reflect it. [Read more 🡒]
Indiana Just Made A Big Ten Statement Fans Had To See
Indianas rise hit another gear in Bloomington with a 27-13 win over USC at Memorial Stadium, a result that felt bigger than a single Saturday afternoon. The Hoosiers handled the moment in regulation, leaned on a defense that came up with multiple interceptions, and got enough from quarterback Grant Wilson through the air to keep control of a game that carried real Big Ten weight.
The victory pushed Indiana to 9-1 overall and 6-1 in conference play, the kind of record that changes how the rest of the league looks at a team in November. For a program trying to turn a strong season into something even more meaningful, this was the sort of statement win that can echo well beyond one home crowd, especially with the way the defense set the tone and the offense did just enough to finish the job. [Read more 🡒]
