Nebraska’s loss to Illinois did more than add another mark in the defeat column. It finally pushed the Huskers to move on from offensive coordinator Dana Holgorsen, and for the Sunday Morning Quarterback crew, the reaction was less shock than long-overdue relief.
After a season and a half of watching Holgorsen try to shape Nebraska into a “pass sets up the run” team, the change had become impossible to ignore. The argument from SMQ has been consistent since last season: Nebraska should be built to run the ball, control the line of scrimmage, and fit the Big Ten instead of fighting it.
That never really happened. Holgorsen kept leaning into slow-developing passing concepts, kept the tight ends out of the picture, and kept treating the run game like an afterthought. The result was exactly what the skeptics expected.
Illinois coach Bret Bielema didn’t need anything fancy. He brought a disciplined, physical team that played the kind of football that works in the Big Ten. Nebraska, by contrast, kept making the game harder than it needed to be.
The difference showed up in the trenches and in the simplest football truth of all: games are won up front. Bielema’s formula was built on line play, the run game, and avoiding mistakes. Nebraska never matched that approach.
SMQ’s top defensive priority was straightforward: don’t let the other team’s best player take over. That plan failed, because Collin Dixon finished with eight catches for 129 yards and two touchdowns.
The Huskers’ offense, meanwhile, kept running into the same wall. Long routes took too long to develop.
Receivers struggled to separate. Anthony Colandrea held the ball while waiting for someone to get open.
The quick game never really showed up. Neither did the screens.
The intermediate throws were missing too. And the running game never got the kind of emphasis it needed.
The game was tied at halftime, but Illinois made adjustments. Nebraska did not. Again.
So while the firing of Holgorsen marks a change, it also underscores how long Nebraska waited to make the obvious move. The bigger issue, though, doesn’t disappear with one coaching dismissal. Some people believe the real problem sits with Matt Rhule.
The Huskers have continued to beat themselves with penalties, questionable decisions, and drive-killing mistakes. Against Illinois, they also went for a two-point conversion when the extra point made much more sense, another aggressive call from a staff that may want to take a hard look at its own decision-making.
As Bob Frady asked on the show, does Rhule’s background as a linebacker explain his preference for aggression over restraint?
Football still requires more than yelling “Attack!” and hoping it works.
SMQ also looked at the backgrounds of the sport’s most successful coaches and found that most came from offensive positions, especially the offensive line and quarterback. The point was simple enough: maybe there’s value in coaches who see the whole field, not just the man with the ball.
Rhule’s buyout and Nebraska’s massive stadium renovation commitments make any change at the top difficult. But money problems are not the same thing as coaching success.
At 5-4, Nebraska has gone from talking about a breakthrough season to wondering whether it can even get to six wins. Rutgers looks like the best remaining chance, though Washington and Illinois were supposed to be good opportunities too.
Glenn Thomas now takes over the offense, and SMQ’s message to him was direct: Run. The. Football.
Build around the offensive line. Give Colandrea quicker answers.
Stop asking receivers to run halfway to Omaha before they get open. It is a lot better to wear down an opponent and score in the fourth quarter than to try to “sprint to 21” in the first.
If Nebraska looks the same against Rutgers, then the philosophy hasn’t changed at all. The only thing that changed is the name on the play sheet. And that would be another wasted chance.
The show ended on a personal note, with the crew remembering Jay’s brother and George Stockwell’s Uncle Mark, who died Friday after a long battle with cancer.
Mark Stockwell was a Virginia Tech graduate who built a remarkable career, including 18 years in Brazil. More than that, he was a beloved brother, uncle, friend, and loyal SMQ listener.
Bob recalled meeting Mark almost 20 years ago and spending the next two years being called “Bob Fraley.”
Even after he learned the right name, Mark never fully gave up the habit. Eventually, Bob just started introducing himself as Bob Fraley whenever they crossed paths.
It turned into their joke, and one of those small memories that sticks with you.
The crew raised a glass to Uncle Mark, a good man who will be deeply missed. Here’s to you, Uncle Mark.
In Other News...
Illinois Walks Into A Texas Tech Test That Could Get Uncomfortable
Texas Tech has opened the season with two wins and now gets a far bigger measuring stick, with No. 3 Illinois coming to town in a game that should tell both teams plenty about where they stand early. The Red Raiders are already dealing with frontcourt absences, which puts extra pressure on players like Bassala Bagayoko and Darrion Williams to help hold things together inside while the rest of the roster tries to match Illinois size and depth.
The more intriguing part may be on the perimeter, where Texas Techs Cruz Davis and Dra Gibbs-Lawhorn will be asked to keep pace with Illinois guards Quentin Coleman and Stefan Vaaks. With key big men unavailable on both sides, this one could tilt toward whichever backcourt handles the moment better and avoids the kind of stretches that can quickly make a high-profile nonconference game feel uncomfortable. [Read more 🡒]
Former Illini Adds A Dangerous Twist To Illinois Biggest Test
Illinois is getting ready for one of its biggest early tests against No. 16 Texas Tech, and the matchup comes with a familiar face on the other side. Former Illini guard Dravyn Gibbs-Lawhorn is now part of the Red Raiders rotation, adding a little extra intrigue to a game that already carries plenty of weight for Brad Underwoods team.
Underwood touched on Gibbs-Lawhorns scoring ability in his pregame press conference, and it is easy to see why Illinois would pay close attention. The question now is whether the kind of offensive success he showed at the mid-major level can hold up with the same consistency against high-major competition, especially in a game where every possession figures to matter. [Read more 🡒]
Illinois Suddenly Has A Playoff Path Fans Never Really Had
The College Football Playoff is headed for another major shift, and for programs like Illinois, the change could reshape what a realistic season looks like. Beginning in 2027, the field will expand from 12 to 24 teams, a move that opens the door wider for schools that have long been on the outside looking in when it comes to national title contention.
For Illinois, the timing matters because the programs recent progress has already started to make postseason conversations feel less theoretical. A larger bracket does not guarantee anything, of course, but it does give the Illini a clearer path to stay relevant deeper into the year and turn a strong season into something with real playoff stakes. [Read more 🡒]