The Colts’ season has already been reduced to a conversation about what comes next, and Chris Shepherd of Stampede Blue doesn’t sugarcoat where he thinks this is headed. In his view, Indianapolis is staring at a full teardown, with holes all over the roster and no clear answer at quarterback.
Shepherd pointed to a defense without a quality pass-rushing edge, high-priced cornerbacks not delivering, and a passing game that still isn’t making enough use of its highly drafted tight end. He also noted that the Colts are leaning on a 27-year-old running back who is “soon to be 28” and having a down year, while the most important problem remains the one under center.
“most importantly they don’t have a quarterback who should be starting for an NFL team in 2026 or 2027, nor do they have a first round pick to try to find one. Short of a brilliant stroke of luck, something the Colts haven’t really had for more than a decade, good times seem to be several years away.”
When asked about the front office, Shepherd said there are “a multitude of good GM candidates on paper,” but his personal favorite is Catherine Hickman, the assistant GM of the Cleveland Browns. He described her resume as short but impressive, saying she has excelled in every football job she has held and could be a special hire. He also added that he would enjoy seeing Carlie Irsay-Gordon hire the NFL’s first female GM just to see the reaction online.
As for Shane Steichen, Shepherd estimated there’s about a 40% chance he returns next season. He said that number is higher than many Colts fans would want, but he can see a path where Steichen is kept around to absorb losses during what should be a rough year.
The rest of the season, in Shepherd’s eyes, is about development. He said Chris Ballard’s final draft class with Indianapolis might end up being a good one.
He singled out left guard Jalen Farmer, who has flashed both good and bad moments, and said continued reps should bring more consistency. Running back Seth McGowan, a seventh-round pick, has cut into Jonathan Taylor’s workload and looks like a steal.
Linebackers CJ Allen and Bryce Boettcher have also impressed, with Allen drawing stronger praise. Safety AJ Halucy has shown some splash plays, and Shepherd hopes more time on the field will raise his overall level.
Taylor’s status at the trade deadline was not a surprise to Shepherd. He said the Colts’ earlier moves involving Quenton Nelson and DeForrest Buckner, along with comments from ownership, suggested the team was willing to move players on expiring deals. In his view, the plan was to give the next general manager as much draft capital as possible without making decisions for 2027 contract situations ahead of time.
He also said he does not expect Daniel Jones to be back, though he stopped short of ruling it out entirely. “stranger things have happened to the Colts in the last decade (Head Coach Jeff Saturday, comes to mind) so I wouldn’t rule it out.”
Looking ahead to March and April, Shepherd said the Colts have to devote major resources to fixing the pass rush if they want any shot at meaningful success before 2028. He also expects them to target wide receiver in the draft, given how thin the current group is. He noted that Indianapolis is starting three receivers who might otherwise be on practice squads if not for the state of the roster.
For Friday night’s game, Shepherd thought the Texans being favored by ten made sense. He expects Indianapolis to play hard after showing fight in Miami a week ago, and he believes the Colts will try to run the ball with Taylor and McGowan before Daniel Jones is asked to throw into trouble. In his words, Jones is “good for at least one pick a game,” and if he gets the ball late with a chance to tie or win, Shepherd said another interception is the safe bet.
He also pointed to Nico Collins’ receiving yardage prop as a spot he likes, saying that if the over/under is below 200 yards, the over is the play.
In Other News...
Texans Get A Huge Thursday Night Break Against The Colts
The Texans are getting an important Thursday night break before they even take the field, with the Colts expected to be without cornerback Sauce Gardner because of a calf injury. Gardner missed practice during the week and will not play, leaving Indianapolis thinner in the secondary for a divisional matchup that already carried plenty of weight.
For Houston, that changes the complexion of a game that could hinge on how well the passing attack can stress a weakened back end. The Texans receiving corps now has a cleaner path to creating separation, and with a short week leaving little time for adjustments, Indianapolis will have to sort out its coverage plans without one of its top defensive pieces. [Read more 🡒]
Texans Make A Secondary Change Fans Have Been Waiting On
After a stretch in which the back end of the defense has been under the microscope, Houston is making a notable change for its upcoming game against the Indianapolis Colts. Reed Blankenship is back in the starting lineup at safety alongside Calen Bullock, a move that comes after Blankenship had been sidelined by injury and M.J. Stewart filled in during the previous game against the Cleveland Browns.
For a Texans defense that has given up too many passing yards and too many chances for opponents to make plays on the ball, the adjustment feels like a straightforward attempt to steady the secondary. Blankenships return gives Houston a different look in the middle of the field, and the team will be hoping the change translates into cleaner coverage and fewer breakdowns against a Colts offense that can test a defense in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]
Texans Pass Rush Takes Another Early Hit Fans Will Hate
The Texans were already looking for ways to shore up their pass rush, and Thursday night brought an unwelcome setback before the defense even had a chance to settle in. Chris Braswell, recently elevated from the practice squad to add depth off the edge, went down with a knee injury on the opening kickoff against the Colts and had to be carted off the field.
Braswell was ruled out for the game, leaving Houston to adjust on the fly after losing a player it had just brought up for extra help up front. For a defense trying to keep pressure on opposing quarterbacks, it was a tough early blow and another reminder of how quickly the margin can shrink in a divisional game. [Read more 🡒]
