Yordan Alvarez is putting together the kind of season that usually makes the MVP conversation pretty simple. He’s leading the AL in 10 offensive categories, sitting second in home runs and RBI, and piling up career-best full-season numbers in home runs, runs scored, walks, batting average, on-base percentage, slugging percentage, OPS, OPS+, total bases and intentional walks.
Even with all that, former MLB GM Jim Bowden has gone the other way and made the case for Rays third baseman Junior Caminero over Alvarez. Bowden’s argument, as presented on Foul Territory on September 14, 2026, was blunt: "Take Caminero off the Rays, and the Yankees win the division. I don't even know if Houston gets in."
Caminero has every right to be part of the race. The 22-year-old is having a huge year of his own, is the best hitter on the AL-leading Rays and is on his way to a second straight 40-plus home run season.
His walk rate has improved, and that has helped his on-base percentage and OPS. He also continues to lead the league in grounding into double plays for the second year in a row.
But the gap between the two bats is hard to ignore. Alvarez is hitting .310, while Caminero is at .279.
Alvarez’s .429 on-base percentage leads the league; Caminero’s is .363. Alvarez owns a 1.024 OPS, also best in the AL, compared with Caminero’s .898.
The raw power numbers are close enough to invite debate, with Caminero at 41 home runs and Alvarez at 39. The same goes for RBI, where Alvarez has 98 to Caminero’s 96, and runs scored, where Alvarez has 96 to Caminero’s 92.
But Alvarez has the edge in doubles, 30 to 22, walks, 103 to 74, and intentional walks, 32 to 13. That last number is especially telling, since Alvarez’s 32 intentional walks are twice as many as Shohei Ohtani’s 16, and the closest AL player is Caminero at 13.
Bowden also leaned on Caminero’s defense, but that part of the case is shaky too. Caminero has played third base every day, but according to baseball savant he is the worst defensive third baseman in baseball, with a league-worst -12 outs above average and a league-worst -9 defensive runs saved. Last season he finished at -3 OAA and -2 DRS, so the defensive numbers have actually gotten worse.
The team context matters as well. Bowden pointed to the Rays’ AL-best record, but Tampa Bay’s success has a lot to do with its pitching.
Drew Rasmussen is 14-5 with a 2.81 ERA, Nick Martinez is 14-4 with a 2.92 ERA, Shane McClanahan is 10-7 with a 3.36 ERA, and Bryan Baker has 40 saves with a 1.52 ERA. The Rays are seventh in team ERA at 3.76.
The Astros are 24th at 4.53.
Even the idea that Tampa would collapse without Caminero doesn’t really hold up in the source material. The claim there is that without him, the Rays might still have 86 wins, which would still be the second-best record in the AL.
Bowden added a caveat that if Alvarez wins the Triple Crown, he’d understand Alvarez getting the award. But the source pushes back hard on that logic, arguing that a season should not be reduced to whether Alvarez finishes first in batting average and RBI while possibly being one home run behind Caminero.
That leaves the bigger point untouched: Alvarez is having the more impactful offensive season. And the source makes clear that the idea a designated hitter can’t win MVP doesn’t hold up either, pointing to Shohei Ohtani winning the award in 2024 as a DH without the Triple Crown and without playing a single inning in the field.
In Other News...
Josh Hader Gives Astros Fans Another Reason To Be Proud
Josh Hader has already given the Astros a reason to feel good about the ninth inning, and now he is being recognized for work that goes far beyond the mound. Houston has nominated its closer for the Roberto Clemente Award, a league honor that celebrates community involvement and philanthropic efforts, putting Hader in a conversation that reflects both his impact on the field and the way he has carried himself away from it.
Hader and his wife launched Haders Heart to support children in Child Protective Services and at-risk youth, working with local organizations such as BEAR Houston and Covenant House. It adds another layer to a season in which Hader has been a major piece for Houston despite missing the first two months because of injury, and it leaves the Astros with a closer whose value has shown up in more ways than one. [Read more 🡒]
Astros Just Let The AL West Race Get A Lot Tighter
The Astros came home needing a steadier night, but Kansas City handed them one instead. Houston fell 5-2 at Daikin Park, a loss that dropped the club back to .500 and added more pressure to a division race that is getting crowded at the wrong time.
Cristian Javier gave the Astros a solid enough start, working 5 1/3 innings and allowing two runs, and Jeremy Pea did his part with three hits. Still, Houston could not do much with traffic on the bases, repeatedly failing to push runners beyond second, and the Royals broke it open with three runs in the eighth to leave the Astros looking up again in the AL West. [Read more 🡒]
Astros Suddenly Have Real AL West Pressure With Texas Closing In
The Astros kept pace with a 4-2 win over the Royals, but the bigger picture in the AL West got a lot tighter after Texas handled Boston by the same score and stretched its winning streak to three. Houston still sits one game up, yet the margin has been slim enough that every result now feels like it carries a little extra weight with just 11 games left in the regular season.
Texas also has the head-to-head tiebreaker in hand, which means the Rangers do not need help if they can finish tied in the standings. Houston has been in control of the division race for much of the stretch run, but the pressure has clearly shifted, and the Astros can no longer afford to treat each night like just another box score win. [Read more 🡒]