Yordan Alvarez Faces A Challenge No Astros Star Has Met

Can Yordan Alvarez defy history and maintain his stellar performance from last year's MVP run, as the Astros hope he can break the trend of post-MVP player decline?

Yordan Alvarez is set to open the tentative 2027 MLB season coming off an MVP year, and the Astros have a long enough track record to make the follow-up worth watching. The club has seen a handful of players reach the top of the award race or finish just behind it, and the next season has usually brought a drop.

Glenn Davis was the first Astro to win MVP or finish runner-up. In 1986, the first baseman played 158 games, hit 31 home runs, drove in 100-plus runs and finished second behind Mike Schmidt with 4.5 bWAR.

The next year was a step back. Davis still played plenty, but his production dipped to 1.7 bWAR with 27 home runs, his OPS slid from .837 to .769, and Houston missed the playoffs.

He did not receive any MVP votes in 1987.

Jeff Bagwell delivered the franchise’s first MVP award in the strike-shortened 1994 season, and the numbers were outrageous. He put up a 1.201 OPS with a 213 OPS+, led the league in RBI, runs, slugging, OPS and total bases, and made the case as clearly as anyone could. In 1995, he played 114 games and couldn’t match those peak figures, but he still turned in a strong year: 4.9 bWAR, a .894 OPS and a 15th-place finish in MVP voting.

Bagwell showed up again near the top of the ballot in 1999, when he played every game and posted one of his best run-scoring seasons, crossing the plate 143 times while leading all NL hitters with 7.4 bWAR. The following season, 2000, his OPS was nearly unchanged, though his OPS+ dropped by 12 points because of the new ballpark’s dimensions.

Even so, he still produced 5.4 bWAR, scored 152 runs to top his 1999 total and led the league again. He finished seventh in MVP voting.

Jose Altuve’s MVP season came in 2017, when he led the league with 8.1 bWAR, hit .346 and got on base at a clip above .400. The next year brought a modest decline, but not a collapse.

In 137 games, Altuve hit .316, posted 5.1 bWAR and helped push the Astros back to the playoffs before they fell to the Red Sox in the ALCS. His OPS+ went from 160 to 130, and he finished 13th in MVP voting.

Alex Bregman was the last Astro other than Alvarez to finish in the top two of MVP voting, doing it in 2019. He led the league in walks and finished with 8.9 bWAR to pace the American League.

Then the COVID-19 outbreak wiped out two thirds of the season, and when play resumed, the schedule was cut to 60 games. Bregman ended up with just 1.0 bWAR, and his OPS+ fell to 117 after sitting at 162 the year before.

Taken together, the pattern is clear: Astros stars tend to come down from those peak MVP seasons. On average, their OPS+ dropped to 78% of the previous year after a top-two MVP finish.

If Alvarez followed that same path, he’d still land around a 148 OPS+, which would keep him firmly in the American League MVP mix. He also has one edge the others didn’t - the DH role, which spares him the everyday grind that came with those earlier seasons.

No Astro has followed an MVP-top two finish with a top-six MVP season the next year, but Alvarez is in a different spot than the rest.

In Other News...

Astros Cut Ties With A Once Promising Outfielder Before A Critical Offseason

Joey Loperfidos time with the Astros appears to be over after Houston placed the outfielder on release waivers following the 2026 season. The move comes as the club works through its 40-man roster decisions with the offseason approaching, and it arrives after Loperfido had offseason surgery on his right hip and was not expected to be ready for the start of spring training.

For an Astros team trying to get its roster lined up before a potentially complicated winter, the timing matters as much as the personnel. Loperfido had once looked like part of the organizations next wave, but Houston is clearly making hard choices early as it tries to create flexibility and avoid getting caught flat-footed if the offseason turns into a lockout situation. [Read more 🡒]

Astros Face A Tough Deadline As Former Playoff Hero Moves On

Chas McCormick is trying to work his way back into the big leagues, and the former Astros outfielder has found a new landing spot with the Pittsburgh Pirates on a minor-league contract that includes an invitation to Major League spring training. After spending the 2026 season with the Chicago Cubs Triple-A affiliate, McCormick is aiming to revive a career that once made him a familiar name in Houston, where he carved out a role during a memorable run.

For the Astros, his move comes as the organization faces a different kind of roster pressure. Houston is weighing which prospects to protect on its 40-man roster ahead of the Rule 5 Draft deadline, a decision that can shape both the immediate depth chart and the longer-term pipeline. It is the sort of front-office checkpoint that often forces a team to balance present needs against future upside, and the choices made now could have ripple effects well beyond spring training. [Read more 🡒]

Astros Outfield Search Puts One Familiar Trade Target Back In Focus

The Astros search for outfield help is already taking shape under new general manager Randy Flores, and one familiar name has resurfaced in the conversation. Jarren Duran has been mentioned as a trade candidate out of Boston, and Houston is among the clubs that reportedly showed interest before, which makes him an easy fit to circle as the front office starts weighing ways to upgrade the position after a disappointing season.

Duran brings the kind of track record that naturally gets attention, even with his production trending down in recent years after an All-Star season in 2024. For Houston, the appeal is obvious enough: a player with a ceiling worth revisiting, and a market that could open if the Red Sox decide to listen. The question now is whether the Astros are merely monitoring the situation again or ready to push harder this time around. [Read more 🡒]