Nick Pivetta Could Be An Astros Fit For One Big Reason

Can Nick Pivetta's newfound pitching prowess turn him into the Houston Astros' next star acquisition?

Nick Pivetta doesn’t enter free agency with the kind of résumé that usually screams front-line starter. But the last two seasons have changed the conversation around him, and that’s why his name now makes sense in a place like Houston.

Pivetta’s path to this point has been a steady climb. He left Boston after turning down a $21.05 million qualifying offer and finishing a four-season run with the Red Sox.

His early years with the Philadelphia Phillies from 2017 to 2019 were rough - a 19-30 record, a 5.34 ERA, a 4.56 FIP and 0.9 bWAR. He looked more like a back-end arm than a difference-maker.

That changed in Boston, where he put together a 48-46 record, a 4.00 ERA, a 4.04 FIP and 13.8 bWAR from 2021 to 2025. Even so, his best ERA there was only 4.04, posted in 2023 when he worked both as a starter and a reliever, making 16 starts and 17 relief appearances.

The real shift came when you zoom in on his most recent two seasons. Pivetta cut his FIP from 4.35 to 4.01 while giving up the same number of home runs, 51 in each half. The difference was in how he handled hitters: more strikeouts, far fewer walks, and a jump in his SO/BB from 2.54 to 4.13.

San Diego clearly saw that trend and bet on it. The Padres gave him a four-year, $55 million deal, though they ended up paying out only $23 million over his two seasons there.

His first year with San Diego was the best of his career. He went 13-5, threw 181 ⅔ innings, and posted a 2.87 ERA across 31 starts. His career BABIP dropped from .301 to .235, his home run rate fell from 15.1% to 9.7%, and he finished with 3.7 fWAR, the top total of his career and equal to the 3.9 he had combined over his previous two seasons.

The stuff backed up the results. Pivetta jumped from the 35th percentile in Pitching in 2024 to the 99th percentile, with his fastball grading in the 98th percentile and his breaking pitches in the 92nd. Still, he remained the same basic type of arm in some ways: not a big chase-rate or whiff monster, but an above-average strikeout-to-walk pitcher who could still be hit hard.

The setting mattered, too. Petco Park gave him a different run environment than Boston did, and the park effect shows it. Across his career, Pivetta has allowed 205 home runs, a number that would have dropped to 160 with Fenway Park’s park effect, compared with 190 under Petco Park expectations.

This season brought a setback. After that big 2025 campaign, Pivetta landed on the injured list with a right elbow flexor strain and missed much of the year.

When he came back, though, the performance still looked sharp. In eight starts and 34 ⅔ innings, he posted a 3.46 xFIP, his best mark since 2018, raised his strikeout rate from 9.41 last year to 10.90, cut his walks, and again kept the ball in the park, dropping his home run rate from 9.7% to 4.3%.

That’s the case for Pivetta now: if he stays healthy, he looks like a legitimate option for a team such as the Houston Astros, who need experienced starters capable of bringing both durability and impact to the rotation.

In Other News...

Astros Could Lose Familiar 40-Man Names In Rule 5 Squeeze

With the Rule 5 Draft deadline looming on Nov. 17, the Astros are sitting in a familiar roster bind: 39 players on the 40-man and only one open spot to work with. That leaves Houston with some tough decisions as it weighs which prospects are worth protecting and which current names might be squeezed off the roster to make room.

Jackson Nezuh and Will Bush are both eligible to be taken in the draft, which puts added pressure on the front office to create space before the deadline passes. To do it, the Astros could have to designate players such as Ronel Blanco, Collin Price or Taylor Trammell for assignment, a reminder that roster management this time of year can be just as consequential as the moves made on the field. [Read more 🡒]

Astros Still Have A Real Shot At More Hardware After Pea Snub

The Astros still have a chance to add some hardware even after the latest round of award chatter left them with a familiar mix of praise and frustration. Houston has two finalists for the Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger Awards this year, with Yordan Alvarez in the designated hitter race and the club itself in line for the AL team honor, a reminder that the lineup and the overall offense still carried enough weight to stay in the conversation.

The broader award picture has also turned into a familiar exercise in sorting through who made the finalist cut and who did not, with the article breaking down the American League field position by position and weighing the strengths of the candidates from the 2026 season. For the Astros, the bigger interest is whether those finalists are just the start of the nights recognition, or whether the rest of the voting leaves them still waiting for the next piece of good news. [Read more 🡒]

Astros Face A Risky Trevor Rogers Decision Beneath The Breakout

Trevor Rogers turned his 2025 season into one of the more intriguing pitching stories on the market, and that puts Houston in an uncomfortable spot. The left-hander was excellent for Baltimore, finishing with a 1.81 ERA and 3.3 fWAR over 18 starts, then sharpened even more after the All-Star break as his strikeout rate climbed and his walks came down. Even with the strong finish, the underlying picture is not entirely spotless, which is exactly why he has become such a fascinating fit for teams trying to balance upside with risk.

For the Astros, the appeal is obvious because front-line left-handed pitching is never cheap, especially when a starter is projected to land a multi-year deal in the neighborhood of $104 million. The hesitation comes from the same place it always does with a pitcher coming off a breakout: there are still questions about whether the offspeed stuff will hold up and whether the ground-ball profile can stay where it needs to be. Houston has seen enough to know the ceiling is real, but the decision is whether that ceiling is worth paying for before the market pushes the price even higher. [Read more 🡒]