The Astros have reached the point where Christian Walker’s fit at first base no longer looks clean, and the simplest path may be the one that gives Houston the best chance to move forward this offseason.
Walker has not been a total flop - 29 HR and 87 RBI are real production - but the overall package has not matched the job description. A sub .230 AVG and sub .300 OBP at first base is a tough sell, especially when the bat is supposed to help anchor the middle of the order.
After April 30, he managed only one month above .210 at the plate, hitting .223 in June, and that stretch made the issue impossible to ignore. He was supposed to be the main protection for Yordan Alvarez, but after April 30 he failed in that role so badly that he eventually slid down the lineup despite the power.
If Houston does decide to move on, the first option is the most straightforward: shift Isaac Paredes to first base. Paredes eventually became Alvarez’s primary protection and the numbers improved with it.
After a slow start, he finished at .262 with a .360 OBP and .806 OPS, right in the range the Astros were hoping to get from Walker. He also posted 25 HR, 94 RBI and 71 walks, all of which were the second-highest marks of his career, while his 27 doubles, average and OBP were all career highs.
He played 155 games, too. The wrinkle is defensive comfort.
Paredes has spent most of his career at third base, has only started 45 games at first in the majors, and his defensive metrics at first were below league average, even in a small sample.
Carlos Correa is the other infield name that fits into the conversation. There’s uncertainty around how his ankle surgery will affect his mobility, but there are also clues that a move to first could make sense.
Correa wanted to move to third two years ago to reduce the wear on his body, and just a few weeks ago he said he was willing to play anywhere on the infield. First base would put less strain on him than anywhere else on the dirt.
At 6-3, he would be a big target, and his hands, baseball IQ and natural athleticism all point toward a smooth adjustment if he wants it. He is already the team’s vocal leader, so if he embraced the switch, it would carry weight in the clubhouse.
There is also a more aggressive internal route: Jason Schiavone. The Astros’ 2026 MiLB Player of the Year split time between catcher and first base and became just the third Astros minor leaguer to post a 30/30 season.
He was also the first catcher to do that in the minor leagues for any organization since 1981. Schiavone moved quickly through the system this year, putting up a 1.218 OPS in 37 games at High-A Asheville, then going to Double-A Corpus Christi and delivering 14 HR, 44 RBI, 49 BB and 20 SB in 283 AB before finishing with nine games at Triple-A Sugar Land and a .924 OPS.
He has shown he can handle both catcher and first base defensively. The leap would be fast, considering he has only 26 Triple-A AB, but the Astros already showed they are willing to be aggressive with Cam Smith, who had just 19 AB at Double-A before reaching the major league roster and only 115 professional AB overall.
If Houston wants to go outside the organization, Ty France is the free-agent name on the list. He put together arguably his best season at age 31, batting .295 with a .363 OBP and .865 OPS for the San Diego Padres.
France added 21 HR and 72 RBI in 133 games, and he was also excellent defensively with an 8 OAA, the second-best mark in MLB. He made just $2M after incentives in 2026, so even with a raise, he should still be affordable.
Any outcome that puts someone other than Correa or Paredes at first base would likely signal something bigger - either Jeremy Pena has been traded and Correa has moved back to shortstop, or an injury has forced the Astros to add a first baseman. Otherwise, Houston risks carrying the same infield logjam into 2027 if Walker is still on the roster.
In Other News...
Astros Power Couldnt Hide A Bigger October Lineup Problem
The Astros spent the 2026 season leaning into what they do best, and nobody in baseball hit more home runs. But the October version of that offense never quite looked as dangerous as the regular-season totals suggested, because the same lineup that could change a game with one swing also carried a baserunning problem that kept surfacing in the background all year.
Houston finished last in the majors in Baserunning Runs, and the postseason exposed how much that cost them. In the Wild Card Series, the Astros went 0-for-9 with runners in scoring position and never fully turned extra traffic into runs, even with power in the middle of the order. Jeremy Pea and Cam Smith were among the few players who provided positive value on the bases, while Yordan Alvarez and Jose Altuve were part of the group that did not. [Read more 🡒]
Astros Offseason Suddenly Hinges On One Uncomfortable Decision
The Astros offseason has already become bigger than a simple roster tune-up, with the front office staring at a chain of decisions that could shape the next phase of the franchise. Houston needs a new general manager, Joe Espadas contract is nearing its end, and the organization is trying to sort out whether this group should be rebuilt, retooled or supplemented after a year that exposed real roster deficiencies and a farm system still in transition.
Amid all of that uncertainty, one more layer is waiting in the background: pitcher Tatsuya Imai has a decision to make on his 2027 contract option. It is the kind of detail that underscores how many moving parts Houston is juggling at once, and how much of the clubs near-term planning depends on choices that have not been made yet. [Read more 🡒]
Astros Face Tough Veteran Decisions As An Offseason Reset Looms
The Astros are heading into another important offseason with a familiar kind of roster pressure, this time centered on a mix of veteran relievers, an outfielder, and a catcher whose futures all need sorting out. With six players nearing free agency and two more tied to club options, the front office is again staring at a reset that will shape how much of the current core carries forward and how much gets reworked for 2027.
Bryan Abreu, Steven Okert and Enyel De Los Santos headline the bullpen questions, while Daulton Varsho and Christian Vazquez add to the uncertainty on the position-player side. The answers are not all expected to be the same, and that is what makes the coming decisions so tricky for Houston: some of these moves will be about performance, some about age and cost, and some about whether the club wants to keep certain veterans around for another run or start clearing the deck now. [Read more 🡒]