Clay Holmes looks like the kind of arm the Houston Astros could use, but he’s not the kind of bet that comes without some real baggage.
That’s the tension here. Houston spent the year patching together its pitching staff, and the starting rotation became such a mess that the Astros used 19 different pitchers, a new franchise record. When a reliever like AJ Blubaugh has to start Game 1 of the Wild Card Series, it says plenty about how the season unfolded and what the roster could actually handle.
Blubaugh, in his second season with Houston, led the relievers with 96 innings across 64 appearances. Even that number tells a bigger story: he threw more innings than 17 of the Astros’ 19 starters over the course of the season.
Holmes would give Houston something it clearly lacked: a starter who can soak up innings. He finished his second season as a starter in 2026 with a 3.29 ERA over 101 ⅓ innings, along with 78 strikeouts and 1.4 bWAR.
His year was split between two very different stretches. He posted a 2.39 ERA in 52 ⅔ innings with the New York Mets, then after suffering a fractured fibula and getting sent to the Chicago Cubs in the second half, his performance dropped and his xFIP climbed from 3.68 to 4.12.
The contact profile stayed mostly steady. Hitters produced almost the same BABIP against him - .250 in New York, .252 overall - and he even improved his ground-ball rate.
The issue was the ball leaving the yard. His HR/FB rate jumped from 7.1% to 11.1%, and that became the biggest problem in the second half.
Even with that risk, Holmes profiles as a mid-rotation starter who could clear 100 innings, which is exactly the kind of stability Houston was missing. The Astros had only two pitchers reach that threshold: Peter Lambert, who logged 155 ⅔ innings, and Hunter Brown, who threw 107 ⅓.
The price tag, though, could make this a tougher call. Holmes is projected to cost between $35-40 million, with an AAV in the $17-20 million range.
That’s a hefty commitment for a pitcher whose biggest questions still revolve around control and missing bats. In 2026, he finished in the 23rd percentile in Whiff%, while his 18.6% strikeout rate and 10% walk rate landed in the 24th and 29th percentiles, respectively.
Those numbers help explain why he doesn’t look like a classic overpowering starter. He gives hitters more chances to put the ball in play. What keeps him afloat is the elite ground-ball work: a 60.5% ground-ball rate that ranked in the 99th percentile.
That’s been the tradeoff since he moved from the bullpen to the rotation. The workload changed, and Holmes had to change with it, reshaping his mix by adding a curveball, a changeup, and a cutter that has played a bigger role over the last two seasons.
He’s also had to deal with a velocity drop of about four miles per hour, which makes his margin for error thinner and puts even more pressure on his ability to limit hard contact.
So the path forward is pretty clear. Holmes doesn’t need to be a strikeout machine to matter.
His value now comes from efficiency, from keeping the ball on the ground and forcing weak contact. And that part of his game has held up for a long time: he has now finished six straight seasons with a ground-ball rate in the 94th percentile or better, including multiple years in the 100th percentile.
In Other News...
Astros Suddenly Face A Brutal Offseason Clock
The Astros offseason took a sharp turn when Dana Brown was fired on Aug. 24, and the front office has been moving ever since to reset the organization before the winter really gets away from it. Randy Flores was hired at the end of November to take over as general manager, stepping into a job that now comes with a compressed stretch to sort through roster matters and staff changes while the club also works through the fallout from Joe Espadas departure.
Flores does not have the luxury of a long runway. With the current collective bargaining agreement set to expire on Dec. 1, Houston is staring at a deadline that could quickly change how much business can get done, all while the search continues for a new manager and coaching staff. For a team trying to reestablish direction, the timing is about as unforgiving as it gets. [Read more 🡒]
Astros Are Chasing A Japanese Arm With Plenty Working Against Them
An 18-year-old Japanese pitching prospect is drawing plenty of attention this week, and the Astros are among the teams lining up to get a closer look. Shoki Oda is reportedly set to meet with Houstons management as he explores a path to MLB that would let him sign as an international free agent rather than go through the usual posting route, a wrinkle that has only added to the intrigue around his market.
Houston is hardly alone in the chase. The Phillies, Mets, Cardinals, Blue Jays and Yankees have also met with Oda or are scheduled to do so, and the timing only gets trickier with uncertainty hanging over the international signing period because of a possible MLB lockout. The Astros also have some history here, and their prior experience with Japanese pitcher Tatsuya Imai could shape how they approach Odas camp as they try to make their case. [Read more 🡒]
Yordan Alvarez Is Finally Closing In On The Award Astros Fans Wanted
Yordan Alvarezs 2026 season put him in the center of the American League MVP conversation in a way Astros fans have been waiting to see. The Houston slugger was named a finalist for the award after a year in which he stood atop Major League Baseball in batting average, OPS, on-base percentage, slugging percentage and walks, while also delivering 42 home runs and 106 RBIs.
The attention around Alvarez has only grown because opposing teams had so little choice but to work around him, and the intentional walks piled up as the season went on. He now enters the final stretch as the favorite for the MVP, putting him on the brink of the kind of individual honor that would match the force of his production and the respect he commanded all year. [Read more 🡒]