The Houston Astros had the kind of night that can swing a division race, and for most of it, they looked ready to seize it.
They entered Wednesday with first place back in hand after a 7-0 win over the Seattle Mariners on Tuesday, then watched the Texas Rangers drop their second straight game to the New York Mets earlier in the evening. That set up a clean shot for Houston: win the series, build a one-game cushion in the AL West, and lean on the head-to-head tiebreaker over Texas. Instead, the Astros let it slip away in a 5-4, 10-inning loss that left them still in first at 78-80 only because of that tiebreaker.
Houston did plenty early to make it feel like this one was theirs. Jose Altuve drove in a run with a single, Isaac Paredes added a sacrifice fly, and Yainer Diaz launched a two-run homer as the Astros raced to a 4-0 lead after the top of the third. But Seattle answered immediately with three runs in the bottom half, chasing rookie starter Ethan Pecko from the game and wiping out the comfort Houston had built.
From there, the game settled into a grind. Seattle picked up another run in the fifth, and neither lineup found much until extra innings. Then Diaz came through again, this time with his first triple of the year, putting Houston back in front in the 10th and leaving the Astros three outs from a huge win.
That’s where it all unraveled.
Josh Hader, who had already worked 19 pitches in the ninth, came back out for a second inning in the 10th. It was his first time pitching more than one inning since Aug. 10, and the longer he stayed out there, the more the outing tilted the wrong way. The command slipped, the walks piled up, and Hader eventually issued three free passes in the inning before Josh Naylor lined the first pitch he saw for a walk-off single.
By the end, Hader had thrown 44 pitches, 25 for strikes. It was his highest pitch count in an outing since Aug.
9, 2019. He finished with four walks, two hits allowed and one earned run across 1.1 innings.
Manager Joe Espada stuck with him, and afterward explained the decision to Brian McTaggart of MLB.com. “The stuff was really good.
They fouled some tough pitches off, they really made him work,” Espada said. “The slider was there, the sinker was good, up to 96 [mph], but they just put some really good at-bats against him and made him work."
Espada also didn’t have many obvious alternatives. Nobody was warming in the bullpen, and the only other real possibility appeared to be rookie Miguel Ullola, who had already thrown two innings Tuesday.
Hader, on six days of rest and carrying a $95 million price tag, was the arm Houston trusted in that moment. This time, it didn’t hold.
Hader said the problem started with his location. "I think I’ve got to be in the zone more. Obviously in the 10th, you don’t want to be in the zone to give up a hit, but you’re not doing yourself good if they’re not swinging at the ones out of the zone," Hader said according to McTaggart.
The fallout matters just as much as the loss itself. Hader likely won’t be available Thursday and could also be down Friday, which is a brutal development with two more must-win games looming and no closer available.
The game also brought scrutiny to another Espada move, this one in the eighth inning when he lifted Cam Smith for pinch hitter Lamonte Wade Jr. Smith has the better numbers against right-handers, while Wade has only been slightly more productive over the last week.
Smith also had just doubled on Tuesday. Houston’s outfield issues only added to the frustration, with the group going 0-for-11 in the game.
Even with all that, the bullpen had done enough to set Houston up. AJ Blubaugh gave them two scoreless innings, and rookie debutant Josh Hendrickson added two innings of one-run work.
That kind of effort should have been enough to cash in. Instead, the Astros walked away with a painful reminder of how thin the margin is in a race this tight.
Now they have to turn the page quickly and try to hold onto control of their own fate in a four-game road series against the Athletics.
In Other News...
Astros Bullpen Debate Just Put Joe Espada Under A Harsh Spotlight
Joe Espadas bullpen choices have come under a sharper lens lately, and the comparison between Enyel De Los Santos and Nate Pearson shows why. Both right-handers have been asked to bridge important innings for Houston, but the way theyve been deployed has not been the same, and the results have reflected that. Their usage has become part of the story, not just their raw production, because the Astros have been leaning on each arm in different spots and asking different things of them.
De Los Santos and Pearson have each flashed reasons to trust them, with innings, strikeouts, walks and scoreless outings all offering clues about what has worked and what has not. The bigger question is whether the performance gap is really about stuff or command, or whether it comes back to how Espada has chosen to use them. For a bullpen that needs stability, the answer matters, and the way these two have been handled leaves Houston with a decision it still has to sort out. [Read more 🡒]
Verlander Just Reopened A Loaded Debate Astros Fans Never Escaped
Justin Verlander stirred up an old conversation during an appearance on "On Base with Mookie Betts," putting the 2019 Astros back in the center of a debate that never really went away. Asked about the best team he has ever been part of, Verlander pointed to that Houston group and leaned on the kind of talent that defined the roster, naming Jose Altuve, Gerrit Cole, Carlos Correa, George Springer and Yuli Gurriel as the core of a team he viewed as loaded from top to bottom.
The comments are the latest reminder of how much that era still lingers in Houston, where the baseball memory of that club is impossible to separate from the arguments around it. Verlander also said he has not decided whether he would enter the Hall of Fame as a Tiger or an Astro, leaving another familiar topic hanging in the air as his career moves deeper into its legacy stage. [Read more 🡒]
Astros Suddenly Face A Varsho Problem At The Worst Time
Daulton Varshos left wrist has been bothering him for the better part of three months, and the timing is especially awkward for an Astros team already managing other health issues. The problem stems from two cysts, and Varsho has been trying to play through it with the help of cortisone shots while the club waits to see whether rest and treatment can get him back on track.
Varsho is now set to seek a second opinion, with surgery and a recovery timeline of about a month in the conversation. Houston is also dealing with Cristian Javier being sidelined by a Grade 2 groin strain, while Jeremy Pea has had wrist soreness of his own even though he was still available as a pinch-runner. It is a reminder that the Astros margin for error is getting thinner at exactly the wrong time. [Read more 🡒]