The AL West has a chance to do something no division has ever done before, and it’s the kind of milestone baseball would rather skip.
With just four games left for the Astros and Rangers, the race is still alive, but it’s alive in the ugliest possible way. Houston and Texas are tied in the standings, the Mariners are hanging on by a thread, and every team in the division is below .500.
That alone makes this stretch feel wrong. The deeper you go, the worse it looks.
Here’s where things stood going into Thursday’s slate: the Astros and Rangers were both 78-80, the Mariners were 74-84, the Athletics sat at 63-95, and the Angels were 60-98. Houston and Texas were tied for first, but the Astros held the tiebreaker thanks to a 9-4 head-to-head record against the Rangers.
In practical terms, that gives Houston a one-game edge with four to play. SportsLine had the Astros at 63.6% to win the division.
If that race ends with a division winner under .500, MLB will have a first. No team has ever won a division title or grabbed a wild-card spot with a losing record, even in this era of expanded playoffs.
The current mark for the worst regular-season record by a playoff team belongs to the 2005 Padres at 82-80. For the AL West champ to avoid breaking that record, it would have to win out.
And that’s not the only number that makes this division look rotten from top to bottom. The five AL West clubs are a combined 84 games under .500.
Their run differentials tell an even harsher story: together, they’ve been outscored by 467 runs. Based on those run differentials, the division should be 90 games under .500.
The Angels are the only team that hasn’t outplayed its run differential.
The gap between the AL West and the rest of the league shows up on both sides of the ball. The division has a combined .706 OPS and averages 4.20 runs per game, while teams outside the division are at .721 OPS and 4.53 runs per game. On the pitching and defense side, AL West teams have a 4.54 ERA and allow 4.79 runs per game, compared with a 4.09 ERA and 4.41 runs allowed for the rest of baseball.
That’s why this isn’t just a bad division race. It’s a historically bad division, full stop.
Since divisional play began in 1969, the 2026 AL West is on track to be the worst division ever. None of its teams are heading toward the kind of individual collapse seen from the 2024 White Sox or the 2025 Rockies, but as a group, this division has dragged itself - and potentially the postseason - into a place baseball has never been before.
And yet one of them is going to the playoffs. The Astros are in the stronger spot, the Rangers are right there, and the Mariners still have a mathematical path. However this ends, the AL West has made itself the division that nobody in baseball wanted to watch write history.
In Other News...
Astros Bullpen Debate Just Put Joe Espada Under A Harsh Spotlight
Joe Espadas bullpen choices have come under a sharper lens lately, and the comparison between Enyel De Los Santos and Nate Pearson shows why. Both right-handers have been asked to bridge important innings for Houston, but the way theyve been deployed has not been the same, and the results have reflected that. Their usage has become part of the story, not just their raw production, because the Astros have been leaning on each arm in different spots and asking different things of them.
De Los Santos and Pearson have each flashed reasons to trust them, with innings, strikeouts, walks and scoreless outings all offering clues about what has worked and what has not. The bigger question is whether the performance gap is really about stuff or command, or whether it comes back to how Espada has chosen to use them. For a bullpen that needs stability, the answer matters, and the way these two have been handled leaves Houston with a decision it still has to sort out. [Read more 🡒]
Verlander Just Reopened A Loaded Debate Astros Fans Never Escaped
Justin Verlander stirred up an old conversation during an appearance on "On Base with Mookie Betts," putting the 2019 Astros back in the center of a debate that never really went away. Asked about the best team he has ever been part of, Verlander pointed to that Houston group and leaned on the kind of talent that defined the roster, naming Jose Altuve, Gerrit Cole, Carlos Correa, George Springer and Yuli Gurriel as the core of a team he viewed as loaded from top to bottom.
The comments are the latest reminder of how much that era still lingers in Houston, where the baseball memory of that club is impossible to separate from the arguments around it. Verlander also said he has not decided whether he would enter the Hall of Fame as a Tiger or an Astro, leaving another familiar topic hanging in the air as his career moves deeper into its legacy stage. [Read more 🡒]
Astros Suddenly Face A Varsho Problem At The Worst Time
Daulton Varshos left wrist has been bothering him for the better part of three months, and the timing is especially awkward for an Astros team already managing other health issues. The problem stems from two cysts, and Varsho has been trying to play through it with the help of cortisone shots while the club waits to see whether rest and treatment can get him back on track.
Varsho is now set to seek a second opinion, with surgery and a recovery timeline of about a month in the conversation. Houston is also dealing with Cristian Javier being sidelined by a Grade 2 groin strain, while Jeremy Pea has had wrist soreness of his own even though he was still available as a pinch-runner. It is a reminder that the Astros margin for error is getting thinner at exactly the wrong time. [Read more 🡒]