Packers May Be Nearing A Tough Decision On Their Kicking Problem

As the Green Bay Packers grapple with kicker Trey Smack's inconsistencies, former Falcon Younghoe Koo emerges as a potential, yet risky solution amidst a scarce kicker market.

The Packers are at the point where every missed kick feels bigger than the last, and Sunday’s loss to Minnesota only sharpened the alarm. Trey Smack’s early miss didn’t just cost points; it fed the sense that Green Bay can’t keep waiting for things to stabilize on their own. If the team is going to move away from him, it looks like desperation time.

That’s where Younghoe Koo enters the conversation. The former Atlanta Falcons kicker is a free agent, and while his recent work has been shaky, there was a time not long ago when he was among the most accurate kickers in league history. Two years ago, Koo ranked top-five in all-time field goal percentage, a reminder of just how steady he once was before the last two seasons went sideways.

None of that erases how rough those last two years have been, which is exactly why he’s still available. But Green Bay isn’t shopping for a clean answer at this point. Any move away from Smack is going to come with risk, and Koo at least offers a path worth considering.

The Packers also appear likely to keep looking at practice squad possibilities while hoping the rookie can straighten himself out. That’s the bind they created by betting on a first-year kicker without a real fallback plan.

It’s a frustratingly familiar spot for a team that already watched Brandon McManus collapse a year ago. His postseason struggles helped end Green Bay’s season, and now the Packers are back in the same uncomfortable place, stuck with a kicker who has been the definition of inconsistent.

There are other names that could be floated, but Koo makes the most sense when you weigh the past against the present. At the very least, Green Bay should bring him in and see whether a practice squad stint could help restore some confidence.

That’s how thin the margin has become. There isn’t an easy fix here, only a set of flawed options, and the Packers are running out of room to keep absorbing the misses from Smack.

In Other News...

Packers Bye Week Puts Several Veterans On Notice For 2025

The Packers are heading into their bye week with more than just the playoff picture hanging in the balance. Green Bay still has questions about where it stands in the postseason race, but the bigger long-term issue may be how the front office sorts out an offensive line that has not settled in and a roster filled with veterans whose contracts are moving toward a crossroads.

Keisean Nixon, Laken Tomlinson, Carrington Valentine, Kevin Zeitler and Karl Brooks all sit in that uncertain category as the season pauses, and each brings a different case for why Green Bay might want to keep talking. Some have flashed enough to make a return possible, while others could be on the outside looking in once the offseason arrives, leaving the bye week as a natural checkpoint for a team that has to think beyond the current push. [Read more 🡒]

Packers Just Opened A Roster Spot Fans Will Want To Watch

The Packers made a quiet roster move after the trade deadline that could have a ripple effect over the next few days, waiving running back Pierre Strong Jr. and opening a spot on the 53-man roster. Because of the timing, Strong is subject to waivers despite being a vested veteran, which means Green Bay is now in line with the rest of the league if another team wants to make a claim.

The move also fits with the teams next bit of business, as Micah Parsons is expected to be activated from the physically unable to perform list. Green Bay already has four running backs on the active roster, so there is at least a chance Strong could be brought back on the practice squad if he clears waivers, making this one of those transactions that looks routine on paper but still deserves a close watch. [Read more 🡒]

Former Packers Just Got A New Shot Fans Will Want To Track

The United Football Leagues latest draft gave a handful of former Packers a fresh path back into the spotlight, with the league moving to a full 15-round format instead of its old position-based system. Seven ex-Green Bay players heard their names called, a reminder that the UFL is trying to create a more traditional draft day feel while also giving NFL hopefuls another real chance to stick somewhere.

Cornelius Johnson, McCallan Castles, Tyron Herring, Damien Martinez, M.J. Devonshire, Brenden Rice and Kyron Drones all landed with UFL teams, and the list is worth keeping an eye on because some were slotted at different positions than they had been with the Packers. Even with that group coming off the board, a few well-regarded prospects still went undrafted despite being rated highly by the leagues scouting department, leaving the kind of unfinished business that tends to make the next round of roster movement even more interesting. [Read more 🡒]