The Cowboys may already be finding out what the Packers figured out a while ago about Rashan Gary: the talent is still there, but the motor has become the story.
That’s a tough place to be when you’ve just paid a fourth-round pick for him. Brian Gutekunst, by the look of it, pulled off the kind of deal executives dream about. Dallas called, Green Bay answered, and suddenly the Packers had turned a declining asset into what now looks like their best offseason move.
The warning signs were there before the trade ever went through. Gary’s production fell off badly in the second half of last season, and the effort level started drawing heat.
He looked like a player slowing down on plays, or in plainer terms, giving up on them. Packers legend Mason Crosby didn’t mince words, calling it “inexcusable.”
Now five games into his Dallas run, the same problem is back on the tape.
Thursday night’s loss to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers put the issue under a bright spotlight. ESPN’s Dan Orlovsky said on Get Up, “There are the three veterans on this defense - Rashan Gary, very good player, Kenny Clark, very good player, Quinnen Williams, very good, highly-paid player - that their effort isn't good enough,”
The clearest example came on Bucky Irving’s 72-yard run. Gary held contain early, then when Irving bounced inside, Gary just jogged toward him. He may not have been in position to finish the play, but he didn’t give himself much of a shot.
That kind of sequence has become familiar. Packers fans saw plenty of it last season, including the now-notorious moment when Gary jogged toward Bo Nix against the Denver Broncos while Micah Parsons sprinted past him to make a pressure.
It was maddening then, and the numbers followed the frustration. Gary had 7.5 sacks in the first seven games last season, helped immediately by Parsons’ arrival. After that, he produced zero sacks, zero tackles for loss and only eight quarterback hits over the final 10 games, playoff loss included.
The start in Dallas has been flat by comparison. Pro Football Reference has Gary with one sack in five games, and his five pressures rank 68th in the NFL. He has the same number of pressures as Packers safety Evan Williams, even though he has played one more game.
His run defense has been just as underwhelming. According to PFF, Gary’s run defense grade ranks 90th among 110 edge defenders.
Green Bay’s decision to move on from him and keep Lukas Van Ness is looking smarter by the week. The Packers also picked up Van Ness’ fifth-year option, a move that drew skepticism at the time. So far, though, it’s paying off.
Van Ness has been better than Gary in just about every measurable way:
- Sacks: Van Ness 2.5, Gary 1
- Pressures: Van Ness 8, Gary 5
- Hurries: Van Ness 2, Gary 2
- QB knockdowns: Van Ness 3, Gary 2
Those numbers, according to Pro Football Reference, come with the added note that Gary has played one more game than Van Ness, thanks to Dallas opening Week 5 on Thursday Night Football.
Van Ness is starting to look like a player on the rise in Green Bay, which only adds to the contrast. Gary, meanwhile, has one sack in his last 15 NFL games. For a pass rusher, that’s a long stretch of emptiness.
The Packers already lived through this version of Rashan Gary. The Cowboys are just getting there.
In Other News...
Packers Fans Still Debate The Ezra Johnson Sideline Controversy
When Packers fans look back at the best players to wear No. 90, Ezra Johnson sits at the top of the list for good reason. A first-round pick in 1977, he spent 11 seasons in Green Bay and piled up 82.0 sacks, still the third-most in franchise history, which is enough to make him a notable figure even before the old sideline story enters the conversation.
The controversy attached to Johnson has lingered because it came during a rough stretch and touched a nerve inside the organization, turning a preseason moment into a lasting talking point. It remains one of those Packers footnotes that gets revisited whenever Johnsons name comes up, especially by fans who remember the era and still disagree about how it should have been handled. [Read more 🡒]
Packers-Bears History Holds Some Surprising Firsts Fans May Not Know
A look back through Packers-Bears history turns up some early landmarks that still feel surprising. Green Bays record book points to Verne Lewellens 100-yard receiving game in 1926, Clark Hinkles earliest documented 100-yard rushing effort in 1936 and even the first recorded sacks by Cliff Lewis and Ezra Johnson in 1983, reminders that some of the franchises biggest statistical milestones came long before modern passing numbers became routine.
The old rivalry also carries a few record-book quirks because the early eras were not always tracked with the same precision we expect now. Lynn Dickeys 1983 outing stands out as a major passing benchmark, and Don Hutsons name surfaces in another unusual place in the statistical history against Chicago, with the available records leaving just enough uncertainty to keep the story from feeling fully settled. [Read more 🡒]
Packers Backfield Just Got Thinner At The Worst Time
The Packers backfield took another hit this week, with the club forced to adjust on the fly after Chris Brooks went down in Week 4. Brooks had been part of Green Bays depth at running back, and now the team is staring at at least four games without him, starting with the Week 5 matchup against the Bears.
Pierre Strong Jr. has been brought up to the active roster to help patch the position group in Brooks absence. For Green Bay, the timing only adds to the pressure on a backfield that was already being asked to hold together through early-season attrition, and the next few weeks will show how much flexibility the staff still has there. [Read more 🡒]