The Packers thought they were buying themselves a solution when they used three draft picks to move up for Trey Smack. Instead, they’ve landed in the same familiar mess - only this version looks even uglier.
Smack has already missed eight kicks, the most in the league, and the numbers are getting hard to ignore. Green Bay is not a team in a patient rebuild.
This is a club trying to win now, which makes every miss feel heavier. The danger isn’t just that Smack has been shaky; it’s that he’s missing the kinds of kicks that should be automatic.
His worst came on a 26-yarder indoors at Ford Field, and he’s the only kicker in the league to miss inside 30 yards this season. He also has two misses from within 40 yards, while every other kicker combined has the same number.
That’s what makes this so uncomfortable for Green Bay. The Packers already lived through this kind of storyline with Anders Carlson, sticking with a rookie kicker long enough for it to matter in the playoffs. Smack is tracking toward something worse, and the damage may arrive before January even gets here.
The Packers knew the risk when they drafted him. They traded away two seventh-round picks to move back into the sixth for Smack, so cutting bait now would mean admitting the gamble went sideways fast. But the alternative is watching a kicker who is performing below the standard of the last three Packers options continue to drag the operation down.
That’s the part that really stings. Green Bay moved on from Carlson, Brayden Narveson and Brandon McManus because they weren’t good enough.
Yet Smack has been worse than all of them. McManus missed seven kicks in 14 games last season, but Smack has already missed eight in eight games.
Carlson missed 11 in his rookie year, and Smack is on pace to blow past that. McManus, meanwhile, has played two games for the Los Angeles Rams this season and made his only field goal from 30 yards along with all eight extra points.
McManus’ playoff issues gave the Packers every reason to move on. He converted only one of four field goals and missed an extra point in postseason games, and Green Bay paid for it. But replacing him with something even shakier is not the outcome anyone had in mind.
For now, Matt LaFleur says Smack will keep the job. That leaves the Packers waiting and hoping the rookie finds his footing before the season turns into another kicking nightmare.
If they do decide to pivot, there are a few names to consider.
Lucas Havrisik is the cleanest fit. He handled himself well last year when McManus was injured, making all four of his field-goal attempts and drilling a 61-yarder that broke Mason Crosby’s franchise record.
He did miss two extra points in swirling winds at MetLife Stadium, but otherwise he was perfect. The catch is the sample size.
Havrisik’s only other NFL work came with the Giants in 2023, when he missed five field goals and three extra points. Even so, his 75 percent field-goal rate was better than Smack’s.
Then there’s Matt Prater, who remains a free agent at 42. He may not want to come back, but he was still kicking at a high level last season with the Buffalo Bills, making 18 of 20 field goals and 46 of 49 extra points.
Prater brings 19 years of NFL experience, 425 made field goals, two Pro Bowls and a second-team All-Pro nod. The question is whether he still has that level left in him.
Graham Gano is another veteran still available. He’s 39, hasn’t played since last season, and was nearly flawless when he was on the field, missing only one of 10 field goals while going perfect on extra points.
But health is the issue. Gano missed the second half of last season with back and neck injuries, and the Giants waived him in March.
The Packers are still sticking with Smack, but the margin for error is shrinking. Training camp already showed the pressure was getting to him, enough that LaFleur asked officials to stop signaling whether kicks were good in an effort to take some weight off the rookie. That didn’t change the reality once the games started.
Winter is coming, the misses are piling up, and Green Bay can’t keep pretending this is sustainable forever. Havrisik looks like the most logical fallback, but every option carries risk.
So does doing nothing. If Smack doesn’t turn it around quickly, Gutekunst may be forced to hunt for yet another kicker.
In Other News...
Packers Walk Into A Patriots Moment That Will Dominate This Week
The Week 9 trip to New England already had a little extra shine for the Packers, and now it has a broadcast wrinkle to match. Tom Brady is set to call a Patriots game at Gillette Stadium for the first time in his broadcasting career when Green Bay visits Foxborough, adding another layer of attention to a matchup that was already going to draw plenty of eyes.
Brady said he is excited to return to the stadium where so many of his biggest moments unfolded, while Patriots coach Mike Vrabel and others around the organization have been taking stock of the occasion. The conversation around the game has also drifted toward Rob Gronkowskis upcoming Hall of Fame induction, giving this week in Foxborough a distinctly Patriots flavor even before the teams take the field. [Read more 🡒]
Packers Trade Buzz Just Raised The Stakes For This Defense
With the NFL trade deadline drawing near, Green Bay has started to look like a team that could be more than a bystander. The Packers have reason to explore help on defense, especially with Micah Parsons expected back from injury, and the idea of adding another proven edge presence has only sharpened the conversation around how aggressive they want to be.
One name that has surfaced in that discussion is Khalil Mack, a veteran pass rusher who would give Green Bay another disruptive piece if the Chargers decide to listen. Los Angeles has stumbled this season, which only adds to the intrigue around whether a player of Macks caliber could become available, and for the Packers the appeal is obvious: a chance to deepen a defense that could get a lot more dangerous if the right move is made. [Read more 🡒]
Josh Jacobs Puts Packers On Edge As NFL Wait Continues
Josh Jacobs situation has taken another turn as the Packers wait for the NFLs next move. The running back is already back in the middle of a difficult legal and league process after missing six games on the commissioner-exempt list following his May arrest, and recently released police records have now added fresh allegations from three women involving physical and verbal abuse.
For Green Bay, the uncertainty is the real issue. Jacobs has said he believes in his legal defense and expects to stay on the field for the rest of the season, but the NFL investigation is still ongoing, leaving the team to monitor a case that could continue to hang over its backfield. If the league eventually acts, any suspension would likely be applied against the games he has already missed, which only adds another layer to a situation the Packers would rather not have lingering into the stretch run. [Read more 🡒]