Packers Insider Just Reopened A Frustrating Brian Gutekunst Draft Debate

General manager Brian Gutekunst faces criticism for his underperforming 2021 draft class as attention shifts to the potential impact of the Green Bay Packers' 2026 rookies.

The Green Bay Packers are heading into 2026 with hopes of chasing the NFC North crown after an early playoff exit last season, and the pressure on their young talent is obvious. If this year’s rookie class can hit, it could give Green Bay the kind of lift it needs to push itself into the NFC’s top tier.

That bigger picture is part of why Brian Gutekunst’s draft record is under the microscope. Jacob Westendorf of Sports Illustrated recently went through each of the Packers general manager’s draft classes, and his verdict on the 2021 group was brutal.

Westendorf called that class a failure from the start, pointing to injuries that derailed Eric Stokes in Green Bay and then to the Day 2 picks that followed.

“This class was a dud from the very beginning with injuries ruining Stokes’ career in Green Bay. That pick was followed up by the selections of center Josh Myers and receiver Amari Rodgers with the Day 2 picks,” the Packers insider wrote.

The rest of the class never gave the Packers much to build on. Westendorf noted that Rodgers “never found his footing and was released midway through his second season.

Myers never developed into the franchise center the team hoped he would be. Fourth-round guard Royce Newman piled up starts but never developed into an impact player.”

The most painful part, according to Westendorf, wasn’t just the production Green Bay got. It was the talent left on the board. He pointed to Creed Humphrey as the better choice than Myers and said Nico Collins was still there when the Packers took Amari Rodgers.

If 2021 was a miss, 2022 was the opposite. Westendorf gave that class a B+ and called it Gutekunst’s strongest draft, with Green Bay’s extra first-round pick from the Davante Adams deal helping shape the roster it has now. That group produced Quay Walker, Devonte Wyatt, Christian Watson, Romeo Doubs, Zach Tom, and Rasheed Walker.

Westendorf did not hand out a final grade for the Packers’ 2025 draft class, saying one season isn’t enough to judge its long-term value. For now, the focus turns to the 2026 rookie class, with training camp later this summer set to provide the first real look at how those players might fit into Green Bay’s future.

In Other News...

Savion Williams Could Become Packers Camps Most Intriguing Surprise

Savion Williams arrived in Green Bay with the kind of background that can make a training camp conversation turn quickly from roster filler to genuine curiosity. The Packers have already shown a willingness to use him on the ground a little, and his college rushing experience gives the idea some footing as the team sorts through its options behind Josh Jacobs.

The running back room is thin enough that every versatile body matters, with Chris Brooks and MarShawn Lloyd next in line and both carrying their own questions about workload and availability. Williams is still being viewed first as a wide receiver, but camp has a way of revealing whether a player is merely depth or something more, and this is one of those cases where Green Bay may want to see just how far the experiment can go. [Read more 🡒]

Packers Fans Are Missing One Crucial Detail In Christian Watson Deal

The Packers locked up Christian Watson on a four-year extension worth $92 million, a move that looks like a major commitment on paper and a clear sign they still believe in his upside. But the deal was built with enough flexibility to keep Green Bay from being stuck if Watson does not deliver the way the team hopes, which matters just as much as the headline number for a front office that has to manage its roster carefully.

Matthew Golden gives the Packers another reason to feel comfortable about the wide receiver room, because there is at least one plausible alternative if Watson cannot stay on the field or develop into the kind of top option Green Bay needs. The bigger question now is whether Watson can justify the investment and settle the debate around how the Packers are valuing him, especially with outside voices already questioning whether the price tag matches the production. [Read more 🡒]

Why Tucker Kraft Could Make Or Break Jordan Loves 2026 Offense

The Packers have spent the offseason reshaping the pieces around Jordan Love, but one of the biggest swing factors for 2026 may already be in the building. Analyst Kristopher Knox singled out Tucker Kraft as Green Bays most promising player for the season ahead, a nod to how much the tight end had already become part of the offense before his year was interrupted.

Krafts value goes beyond being another target in the passing game. He had been tracking toward a huge breakout before the setback, and the Packers are now counting on his return to restore some of the middle-of-the-field threat that can make Loves job easier. If Kraft comes back close to form, Green Bays offense looks a lot different. If he does not, the margin for error gets much thinner. [Read more 🡒]