Packers fans can dream up a Mike Tomlin rescue plan all they want, but it doesn’t line up with reality - or with what Green Bay actually needs.
The frustration in Green Bay is easy to understand. The Packers have dropped seven of eight since Micah Parsons got hurt, and the list of bad losses keeps growing: a blown double-digit lead in the Wild Card round against the Chicago Bears, a blown lead to the Minnesota Vikings in Week 1, and a blowout loss in the home opener.
Their only win in that stretch came in overtime against the ever-struggling New York Jets. That’s how close this team came to stumbling into a disaster of a start after closing last season with five straight losses.
So yes, the heat on Matt LaFleur and GM Brian Gutekunst is real. It should be.
But the idea that Tomlin is waiting in the wings for Green Bay makes no sense. It’s not happening, and it wouldn’t fix the Packers’ problems anyway.
For one thing, Tomlin is under contract to do TV this season. Whether he has some sort of clause that would let him return to coaching is speculation, nothing more.
And the Steelers didn’t fire him; he stepped away on his own. Even if he wanted back in, Pittsburgh still controls his contract, which means Green Bay would have to trade for him and give up assets instead of simply hiring a free agent.
Then there’s the football part, and that’s where the fit gets even worse.
LaFleur is being judged for failing in the biggest spots. He gets too cute when the situation calls for clarity, and his game management and clock management are described here as borderline atrocious, especially when his team is ahead.
That’s fair criticism. But swapping him for Tomlin doesn’t exactly scream upgrade for a team looking to change its direction.
Tomlin’s resume comes with a Super Bowl ring, sure, but the source makes the case that his Steelers teams settled into too many .500 seasons and first-round exits. It’s been almost a decade since his last playoff win, and even longer since Pittsburgh looked like a real contender.
Some will still point to the usual talking points - culture builder, player’s coach, someone athletes respect. But that reputation gets a hard question attached to it here: Antonio Brown, Ben Roethlisberger, Chase Claypool, Le'Veon Bell, or James Harrison.
And if Green Bay’s defense isn’t the issue, then Tomlin doesn’t even solve the right problem. The source says the real trouble is up front: a borderline-amateur offensive line, a subpar running game, and a quarterback who has improved but still slips back into gunslinger and hero-ball mode when time and space disappear.
That’s why the Tomlin chatter feels so misplaced. He’s a good coach who, in this view, was granted too much grace because of one Super Bowl years ago - the same kind of leeway Mike McCarthy got. The comparison matters because Packers fans already lived through that dynamic and didn’t like it then.
LaFleur and Tomlin may share a common flaw, too: winning games they probably shouldn’t have won, then dropping games they were expected to control. If Green Bay is moving on from LaFleur someday, the last thing it should be doing is chasing a version of the same problem in a different uniform.
And even that change may not be imminent. The Packers just gave LaFleur an extension, so there’s no guarantee they fire him this season at all.
In Other News...
Packers Just Got A Huge Chance To Fix Their Slow Start
A 1-2 start has left the Packers with work to do, and the timing of the next two opponents could not be much better for a team trying to steady itself. Green Bays rough opening has already included a significant loss to the Falcons, so every chance to bank a win now carries a little more weight as the season starts to settle in.
The upcoming matchups with the Buccaneers and Bears may come against backup quarterbacks, with Caleb Williams and Baker Mayfield dealing with injuries. If that holds, it gives Green Bays defense a real opening to tilt the next stretch in its favor, and the Packers could use exactly that kind of help as they look to turn an uneven start into something more manageable. [Read more 🡒]
Packers Just Sent A Clear Message About Their Offensive Line Problem
Green Bays approach to the offensive line has turned into one of the clearest themes of the early roster-building cycle, and Brian Gutekunst kept leaning into it with another veteran addition. After extending Sean Rhyan and restructuring Aaron Banks contract, the Packers also brought in guard help by signing Mekhi Becton, while Laken Tomlinson and Cordell Volson were recent arrivals on the practice squad.
Becton gives the Packers another experienced body to evaluate at a position group that has needed attention, and his background at guard with the Eagles and Chargers makes him a practical fit for the kind of flexibility teams want this time of year. He was also recently cleared from a shoulder injury, which adds another layer of intrigue as Green Bay keeps trying to stabilize a unit that has been a recurring concern. [Read more 🡒]
Packers Just Sent A Clear Message About Their Offensive Line
The Packers moved quickly this week to shore up an offensive line that needed attention, bringing in Laken Tomlinson and Mekhi Becton as part of a clear effort to add experience and size up front. Becton, a former first-round pick with six years of NFL experience, had worked out for Green Bay before the signing, giving the team a chance to see where he fit before making the move.
To create room on the 53-man roster, Green Bay is expected to place Zach Bako-Bewele and Jayden Reed on injured reserve. It is another sign that the Packers are treating the line as a priority, and the additions suggest the team is still sorting out how best to stabilize that group as the season moves forward. [Read more 🡒]