Let's dive into the intriguing world of NFL special teams coaching, specifically focusing on the role of kicking coaches. It's a topic that doesn't often get the spotlight, but it's crucial when you consider how many games hinge on a well-placed field goal.
Kevin O’Dea, a seasoned special teams coach, once highlighted the financial impact of those game-deciding kicks. With coaching staffs expanding, you'd think kicking coaches would be more common, yet they're surprisingly rare. O’Dea pointed out that while teams are willing to employ multiple coaches for other positions, the idea of a dedicated kicking coach often gets sidelined due to budget considerations.
The New York Jets, under O’Dea's influence, led the league in special teams performance last season, showcasing the potential value of specialized coaching. Yet, most teams still rely on general feedback rather than in-depth coaching for kickers. Many kickers end up hiring personal coaches to refine their skills, receiving weekly insights that aren't available during games.
This dynamic creates a unique challenge. Special teams coordinators, often experts in coverage rather than kicking, may feel uneasy about bringing in outside specialists. Meanwhile, kickers might be hesitant to integrate new voices, especially when they've been working with personal coaches for years.
In examining the backgrounds of NFL special teams coaches for the 2025 season, it's clear that few have direct experience as kickers, punters, or long snappers. Most come from positions like linebackers or defensive backs, which are heavily involved in special teams play.
Take the Green Bay Packers, for example. Their special teams usage reflects a league-wide trend, with offensive players seeing limited action in the kicking game. The Seahawks, on the other hand, utilized a fullback extensively, highlighting variations in strategy.
Currently, only four coaches in the NFL have a background in kicking, punting, or long snapping. Darrin Simmons of the Bengals, Randy Brown and his son Tyler with the Ravens, and Chris Gould with the Chargers are the exceptions. Their careers illustrate the rarity of such specialists in coaching roles.
Darrin Simmons has been a staple with the Bengals since 2003, bringing his punting expertise to the team. Randy Brown, a former college kicker, has been with the Ravens since 2008, while his son Tyler joined the Eagles in 2021. Chris Gould, brother of former All-Pro kicker Robbie Gould, transitioned from playing to coaching, now serving with the Chargers.
These coaches, particularly those connected to the Harbaugh family, represent a small but significant group advocating for specialized kicking knowledge within the NFL. Despite their success, the league is still waiting for more specialists, like long snappers, to break into coaching roles.
In conclusion, while the NFL has made strides in many areas, the integration of dedicated kicking coaches remains limited. As the league evolves, it will be fascinating to see if more teams recognize the potential benefits of investing in this specialized expertise.