The Packers got out of MetLife Stadium with a win on Sunday, but the way they got there did not exactly quiet the noise around Matt LaFleur. If anything, it put his play-calling under an even brighter light after Green Bay’s first two games.
LaFleur, who signed a massive extension in the offseason, was already a major part of the conversation after the Packers’ stunning loss to the Minnesota Vikings last week. Against the New York Jets, he gave the same critics plenty more to point to. Green Bay survived, but the game plan often felt disconnected from what was actually happening on the field, and the Packers nearly opened 0-2 for the first time in 20 years.
The weather made the shape of the game obvious from the start. Rain was in the forecast, and the conditions at MetLife Stadium were every bit the kind that usually push a team toward the ground game. The trouble for Green Bay is that this roster was not built to lean on that strength for four quarters.
The offensive line issues were already a problem, and they only worsened when starting tackle Zach Bako-Bewele went down with a seemingly season-ending injury. Add in the fact that Josh Jacobs is still on the commissioner's exempt list, and the Packers were left with a running back-by-committee approach that never really threatened the Jets. Kaleb Johnson, MarShawn Lloyd, and Chris Brooks split the workload and combined for just 63 yards on 18 carries.
Even with that lack of production, LaFleur kept trying to force the issue. On nine of Green Bay’s 12 drives, the first play was a run.
Sometimes it worked. More often, it put the offense behind the sticks immediately, leaving the Packers chasing manageable downs that never came.
That predictability eventually bit them. Early in the fourth quarter, Johnson fumbled on a first-down run, and the Jets turned that into a 17-7 lead. By then, the formula had become easy to see: simple runs up the middle behind an offensive line that was not creating space or rhythm.
The last two drives in regulation were the clearest examples of the problem. After the Packers forced a Jets punt and Skyy Moore ripped off a 63-yard return, Green Bay had the ball at the Jets’ 15-yard line down three.
Instead of attacking the moment, LaFleur called back-to-back run plays that produced only three total yards, including a one-yard loss on the second snap. The Packers failed to convert on third down and had to settle for a tying field goal.
Then came the next strange sequence. After the Packers stopped the Jets on fourth down, they got the ball at midfield with a real chance to take control and set up a game-winning kick.
Instead, all three plays were passes, including a deep shot on second down that did not make much sense even though Jordan Love had room to run. LaFleur did manage the clock well enough to force overtime, but the Packers had already put themselves in a spot where overtime should not have been necessary.
None of this means LaFleur has suddenly become a bad coach or a bad play caller. His track record says otherwise.
But over the first two games, he has looked too tied to the script and not responsive enough to the flow of the game. That kind of rigidity can create more afternoons like this one, and it is the sort of issue Green Bay needs fixed fast if it wants to be what it thinks it is.
In Other News...
Packers Fans Have Another Reason To Be Furious With NFL Officiating
Week 2 brought another round of frustration for Packers fans, and not just because of the usual game-day complaints. Meghan Payton publicly took aim at the NFLs officiating standards after a series of unsportsmanlike conduct penalties across the league, a conversation that included flags on Packers safety Javon Bullard as well as Saints receiver Chris Olave.
The bigger issue is the direction the league has taken this season, with the Competition Committee putting taunting and illegal celebrations near the top of its enforcement list. Officials and league representatives have already laid out the reasoning behind the tighter standard, but the more aggressively it is applied, the more it is likely to keep drawing grumbles from teams and fans who feel the games are getting too tightly policed. [Read more 🡒]
Packers Fans Got Caught In Foxs Most Infuriating Broadcast Mess
Fox Sports turned Week 2 into a headache for viewers across the NFL, and Packers fans had their own moment of broadcast frustration during the overtime stretch of the Packers-Jets game. Multiple early games were affected when the audio feeds did not match the action on screen, leaving viewers listening to commentary that had nothing to do with the game they were watching, while Fox also briefly lost its scorebug during Green Bays overtime finish.
The network got the audio problem sorted out before the primetime Cowboys-Commanders matchup, but the damage had already been done for anyone trying to follow the early slate. For Packers fans, it was one more layer of annoyance on a day when the game itself was already moving into tense territory, and the broadcast breakdown made an already chaotic afternoon feel even messier. [Read more 🡒]
Trey Smack Is Already Changing A Packers Conversation Fans Dreaded
The Packers overtime win over the Jets brought a welcome dose of stability to a spot that has too often been a source of anxiety in Green Bay. Rookie kicker Trey Smack handled the moment with a game-winning field goal, and through the first two weeks of the season he has made all five of his attempts, quickly giving the team something it did not have much of last year: confidence when the game is on the line.
After the playoff frustration that lingered through the offseason, Smacks early showing has changed the tone around the kicking job in a hurry. He has already shown range and the kind of mental toughness the Packers were hoping to find, while Jordan Love and the offense did their part in getting the team into position for the finish. For now, Green Bay has a new reason to feel better about one of its most nerve-wracking situations. [Read more 🡒]