Looking back at the Green Bay Packers’ 2021 draft class, it’s easy to see why it still leaves a sour taste. The year was already a strange one across the league, with COVID scrambling the college landscape and leaving scouts with far less to work with than usual. With that in mind, it’s worth rewinding the board and asking what Green Bay might have done differently in a perfect world.
For this exercise, the focus stays on the first five rounds, and any replacement has to be a player who was taken within ten picks of Green Bay’s original selection. That framework quickly turns the class into a series of regret-filled what-ifs.
The first-round choice at No. 29 was Eric Stokes, and his time in Green Bay was marked by inconsistency. He appears to have turned his career around with the Las Vegas Raiders, but if the Packers could do it over, the obvious answer within range would be Landon Dickerson. The Philadelphia Eagles lineman has dealt with injuries, but when he’s available, he’s one of the league’s most dependable players.
Round two at No. 62 brought Josh Myers, whose run as an expected contributor didn’t last long. That makes this one another easy pivot, especially with so many misses available in that part of the draft. The best alternative within reach is Houston Texans backup quarterback Davis Mills, who would have given Green Bay a stabilizing presence behind Jordan Love.
By round three, the Packers had taken Amari Rodgers at No. 85, just four picks before Nico Collins came off the board. Collins, now with the Houston Texans, would have given Green Bay a receiver who fit Matt LaFleur’s offense and a player with real upside alongside Jordan Love. It’s not hard to picture what that pairing might have looked like, or what kind of numbers Collins could have produced as the top target.
The fourth-round pick at No. 142 was Royce Newman, another name that never really stuck. In a re-draft, the better move would be Ta’Quon Graham, now with the Philadelphia Eagles. He’s the kind of defensive line depth piece who can pop up with a few eye-catching plays over the course of a season and provide value Green Bay likely would have kept around.
At No. 173 in round five, the Packers went with TJ Slaton, hoping for defensive line help that never really materialized. The clearer choice here is safety Talanoa Hufanga, who has built an impressive career and would have been a major force at the back end of Green Bay’s defense.
The final pick in this exercise, Shemar Jean-Charles at No. 178, is the one spot where the debate gets a little more interesting. That’s not because Jean-Charles made a strong case for himself, but because the group of players available within ten picks of that selection wasn’t especially loaded.
Even so, Avery Williams would have been the better bet. He has carved out a solid role as a returner and depth option for the Atlanta Falcons, which gives him more staying power than Jean-Charles ever provided.
In Other News...
Packers Fans Have Every Right To Worry About This Protection Plan
The Packers are already mapping out their next move at left tackle, and it points to Jordan Morgan stepping into a far bigger role in 2026 after spending most of last season at guard. Green Bay made Morgan a first-round pick in 2024 for a reason, and the team still believes his tackle background gives him a path to becoming a better fit on the edge as he gets more reps there.
Rasheed Walkers departure to Carolina leaves a spot that was shaky enough to make the transition feel manageable on paper, but not necessarily comfortable for anyone invested in Jordan Loves protection. Walkers 2025 season set a low enough bar that Morgan does not have to be dominant to look like an upgrade, yet the Packers are still betting on projection over certainty at one of the most important spots on the line. [Read more 🡒]
Packers Fans Have Every Right To Be Furious Over Tucker Kraft
Tucker Krafts rise has already made him one of the Packers most intriguing young players, and the league clearly sees it too. Even after his season was interrupted last November by a torn right ACL, ESPNs 2026 tight end rankings put the Green Bay standout No. 6, a sign that scouts, executives, and coaches still view him as one of the positions most complete players.
What keeps the conversation going is how much more there may still be there once he gets fully back. Kraft has earned praise for his receiving, blocking, and leadership, and there is a growing sense around the league that his best football could still be ahead of him. For Packers fans, the frustrating part is obvious: just as he was breaking out, the injury cut everything short. [Read more 🡒]