When the Detroit Lions brought in head coach Dan Campbell and general manager Brad Holmes, they embarked on a mission to rebuild the franchise from the ground up. A pivotal move in this journey was trading away quarterback Matthew Stafford to acquire Jared Goff.
They also secured foundational pieces like right tackle Penei Sewell and wide receiver Amon-Ra St. Brown.
Among their strategic veteran signings was linebacker Alex Anzalone.
Anzalone, familiar to Campbell from their days with the New Orleans Saints, was a known quantity. After a solid 2021, the Lions re-signed him for 2022, and his consistent performance earned him a three-year, $18.75 million deal in 2023, securing their defensive captain for the long haul.
Now, with five seasons under his belt in Detroit and his role evolving, the question looms: Should the Lions bring Anzalone back in 2026? Let's break it down.
Alex Anzalone: Expectations vs. Reality
2025 Expectations
With linebacker Jack Campbell stepping up after his 2024 sophomore season, the Lions began grooming him as the future defensive leader. Campbell's increased responsibilities meant Anzalone's role would shift slightly in 2025.
Although still a starter, he wouldn't be the primary play-caller. Nonetheless, his presence was crucial, particularly in coverage, and the team valued his contributions immensely.
2025 Performance
Anzalone's stats tell the story: 16 games, 95 tackles, nine pass deflections, four tackles for loss, two and a half sacks, and an interception. His PFF grades were solid across the board, notably with a tackling grade that ranked 10th out of 94.
Despite a contract dispute in July, where Anzalone expressed a desire to retire as a Lion, the team made a slight contract adjustment to keep him motivated. He delivered a strong season, finishing second on the team in tackles and showcasing his tackling prowess.
Looking Ahead to 2026
Pros of Re-signing Anzalone
Anzalone's veteran presence is invaluable. He's deeply familiar with the team's culture and coaching staff, having been part of the franchise's transformation. With limited linebacker depth heading into 2026, his experience could be crucial.
Cons of Re-signing Anzalone
The primary hurdle is cost. Re-signing Anzalone might mean sacrificing other key players like edge defender Al-Quadin Muhammad or cornerback Amik Robertson.
Additionally, younger talents like Jack Campbell, Jahmyr Gibbs, Sam LaPorta, and Brian Branch will soon need extensions. Anzalone, turning 32 in September, might not fit the Lions' vision of getting younger.
Interest from Both Sides?
While Anzalone has expressed a desire to stay, the Lions seem ready to move on. Contract disputes have strained relations, and Anzalone's social media outbursts haven’t helped. Despite coach Dan Campbell's praise, the cost and timing don't align for a re-signing unless circumstances change.
Financial Considerations
Spotrac estimates Anzalone's market value at $7.3 million annually, suggesting a potential two-year, $14.5 million deal. This would be a pay increase from his previous contract.
Conclusion
Ultimately, it seems time for the Lions to part ways with Anzalone. With a tight budget and a focus on retaining younger talent, the Lions must prioritize future flexibility over short-term veteran presence. Anzalone's recent actions have only simplified the decision for Detroit's front office.
What do you think the Lions should do about Alex Anzalone? Share your thoughts in the comments!