LSUs Gonzaga Win Showed Why College Basketballs New Eligibility Fight Matters

As the new college basketball season unfolds with unexpected twists, powerhouse programs like Duke face early challenges while veteran athletes and rookie coaches are making their mark.

Two weeks into the 2026-27 college basketball season, the sport already feels like it has been through a full month of chaos.

That’s what happens when the schedule opens with a pile of marquee games and the offseason has already been packed with lawsuits, eligibility fights, and roster uncertainty. The early returns have given us plenty to sort through, and the biggest takeaway so far is simple: a lot of the teams we thought we knew are still trying to figure themselves out.

Duke is the clearest example. A couple of weeks ago, the Blue Devils were sitting near the very top of the national conversation.

Now they’ve taken a 79-73 loss to Michigan State and followed it with a rough 99-78 home defeat to Illinois, matching last year’s regular-season loss total already. The problems go beyond the final scores.

Duke doesn’t have a true star, and after back-to-back seasons with Cooper Flagg and Cameron Boozer, that absence stands out. No Blue Devil is in the top 500 in shot usage, and there isn’t a dependable late-game scorer to lean on.

Freshman Joaquim Boumtje Boumtje was supposed to fill that role, but the jumper hasn’t come around yet.

The shooting has been ugly across the board. Duke is hitting just 28.2% from three, and only senior guard Caleb Foster is above 30% on more than 10 attempts.

Wisconsin transfer John Blackwell was brought in to help the spacing, but he’s 10-for-35 from deep so far. The defense has issues too.

Playing Boumtje Boumtje and Patrick Ngongba together has hurt the team’s mobility, and the perimeter defense is thin outside of Dame Sarr and Sebastian Wilkins, who can’t really share the floor because the spacing gets cramped. It’s a lot to fix, and the problems are stacking up fast.

The eligibility battles that dominated the offseason have already left a visible mark on the season, too. The NCAA’s move to a five-in-five eligibility model, the decision to exclude the 2022 high school class, and the lawsuits that followed were a major talking point all summer.

Last Saturday’s LSU-Gonzaga game showed exactly why. Seven of Gonzaga’s 14 assists came from Xaivian Lee and Javon Bennett, both of whom got a fifth year through the courts.

Stretch forward Chauncey Wiggins also made his Gonzaga debut after being ruled eligible just days earlier.

LSU’s fifth-year pair had the bigger night. Donovan Dent and Skyy Clark combined for 37 points and 11 assists, and Dent finished the job with a last-second 3-pointer to give LSU the win.

Strip away the eligibility lawsuits, and the game would have looked completely different on both sides. The effects reach well beyond that matchup, with Kansas’ Tre White and Melvin Council, Texas Tech’s Darrion Williams, Donovan Atwell, and Jamichael Stillwell, and Iowa State’s Tamin Lipsey all giving major production to top teams.

If Duke’s slide was jarring, Florida’s stumble against Houston may have been even more revealing. After Duke lost on Tuesday, No.

1 Florida had a chance to make a statement and separate itself from the pack. Instead, the Gators were outscored by 13 in the second half and fell to No.

8 Houston. The warning signs were already there.

Florida lost to Baylor in the preseason, had uneven stretches against Miami and Florida State, and has shown concerning depth issues against quality opponents. Against Houston, the bench managed only two points, not counting Urban Klavzar.

Houston deserves plenty of credit for the result. The Cougars lost Kingston Flemings to the NBA draft in June, but Dedan Thomas Jr. looks like the new centerpiece at point guard. Add in defensive standout JoJo Tugler, and Houston has the kind of mix Kelvin Sampson always wants: toughness, rebounding, defense, and enough scoring support around it.

One of the quieter but still important trends from the opening stretch is the drop-off in freshman production. Last season’s freshman class was loaded, and nearly all of those stars are now in the NBA.

With fifth-year players taking up more roster spots and the high school class not looking nearly as strong, first-year impact has fallen off. Last year, four of the top six KenPom Player of the Year scores came from freshmen.

This season, none are in the top 10. Missouri’s Jason Crowe Jr. is the only power-conference freshman averaging at least 18 points per game, a steep drop from the eight freshmen from major conferences who hit that mark last season.

That doesn’t mean the class won’t improve. Tyran Stokes at Kansas and Jordan Smith Jr. at Arkansas have flashed, even if the shooting hasn’t been efficient yet.

Boumtje Boumtje and UCLA’s Nikola Kusturica should grow into stars. But the first two weeks have made one thing clear: last season’s freshman explosion is not being repeated.

There’s also been a strong early showing from a wave of new head coaches. Four power-conference coaches guided their teams to the NCAA Tournament last season in their first year on the job, and the portal has only made it easier for new staffs to reshape a roster quickly.

This year, Michigan’s Mike Boynton, LSU’s Will Wade, Cincinnati’s Jerrod Calhoun, Utah State’s Ben Jacobson, and Providence’s Bryan Hodgson all have teams in KenPom’s top 50. Some inherited more than others, but the early results are encouraging across the board.

The same goes for coaches stepping into jobs once held by program icons. Saint Mary’s, now led by Mickey McConnell, is ahead of former Gaels coach Randy Bennett and Arizona State in KenPom. Creighton has also started well under Alan Huss, who took over for the now-retired Greg McDermott, with an impressive win over Iowa and a 3-1 record.

The season is still young, but the early picture is already messy in all the right ways. Duke is vulnerable, Florida has questions, fifth-year players are shaping big games, freshmen are taking longer to arrive, and new coaches are making noise right away.

In Other News...

Gonzaga Women Just Offered An Early Glimpse Of The Programs Next Core

Gonzaga womens basketball has already started laying the groundwork for its next wave, with Lisa Fortier and the Bulldogs announcing two signees for the 2027 recruiting class. Aylah Cornwall, a 5-8 point guard from Spokane, and Lilli Schultze, a 6-3 forward from Berlin, give the program an early look at the kind of mix it continues to target: local backcourt toughness paired with size and international experience.

Cornwall arrives with plenty of recognition close to home, having been named the Greater Spokane Leagues 2025-26 Most Valuable Player and Defensive Player of the Year. Schultze brings a different rsum, one built overseas after earning MVP honors in Germanys top U-18 womens basketball league in 2024-25 and competing professionally with Alba Berlin, a sign that Gonzaga is already trying to shape the future with players who can help in very different ways. [Read more 🡒]

Gonzagas Biggest Early Problem Isnt Talent And It Could Take Time

The early issues around Gonzaga this season have not looked like a talent problem so much as a timing one. With late player arrivals and some eligibility uncertainty hanging over the roster, the Bulldogs have spent the opening stretch trying to build chemistry on the fly, and it has shown up in the usual places a new group tends to wobble - turnovers, uneven shooting and stretches where the offense never quite settles in. Through the first four games, the lineup has leaned on players still learning each others habits, which can make even a deep roster look a step behind.

Montana State offered a useful snapshot of why that matters. The Bobcats came in with more continuity and experience, and they were able to make Gonzaga work for everything in a game that exposed how much cohesion can count in November. For Gonzaga, the bigger concern is not whether the pieces fit in the long run, but how long it may take before they start fitting cleanly enough to avoid these early stumbles. [Read more 🡒]