The Warriors brought back De’Anthony Melton on a two-year, $11 million deal last week, but the move already comes with a clear burden attached. Golden State passed on a more offense-heavy option in Anfernee Simons, and that choice is now under the microscope.
ESPN’s Anthony Slater reported Monday that the Warriors leaned toward Melton because they believe he fits better next to Stephen Curry in the backcourt. That view, though, is still more projection than proof, especially with both players dealing with injury issues over the last two seasons.
“They opted to retain Melton instead of putting more behind a pursuit of Simons, team sources said, because of a belief that Melton better fits the backcourt needs of the healthiest version of their current roster. He's not as explosive a scorer but is a more versatile and effective perimeter defender and pairs well with Stephen Curry,” Slater wrote.
That pairing has barely had time to breathe. Melton’s first run with the Warriors in 2024 lasted just two games as a starter alongside Curry before a torn ACL shut him down.
Curry then dealt with his own knee injury last season shortly after Melton came back. In all, the two have shared the floor in only 31 games, though that number is expected to climb after this latest decision.
The fit may make sense on paper, but the roster picture still leaves Golden State with obvious offensive questions if the front office can’t land LeBron James and if Jimmy Butler remains in the middle of a long-term recovery.
That’s why plenty of fans were hoping the Warriors would go the Simons route instead. He signed a two-year, $12.2 million deal with the Philadelphia 76ers, a contract that was very close to Melton’s and would have brought a more proven scoring punch to a team that needs it.
Melton did post a career-high 12.3 points per game in his return with Golden State, but the shooting numbers were shaky: 40.7% from the field and 29.4% from 3-point range. Simons, meanwhile, has averaged 18.8 points over the past five seasons while shooting 38.1% from deep.
That’s why the comparison is coming fast, and it’s not going away. Fans will be watching both players closely early next season, and Melton will be under immediate pressure to show the Warriors made the right call.
In Other News...
Draymond Green Blasts Celtics Over Stunning Jaylen Brown Trade
Draymond Green didnt hide his reaction to Bostons latest roster shake-up, taking aim at a trade that sent Jaylen Brown out of the Celtics orbit and immediately sparked debate around the league. From Golden States perspective, it was the kind of move that invites instant overreaction, especially when a player of Browns stature changes teams and the first question is whether one side just handed the other a major advantage.
Greens criticism landed in the middle of a broader back-and-forth about how to judge the deal, with some seeing Philadelphia as the clear winner and others pointing to the uncertainty around Paul Georges recent play and health as a reason to slow down. Even in a league that lives on bold swings, this is the sort of transaction that can look one way on the day it happens and another way once the dust settles, which is why the discussion around Boston is far from finished. [Read more 🡒]
Warriors May Already Regret Passing On This Draft Night Opportunity
Golden State has gotten a promising early look at Yaxel Lendeborg at the California Classic, but the bigger draft-night question is whether the front office left another useful piece on the board. The Warriors had interest in a few players who slid farther than expected, and the kind of move that might have brought one of them into the fold was there if they wanted to push up into the early part of the first round.
Instead, the player drawing the most attention has been the one they watched land elsewhere, and he has already started to look like more than just a Summer League flash. His recent run has only sharpened the sense that Golden State may have passed on a chance to add a wing with real long-term value, especially with other names the team liked still waiting to make their own summer debuts. [Read more 🡒]