Kirk Herbstreit is not backing away from his preseason national title pick on Notre Dame just yet, but after five weeks, he’s clearly widening the lens.
On his Nonstop podcast with former Ohio State receiver Joey Galloway, the ESPN analyst said the Fighting Irish still deserve scrutiny, then pointed to Miami, Georgia and Alabama as the programs he’d place in the same conversation for the sport’s top team.
“Because for me, it feels like the two best teams right now, I would put Miami in that discussion. I would put Georgia in that discussion.
I would put Alabama in that discussion. They're actually playing each other this weekend,” Herbstreit said.
He then pushed Galloway on whether Notre Dame and Texas still belonged near the top. “Would you put Notre Dame right now in that discussion, even though they haven't been tested? Would you put Texas in that discussion, even though they're the number one team in the country?”
Galloway, who also had Notre Dame winning it all before the season, didn’t jump off the bandwagon. “I don't feel as good about Notre Dame as I did when we began the season.
That doesn't mean I feel bad about them. That means I don't feel as good,” he said.
The Irish are 5-0 and ranked No. 3 in the AP poll, but the skepticism comes from the schedule. Notre Dame has handled Wisconsin, Rice, Michigan State and Purdue by a combined 169-33, then survived its closest test with a 37-26 win at North Carolina. CJ Carr has been sharp through the first month, completing 88 of 124 passes for 1,197 yards with 13 touchdowns and one interception.
The numbers beneath the surface still paint Notre Dame in a strong light. The Irish sit first nationally in net expected points added per play, a measure adjusted for opponent, home field and garbage time, and sixth in adjusted defense. Texas is third in adjusted defense, but only 49th on offense.
Notre Dame gets Stanford at home Saturday before heading to No. 8 BYU on Oct. 17.
Herbstreit’s latest comments came after Miami’s 41-13 rout at Clemson on Oct. 3, a result that left the No. 4 Hurricanes alone atop the ACC at 5-0 overall and 3-0 in league play. Darian Mensah passed for 227 yards and a touchdown, added a 34-yard scoring run, and Mark Fletcher Jr. rushed for 77 yards and two touchdowns as Miami piled up a 192-55 edge on the ground.
The Hurricanes are sixth nationally in adjusted offensive efficiency, and they’ll also get Notre Dame later this season. Miami visits South Bend on Nov. 7, one year after beating the Irish 27-24 in the 2025 opener and claiming the final at-large playoff spot over them.
Georgia has built its own case with points, plenty of them. The No.
2 Bulldogs are 5-0 and 3-0 in the SEC, and their 257 points through five games are just one shy of the 1910 team’s program record for that span. They knocked off Oklahoma 41-13 and Vanderbilt 38-14, with Gunner Stockton throwing for 295 yards and three touchdowns against the Commodores.
Even so, the underlying metrics are less flattering. Georgia’s net efficiency rank sits at 31st nationally, and its adjusted defense is 67th, the weakest profile of the four teams Herbstreit mentioned. Two weeks into the season, Herbstreit was blunt about the Bulldogs: “We don't know anything about Georgia.”
Alabama has also surged into the mix. The No.
6 Crimson Tide are 5-0 and 3-0 in the SEC, and they’ve scored at least 49 points in each of their last three games. That stretch ended with a 56-23 win at No.
16 Mississippi State, where Keelon Russell threw three touchdown passes and ran for another. After that performance, Paul Finebaum called Alabama college football’s most complete team.
The Crimson Tide’s profile backs up the buzz. They rank second nationally in net efficiency and ninth in adjusted defense.
Now the spotlight turns to Saturday night’s showdown in Tuscaloosa. Georgia visits Alabama at 7:30 p.m.
ET on ABC from Bryant-Denny Stadium. The teams split two meetings last season, with Alabama winning 24-21 in Athens and Georgia taking the SEC Championship Game 28-7.
In Other News...
Scott Cross Faces Immediate Pressure To Prove Georgia Tech Is Finally Resetting
Scott Cross officially takes over at Georgia Tech next month, and the early message from the new head coach is less about splash and more about structure. At the ACC media event, he talked about rebuilding around daily effort and team chemistry, a sensible place to start for a program trying to steady itself and move past the uncertainty that has hovered over the Yellow Jackets.
Cross also leaned on his own coaching background as he outlined the challenge ahead, especially in a league where nothing comes easy and the roster he inherits is built largely from transfers and freshmen. For Georgia Tech, the pressure is immediate because the reset cannot just look good on paper. It has to start showing up in how this group fits together and competes once the games begin. [Read more 🡒]
Georgia Tech Faces A Brutal ACC Test In The Trenches
Georgia Tech comes out of its bye week staring at one of the ACCs more demanding measuring sticks, with undefeated Duke waiting in a matchup that should say plenty about where both teams stand in the conference race. The Blue Devils have leaned into a strong running game, while Georgia Techs recent defensive issues make the trenches a particularly important battleground for this one.
There is also some familiar history working in the Yellow Jackets favor, as Georgia Tech has handled Duke well over the years, but the current version of this game feels a little less about tradition and a lot more about health and matchups. Injury uncertainty for Georgia Tech adds another layer of concern, and with both teams coming off a week off, the first few series may tell the story of whether the Jackets can hold up against a physical challenge that has been building for days. [Read more 🡒]
Karen Blair Is Betting On One Edge For Georgia Techs Next Step
Georgia Tech womens basketball is leaning into continuity as it heads toward the new season, and that message came through clearly at ACC Tipoff with coach Karen Blair and players LaNya Foster and Talayah Walker. Blair pointed to a roster that brings back seven players from last year, giving the Yellow Jackets a base of familiarity as they try to build on what was established a season ago. The emphasis, at least for now, is less on reinvention and more on sharpening the connections that can make a good team more reliable.
Blair also stressed how much the program values the homecourt edge it created last season, a sign that Georgia Tech wants its building to matter beyond just the box score. The staff has also spent time working to engage more with the community and fans, another piece of the programs push to make the atmosphere around the team feel stronger and more connected. If the Yellow Jackets are going to take the next step, they appear convinced it will start with chemistry, familiarity and a crowd that feels invested. [Read more 🡒]