Georgia once chased Arch Manning hard enough to make him a real target for Kirby Smart and the Bulldogs, and for a while it looked like Sanford Stadium might be his home. Instead, Manning went to Texas, and what felt like a major recruiting miss then looks different now.
Three years later, Smart may be better off treating that battle as history.
The conversation around Manning has shifted sharply after a rocky stretch at Texas, where questions about his future have started to surface. There’s at least a possibility that he could enter the transfer portal after the 2026 season, and if that happens, Georgia would be wise not to run back into the same chase.
Manning’s situation took on a different tone after Texas dropped consecutive games to Oklahoma and Florida. Steve Sarkisian opened the door to evaluating him, and although Sarkisian has since said Manning remains his starter, the fact that his role came up at all says plenty about how the year has gone.
Through six games this season, Manning has completed 63.9 percent of his passes for 1,295 yards, 11 touchdowns and five interceptions. Those numbers are not a disaster, but they fall far short of the kind of production people expected from a quarterback who entered the season carrying Heisman Trophy buzz and a projected No. 1 overall NFL Draft label.
The Florida loss was especially rough. Manning threw for 173 yards and one touchdown in a 27-24 defeat, and a late fumble helped seal it. That came one week after a late interception stopped Texas from taking the lead against Oklahoma.
There were stretches last season when Manning looked better, and that deserves to be noted. But this season has been inconsistent enough that the questions have become hard to brush aside.
That doesn’t mean he can’t become a good college quarterback down the line. He still has the tools and the experience to attract interest from plenty of programs. But potential and fit are not the same thing as being the right answer for an offense that needs someone it can count on.
That’s where Georgia should be careful not to get caught up in the same appeal that made Manning such a coveted recruit in the first place. Three years ago, landing him would have been a huge win for Smart and his staff. He was the type of prospect who could energize an entire class and dominate the headlines.
But famous names and recruiting rankings don’t score points. Production does, and Manning hasn’t produced at a level that has matched the hype surrounding him.
That doesn’t make Georgia’s original pursuit a mistake. He was an elite prospect, and nearly every major program wanted him. It just means the Bulldogs now have a fuller picture than they did the first time around.
If Smart needs help at quarterback through the transfer portal, he should be aiming for the player who gives Georgia the best shot to win, not the one who would generate the loudest reaction. Manning’s name would absolutely create a wave of buzz if he became available, and any move involving him would be one of the biggest offseason stories in college football.
But Smart is not trying to win a publicity contest. He is trying to win games.
He is not looking to spend NIL money just to make noise. He wants players who are worth paying.
Maybe Manning eventually puts it together and becomes the quarterback people thought he’d be. That door is still open, whether at Texas or somewhere else. But if his time with the Longhorns ends after this year, Georgia should feel no pressure to be the team that takes the next swing.
In Other News...
Georgia May Be Missing A Crucial Defender Against Florida
Georgias defense could be waiting on a familiar name this week, as safety KJ Bolden works his way back from the injury he picked up against Alabama. Kirby Smart said Bolden is hopeful to return, but the final call will depend on whether he gets through the doctors protocol in time for the Florida game.
Bolden already missed the Auburn game, and his absence was part of the conversation around why the defense struggled. With Florida next on the schedule, Georgia would like to have one of its more important defensive pieces back in the secondary, but for now the situation remains uncertain. [Read more 🡒]
Georgia Suddenly Has A Real Fight To Keep Jayden Wade
Georgias hold on its 2028 quarterback commitment is being tested in a way that felt far off only a short time ago. Five-star signal caller Jayden Wade is reportedly set to visit Michigan this weekend, giving another program a chance to make its case to one of the most important recruits in the cycle.
The trip is notable because quarterback development has been a question for Michigan, and the programs current situation at the position is part of what Georgia will have to navigate in keeping Wade on board. NIL could also become a factor in the recruitment if the Wolverines choose to make a major push, leaving this one as a real battle worth watching for the Bulldogs. [Read more 🡒]
Georgia Just Lost Ground In A Key Recruiting Battle
Georgias 2027 class took a hit with linebacker Temorris Campbell backing off his commitment, a move that comes after he pledged to the Bulldogs in May. Campbell is regarded as one of the top linebackers nationally and one of the better prospects in Florida, so his decision is the kind that can ripple through an early recruiting class, especially at a position Georgia has long prioritized.
The Bulldogs still have Joakim Gouda committed at linebacker for 2027, and the class remains ranked ninth nationally by 247Sports, but losing ground with a high-level defender is never ideal this far out. Even in a class that still sits inside the top 10, Georgia will now have to keep working to stabilize its linebacker board and defend against the kind of late movement that can reshape a cycle before it really gets started. [Read more 🡒]