Tommy Castellanos has found himself in the middle of the NCAA’s latest eligibility mess, and this time he came out on the right side of it.
The former Florida State quarterback was originally expecting his college career to end after the 2025-26 season. Then the NCAA’s new eligibility framework changed the picture for Class of 2022 athletes, opening the possibility of a fifth season.
But that didn’t make things simple for Castellanos. Because the transfer portal window had already closed, he still couldn’t move on his own.
So he went to court.
A Kentucky judge granted Castellanos a temporary injunction that gave him both a fifth season of eligibility and access to the transfer portal. He entered the portal and was later picked up by Texas Tech to play in the 2026 season.
His case sits inside a much bigger fight over how college football is supposed to work under the NCAA’s new “five-for-five” system. Under that model, Division I athletes have five continuous years to complete five seasons of competition. The NCAA says the goal is to make eligibility more predictable and cut down on the extra years that piled up under a waiver-heavy system.
But the Class of 2022 was not grandfathered in.
Instead, those athletes got their extra year after a federal judge in Colorado issued an injunction allowing them to compete for a fifth season. The NCAA appealed that ruling, and on Aug. 21, the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals temporarily halted it.
That left athletes in a strange spot. Some had already returned to campus and started preparing for another year only to be left unsure if they were actually cleared to play. In some cases, players were even pulled from practice while compliance departments tried to sort out whether they could participate.
That’s where the confusion really sets in. The NCAA rolled out a new eligibility structure, left out the Class of 2022, got challenged in court, lost at the district level, appealed, and then saw that extra year paused on appeal. At the same time, individual players like Castellanos have gone to court on their own and won exemptions.
So one athlete can be eligible while another, in essentially the same position, cannot.
That’s the core problem. The NCAA has real roster-management concerns, and giving thousands of players another season would create headaches for everyone involved. But those concerns don’t erase the fact that the athletes are the ones dealing with the fallout from the rules.
There’s also a broader point here about structure. Eligibility rules do need limits. COVID years, redshirts, medical redshirts, pink shirts, and mental hardship waivers have all stretched college careers far beyond what used to be normal, with some athletes playing as many as 7 years.
The five-for-five model may end up being that limit.
But a rule doesn’t bring order if nobody knows who it actually covers. Right now, athletes are practicing without knowing whether they can play, and players like Castellanos have had to go to court just to use the eligibility year they were told they had.
Once again, the athletes are the ones left sorting it all out.
In Other News...
Florida State Already Faces Pressure To Hold Onto A Key Commit
Florida States recruiting picture took another hit with ZaKari Johnson, a four-star athlete in the 2027 class, appearing to reopen his recruitment while preparing to visit Texas A&M. Johnson had been committed to the Seminoles, and his profile as both a wide receiver and defensive back made him one of the more important early pledges in the cycle, especially for a program trying to keep its future class on steady ground.
Texas A&Ms push adds another layer of pressure for Florida State at a time when uncertainty around the coaching situation and financial limitations is already making the Seminoles work harder to protect their commitments. The Aggies have the kind of resources that can make a recruiting battle difficult to win, and if Florida States situation shifts again, the concern is not just losing Johnson but watching other young targets start to look elsewhere too. [Read more 🡒]
FSU Running Backs Think Last Week Was Only The Beginning
Sam Singleton Jr. drew some well-earned praise this week from running backs coach Kam Martin, who liked what he saw out of the Florida State back in his recent performance. The message from Martin was not just about celebrating one good outing, though. It was about carrying that momentum forward and keeping the position group moving in the right direction as the Seminoles continue to sort out who can consistently handle meaningful touches.
There is still a clear edge to the way Martin is talking about the room, and that matters for a group trying to establish itself behind the scenes. Florida State has reasons to feel encouraged after Singletons surge, but the staff is also pushing for the kind of weekly growth that turns one promising performance into something more dependable. For a backfield still trying to prove its ceiling, the next step is the one that will tell the real story. [Read more 🡒]
FSUs Backfield Suddenly Looks Like A Real Early-Season Strength
Florida States backfield came out of the New Mexico State game looking a lot more stable than it did a few weeks ago, and Sam Singleton Jr. was a big reason why. In the 34-17 win, the senior produced 164 all-purpose yards and two touchdowns, then added ACC Receiver of the Week honors to a performance that showed how much the Seminoles can now lean on him in space and out of the backfield.
Running backs coach Kam Martin has been open about Singletons work ethic, even drawing a comparison to former UCF back R.J. Harvey, and the praise has not stopped there. Ousmane Kromah also singled out Singleton while pointing to the depth in the room, which is the kind of development Florida State has been waiting for as early-season roles start to sort themselves out. [Read more 🡒]